News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by sircastor on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @11:00PM (#39023107)
Some people think of the App Store as a bazaar that Apple runs on its property, and it’s a 15-30% charge to setup a tent and sell your wares. Others think of it as Apple’s general store where they carry your app as a product, and you pay 15-30% for a place on the shelf.

The concept that Kroger (for instance) has a monopoly of customers in its own store is ridiculous. There are other stores, and other bazaars.

What analogy would you use to describe this situation that clarifies your position?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by basch on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:36AM (#39023683)
Or that Apple APIs and SDKs are Apple writing at least half of everyone’s apps for them. They manufacture all the pieces, and people can arrange them differently. Playing Apple 30% is recognizing that a good chunk of the code running in any app is developed and maintained by Apple.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by guax on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:14AM (#39024318)
By imposition of the platform. If people could choose to use apples SDK for 30% or react native 3000 revenge of the javascript for free, they would not bat an eye and go for the latter.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dwaite on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:59AM (#39025174)
React Native is a (sophisticated) Javascript wrapper around Apple's platform.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:15AM (#39024334)
So I guess you support browser makers taking a 30% cut, too?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by int_19h on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:21PM (#39032144)
That's what the cost of the dev license is supposed to be paying for.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by infotainment on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @11:24PM (#39023279)
Not OP, but sticking with your store analogies, I would use the following:

Apple represents the town government, and the App Store is the only general store in the entire town; other stores have been banned. Don't like it? You're free to pack up and move to another city!

The reason I'd characterize it this way is that changing phone platforms is nontrivial. It's not as simple as just going to another store that day.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by riscy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:27AM (#39023630)
> The reason I'd characterize it this way is that changing phone platforms is nontrivial.

I'm sorry, but how is it "nontrivial" to change phone platforms? Google says it's easy and all you need is a cable to get the best experience: https://www.android.com/switch-to-android/

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kelnos on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:56AM (#39024665)
Maybe it's "easy", but it's a lossy process. You lose all your purchased iOS apps, and have to manually buy the same apps (assuming they're available) on Android. If you watch the "See the steps" video, the fine print notes that Google can only "transfer" free apps that have direct equivalents (that is, released by the same developer) on the Play Store.

Your iMessage history disappears; Google can't transfer that to your Android phone. They claim to be able to transfer SMS/MMS history, which surprises me: I'm not sure how they accomplish that. I'm sure there's a ton of other user data that they also can't transfer. (Speaking of iMessage, any group chats you were in are now broken.)

Google of course has an interest in telling people that switching is easy and painless. It's not, though.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by riscy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:54AM (#39025134)
I agree it’s lossy in some way. Most of the popular apps with purchases are tied to a login, so there’s a step of logging in again but the app is free to download.

Everything else you mention is part of the nature of changing operating systems: software incompatibility / unavailability. That never has and unfortunately never will be solved. It’s hard enough to keep old software working on new releases of the same OS.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by int_19h on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:20PM (#39032135)
But that's the point - it's not like, say, switching to a different car make. It is, indeed, non-trivial to switch phone platforms. So why shouldn't we recognize this fact and hold the companies in the market to a different standard?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by riscy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:50PM (#39034712)
It's "non-trivial" to switch to driving a 18-wheeler truck, or stick-shift transmission, or that funky wheel thing in Teslas, which don't support the same software that other car infotainment systems do.

You can't force everything to be uniform and support all of the same features to make switching between manufacturers of a product-class "trivial". How's that part of a healthy free market? Requirements to that effect kills all creativity and specialization of products for different purposes. Android and iOS are different and that's a good thing!

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by int_19h on Saturday January 20, 2024 @06:12PM (#39073491)
Apple collecting 30% off all purchases is not a feature, and being prevented from doing that does not make it impossible for them to differentiate otherwise.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by blasphemers on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:08AM (#39029585)
Don't forget that getting Apple to stop intercepting your text messages is always a problem. I know a bunch of people who decided to try and switch to android, but they weren't getting their text messages and just went back to an iphone inside of a week.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:32AM (#39023661)
Do you believe them?

You shouldn't. It's a marketing page.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by riscy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:54AM (#39023783)
No it's not. Did you even read it? There's a big button that says "Read the guide" that keeps you on the page and tells you what to do. The FAQ even links to this: https://support.google.com/android/answer/6193424?visit_id=6...
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:30PM (#39032264)
Do you believe them?

This argument doesn't work if you don't believe the part about getting all the same apps, which is objectively not true.

It's a fun way to mock google, but it has nothing to do with the merits of this issue with apple.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Sargos on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:28AM (#39023641)
Apple's App Store is more akin to a Company Store[1] where you live in a town owned by the company you are utilizing for your lifestyle and their store is the only place you have available to shop. It was a scandal in the past as it's unfair to consumers while also being unfair to producers. The argument of "well you can just move/buy a different phone" did not hold up very well with society.

