News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by rglullis on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @09:59AM (#39013943)
So is Storj and Sia.

It raises the question, though: I can pay Storj S3 with STORJ tokens, and I can also pay for renterd space with Sia tokens, and I can also pay for IPFS with Filecoin, and all of them still work with good old credit cards. What "intrinsic" value is there for any of these tokens, if they can only be used on their own internal economies?

And before the "but permissionless, so I can pay with crypto!", why not just use DAI?

Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by buildbuildbuild on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @10:19AM (#39014197)
I’ve earned Storj for years by renting excess hard drive space to store other people’s files. Having a native currency lets you innovate in some unique ways.

Microtransactions are not practical with credit cards and other traditional settlement methods.

The reasons not to use something like DAI are fundraising (unfortunately - crypto VCs really like seeing a token), network bloat/decentralization, and leadership risk. Your own currency is less likely to collapse by other people’s bad decisions.

Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by rglullis on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @11:00AM (#39014838)
I also run my own Storj node. It took at least one year to pay back the hard drive. Now that they are cutting down the payout for hosting, I am receiving barely enough to justify the power bill.

No one cares about microtransactions, and I'm yet to see a customer who likes a product or service but refuses to make a pre-payment of $10.

None of the reasons you mentioned for a token are beneficial to the end user.

Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @02:07PM (#39017453)
How much is the power bill, and how many watts are you using?

Barely paying for power does sound like too little, but enough money to pay back hardware cost in a year is definitely overkill.

Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by rglullis on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @02:45PM (#39018055)
I went to look, and I was wrong on both extremes. I've allocated 2TB. It actually took me two years to get make ~$125, when I bought disks at ~$60/TB.

For the past 6 months, I've received an average of 5.8 STORJ per month, which on today's rate amount to $4/month, but if I look at the price at the time I received them it would be more like $2.2/month.

I don't know the exact wattage, but given that is a oldish celeron and that I'm based in Germany, I'm guessing that running that server + disks takes ~25W, which means ~18kWh per month and given how energy prices have gone up last year (close to 0.30€ per kWh), I am actually losing money by keeping this server on.

Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @03:10PM (#39018418)
Okay, so you're in an especially bad situation for terabytes per watt.

If I was buying hard drives right now, I'd expect 2x14TB for about $500 including tax. If that pulled in anything close to $2/TB/month then $6 of electricity would not be a big deal.

Hmm, I just built a NAS, maybe I should rent out some of that space.

Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by robertlagrant on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @11:05AM (#39014900)
> I’ve earned Storj for years

That makes sense, but then what can you do with Storj?

Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @02:01PM (#39017346)
You can turn it back into storage, and you can sell it to people that want storage. I feel like that's good enough to establish value.
Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by robertlagrant on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @03:49PM (#39018932)
But is there any other value than storage? If I have excess storage to rent to people, I get coins I can use to rent storage?
Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @04:22PM (#39019335)
You can sell it for cash money.

The important thing is not that coins can be exchanged for a product or service that you want, it's that they can be exchanged for a product or service that many people want. And you want that trade to be the basis of the price, rather than speculation.

Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by rglullis on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @04:51PM (#39019646)
I'm all for Storj (or Sia, or Filecoin) managing to create an alternative to AWS/GCP/Azure, but even if they succeed, they are never going to be able to make their system operate at a lower cost of the existing commodity.

I recently set up a Minio cluster with 80TB (usable, 120TB total) for ~150€/month. Storj is cheap (~3.5€/TB/month), but there is no way that Storj can ever be that cheap. And we are not even talking about egress fees.

It's difficult for them to see them truly disrupting the market when their systems have by design so much overhead and middleman wanting a cut. The moment that this model starts to become a threat to the big cloud providers, they will slash their prices and then any advantage will be gone.

The best I see for these decentralized storage systems is to work as a tit-for-tat backup, maybe?

Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @05:01PM (#39019759)
Most people don't want to make their own clusters, or don't have enough data for it to be a good price. There's plenty of room for a service that's twice as expensive as commodity prices.

> The moment that this model starts to become a threat to the big cloud providers, they will slash their prices

I doubt it's ever going to be a big threat, since this kind of storage is never going to have great latency. I don't think that's an existential risk. Though even if it is, and happens, there's billions of dollars to make before we reach that point. It's not a reason to avoid the market.

Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by rglullis on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @06:46PM (#39020852)
> Most people don't want to make their own clusters, or don't have enough data for it to be a good price.

Yeah, these people will pay for iCloud, Google Drive, Dropbox... Or maybe if they are a bit more technical they will look into Backblaze B2.

> there's billions of dollars to make before we reach that point. It's not a reason to avoid the market.

I want to agree with you, but honestly this feels more like a situation where all the players will be investing a bunch of time and money in the hopes of becoming a winner and they will all end up finding an ever shrinking spread.

To illustrate the point, all these projects raised already billions of dollars, but there is a very low chance that any of them will ever recoup that money. It's not a problem for them because they are all playing with someone else's money, but globally this has been nothing but a waste of time and resources.

Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by treyd on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @10:52AM (#39014708)
Afaik there was some work to make it possible to pay for Sia storage in the new renterd node with any crypto asset you could make a payment channel with (so, most of them including Dai), but I don't see that in the readme anymore: https://github.com/SiaFoundation/renterd
Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by iSnow on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @10:36AM (#39014445)
I guess if you are inside the crypto ecosystem, it's easier to pay nodes via tokens.
Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by rglullis on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @11:05AM (#39014890)
It's not. They pay out via zksync (layer 2 system) to avoid fees, but they only accept payment in the main chain.

So if you want to cash out or use the tokens you receive, you need to eat the fees. It's ridiculous and a clear mechanism for them to restrict the circulating supply.

Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by hanniabu on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @12:27PM (#39015990)
It's an evolving ecosystem. Rollups are fairly new so imagine fully migrating to L2 is a work in progress.
Re:Filecoin Foundation Successfully Deploys IPFS in Space by rglullis on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @01:19PM (#39016616)
What I mean is that they could do things on their business side, off-chain, completely independent from the "protocol" or smart contracts. If they already accept use a "traditional" payment processor to accept credit cards, why could't they add zksync as an option for payment on Tardigrade?

It's really not hard - I've done a PoC when I was working on https://hub20.io - but it doesn't help with their "tokenonomics", so they just ignore it.