Overhype within Rust community is a sign of fear among the community that some simple language (may be zig, nim or something new) might come and pull the rug under their feet. Given it compromise on simplicity in favour of quashing memory safety bugs.
One reason rewrite in Rust is popular because its easier to copy something already done vs doing something original (one recent example came to mind is rewriting gnu coreutils in Rust).
I think this is ( or should have been ) obvious but also an interesting observation. At least it never came across my mind. The Hype driven feedback loop that generate a positive ( so to speak ) hype cycle.
The Rust community has definitely toned down a lot of their evangelism in the past 2 years. After obviously enough people came out to say enough is enough. But the third party continue the trend regardless.
Which is exactly what he did, in addition to also acknowledging the pattern of the Rust community using hype to attract attention. He didn't force anything onto anyone, he just expressed his opinion.
But I don't think I've ever seen any other community (except C++, 20 years ago, perhaps?) being so vocal about wanting to rewrite the whole software ecosystem in their language. "Rewrite it in Rust" is basically a catchphrase now.
cough NodeJS cough
I remember web browsers written in Perl.
We live in a world where everything is being rewritten in JavaScript.
etc.
It turns out that Rust is compelling enough that it makes sense to investigate porting lots of things to it. I don't think anybody knows for sure exactly for which projects Rust is better than C (or C++), but I know that Google has ported many fundamental C++ projects to Rust and they're happy enough that they're continuing this trend.
Fun fact, the kernel patchset to do this was recently resurrected https://lore.kernel.org/lkml/3465e0c6-f5b2-4c42-95eb-2936148...
We'll see!
That said, I also think that we live in a world where a little bit of clickbait or hype-riding is admissible. The economics of the thing make it almost mandatory. I would just acknowledge the hype, nod in disagreement, and move on. At the end o the day this is about someone tinkering with a language they enjoy. Let them have that.