This unethical model is not any better in our modern world.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_store

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by paholg on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:21AM (#39023595)
How about if you go to purchase a house, but one of the HoA agreements is that you only shop at Kroger.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by pathartl on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:30AM (#39023652)
And the only roads in and out of your neighborhood leads directly to a Kroger. And there's barbed wire fencing surrounding your neighborhood. Meanwhile, deliveries being made to Kroger from distributors may only use Kroger-branded trucks, which cost at least 20% more. Oh, and that truck may only be serviced by Kroger-approved mechanics. Those mechanics can only buy parts from Kroger. Any totaled truck can't be parted out by mechanics and MUST be recertified by Kroger.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by insane_dreamer on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:57PM (#39036013)
basically this is what Walmart did to countless towns in the US by putting all the mom and pop stores out of business

not saying it's good (in fact, it's much worse than what Apple is doing), but no one contested its legality

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by knubie on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @11:20PM (#39023251)
I think a better analogy would be something like installing aftermarket parts for for your vehicle.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by buffington on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:15AM (#39023566)
Could you actually describe this? How would that be a better analogy?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by knubie on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:38AM (#39024522)
The iPhone is like a vehicle (car, motorcycle, John Deere tractor, etc). iPhone apps are like after market vehicle parts.

As a vehicle owner I'd like to be able to have a choice whether I want to install OEM parts or after market parts. The after market parts might be cheaper, or have features that the OEM parts lack. I would like to be able to purchase these parts without a 30% markup that goes to the car manufacturer.

As an iPhone user, I'd like to be able to install apps on my iPhone without having to pay the iPhone manufacturer a 30% markup.

I realize that this analogy doesn't directly address the issue of whether Apple has a monopoly on the market of iPhone apps, but it's how I think about it as a consumer.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:47AM (#39023746)
> The concept that Kroger (for instance) has a monopoly of customers in its own store is ridiculous. There are other stores, and other bazaars.

I'm not making the argument from a legal perspective, but from a reality perspective, I think that's a very poor analogy to the way operating systems (and "platforms" generally) work.

The very nature of operating systems is that they have much more control than a simple store. For example, if you want to switch from Kroger to Safeway, just go to Safeway. There are almost zero switching costs. I actually was strongly considering switching from Android to iPhone solely to get iMessage access (that's a whole different ball of Apple anti-competitiveness, but I digress...) But in the end, even after buying the iPhone, I decided to give it away as a Christmas gift because I just couldn't stomach how painful switching would be after a decade-plus history on Android: I'd lose all my Android apps, I'd lose all the easiest access to things that live in Google's ecosystem, I'd lose my day-to-day familiarity with my phone, etc. To be clear, I'm not saying that's impossible, but it's just a much higher burden that deciding to go to a different grocery store.

Note the government has often developed special laws for "platform businesses", for example railroads, telecoms, etc., understanding the unique positions these companies are in when it comes to controlling the larger economy. I wish they would regulate operating system platforms in a similar manner.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Mutjake on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:20AM (#39026718)
I like to think this via car analogy: you have similar ecosystem with car infotainment system platforms, but there the cost of switching is often minimum tenfold. Game consoles are an analogous platform to phones with similar pricepoint in switching costs. Of course phones are much more present in our daily lives for the most part of the population. But I suppose the similar burden would easily hit those platforms if legislation would be imposed, and it would come with both upsides and downsides depending on one's viewpoint.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by insane_dreamer on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:54PM (#39035986)
> it's just a much higher burden that deciding to go to a different grocery store

That very much depends on how much you're invested in a particular platform.

Using the store analogy, if you decide not to shop at Walmart anymore because you detest their policies, and the closest store that carries the products you're used to getting is 20 minutes away, or maybe you now have to go to multiple different stores to get everything you need, making an extra 50 minutes of driving, that's a considerable burden of switching as each time you make your purchases (plus pay higher prices).

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kelnos on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:49AM (#39024599)
That analogy doesn't work, unless Kroger is the only grocery store that's permitted to exist.

There are no other stores, or other bazaars. If you want to sell an iOS app, your only option is the Apple App Store.

Apparently the courts don't believe this is a monopoly, presumably because you can also choose to toss your iPhone and buy an Android phone instead. I disagree with that reasoning; to me that's like if Whole Foods also exists in addition to Kroger, but if you want to switch to Whole Foods, you have to get an expensive operation to swap out your stomach, because the groceries at Whole Foods don't work with the stomach that works with the groceries at Kroger.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dwaite on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:58AM (#39025170)
> Apparently the courts don't believe this is a monopoly, presumably because you can also choose to toss your iPhone and buy an Android phone instead.

You also have the entire internet, no tossing required.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by politician on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:10PM (#39031277)
Using Kroger as an example is interesting because, there is, in fact, a currently ongoing review of M&A activity in the grocery store business to prevent situations that harm customers.

[1] https://www.npr.org/2024/01/15/1224401179/kroger-albertsons-...