News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by dclowd9901 on Friday April 27, 2012 @12:39PM (#3899860)
As someone sitting idly in a rather crowded Sunnyvale hotel lobby awaiting my own interview, I'm prepared for a Bob, but I'm afraid I'll get a Ted.

I'm not a formally schooled developer. I don't know a heap about traditional computer science. I don't know all the sorting algorithms off hand (but could throw one together with a little time and reference). I'm not even fluent in all the jargon, vernacular and glossary terms that devs bat around.

I don't know if I'm the best for this job, but I know only 3 short years ago, I was doing graphic design and 3 years before that, I was trying to make good on my degree (and dream) of journalism.

None of us choose how we learn, but I think the best of us just know how to.

Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by qdog on Friday April 27, 2012 @01:08PM (#3900032)
Had a random interview scheduled with Amazon a couple weeks ago when they were in town, they didn't even have regular whiteboards because of some mixup. So, they put these pieces of plastic on the windows that was adhesive on one side, worst whiteboarding experience so far. I couldn't concentrate because of all the crap going on outside, poor interviewer probably wondered how I tied my shoes in the morning.

Hope you have better luck ;)

Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by sethg on Friday April 27, 2012 @02:43PM (#3900522)
I was in one interview at a local startup where there was a whiteboard in the room, but none of the engineers who interviewed me asked me to touch it; they were satisfied to ask questions of the form “what do you know about Java Foobar Technologies?” After an hour or two, I could feel the whiteboard... looming... blank... silently warning me not to take this job.
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by acheron on Friday April 27, 2012 @09:08PM (#3901688)
Wait, so you got an interview that dispensed with the whiteboard BS.. and you thought that was a bad thing?
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by sanderjd on Friday April 27, 2012 @11:47PM (#3901967)
There is no silver bullet. I see a sort of taxonomy of techniques, the relative quality of which is very dependent on the person interviewing.

An assumption: it is bad for the prospective employer to see no code at all.

I see two basic options:

1) see code written before the interview, and

2) see code written during the interview.

Option (1) has a few sub-options:

a) look at open source work,

b) ask for private personal work to be made available, and

c) ask for custom work of your choosing.

All of these share the weakness of requiring work outside work hours. There are many qualified candidates who don't have work of the (a) and (b) sort available, and while many see option (c) as a welcome intellectual challenge, many others see it as a tedious (or even offensive) waste of their time.

Option (2) also has a few sub-options:

a) provide a computer and a project or set of coding questions to be solved in your absence,

b) same as (a) but with pen and paper,

c) ask a question and watch on a projector or over the shoulder as it is solved on a computer,

d) same as (c) but with pen and paper, and

e) same as (d) but on a whiteboard.

Option (a) is basically the same as (1c) above, but attempts to mitigate the waste-of-time factor by using already-committed interview time to do it, and option (b) is just a much worse variant of the same. The weakness of these options is that it is impossible to get an idea of a candidate's thought process while solving the problem. Option (c) is really good for interviewers but very high-pressure, which selects against many qualified candidates. Option (d) and (e) are identical, but some people hate pen and paper, others hate whiteboards, and most hate both! It is imperative when not using a computer to avoid requiring or judging by the use of things that computers help support, like specific languages, specific APIs, or syntactic accuracy.

Or is this all wrong - have you found the general solution?

Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by zheng on Friday April 27, 2012 @11:47PM (#3901968)
Thinking that all interviews which use some form of whiteboard BS are bad is just as much a cargo cult idea as the use of whiteboards.
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by mikeash on Saturday April 28, 2012 @01:23PM (#3903466)
Personally I don't think that using a whiteboard necessarily means "whiteboard BS". There are good and bad ways to do it. Getting nitpicky over syntax and expecting the candidate to have everything memorized makes for whiteboard BS. Concentrating on overall structure and approach and expecting reasonable questions from the candidate makes for a good whiteboard experience.
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by blhack on Friday April 27, 2012 @01:11PM (#3900054)
Don't worry, you'll be fine :)

Can you write code? Yes? Well then you probably can fit the role of somebody who is hired to write code.

Nobody on the planet is expecting you to waltz in the first day and grok their entire stack and their entire codebase; expect the first couple of months to be just you getting your head around what you'll eventually be doing.

Don't sweat it, you'll be fine :)

Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by slurgfest on Friday April 27, 2012 @01:55PM (#3900271)
This isn't correct in my experience. Interviewers do typically insist on more than simply being able to write code and it is common for them to try to hire someone who groks as much of their stack and codebase as possible from day one.

edit: but maybe it is not the same in Silicon Valley?

Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by rhizome on Friday April 27, 2012 @04:12PM (#3900833)
Among CS-led technical departments, this does tend to hold in my experience. Like seeks like, and as much lip service is paid to meritocracy the language and motivations of the industry are largely driven by those who have paid their dues to the ivory tower.
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by srdev on Friday April 27, 2012 @02:46PM (#3900532)
I don't know how it is with most interviewers, but for interviews that I do: If you don't know a term, just ask. I'm more interested in whether you're familiar with the concept and can apply it than whether you know the appropriate term. Chances are that you're familiar with the concept already and are just not familiar with the name.

If you're in the interview room, I'm not so concerned about book learning and knowing facts, but whether you have the correct amount of knowledge to do the job and the ability to apply it.

Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by thebigshane on Saturday April 28, 2012 @12:26AM (#3902038)

  You can know the name of a bird in all the languages of 
  the world, but when you're finished, you'll know 
  absolutely nothing whatever about the bird... So let's 
  look at the bird and see what it's doing — that's what 
  counts. I learned very early the difference between 
  knowing the name of something and knowing something.
- Richard Feynman https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Richard_Feynman and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=05WS0WN7zMQ
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by robyn on Friday April 27, 2012 @06:45PM (#3901360)
The best piece of technical interview advice I've ever gotten: It's much more impressive to NOT know something, ask about it, and then be able to understand it and apply it to your answer during the course of the interview, than it is to just already know it.
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by daleharvey on Friday April 27, 2012 @10:24PM (#3901821)
agreed, a few weeks ago I was interviewing and the interviewer schooled me on python generators and cooperative threading (pretty much all my knowledge is around erlang and message passing / explicit threading)

I got the job, and learned something along the way

Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by TimGebhardt on Friday April 27, 2012 @01:54PM (#3900265)
> I'm not a formally schooled developer. I don't know a <strong>heap</strong> about traditional computer science.

Well you sure do talk the talk. ;)

Ba-dum---Crash!

Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by dclowd9901 on Friday April 27, 2012 @02:24PM (#3900404)
;) As I wrote it, I was tempted to kick myself.
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by cannuk on Friday April 27, 2012 @02:34PM (#3900476)
See you do know the venacular
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by seldo on Friday April 27, 2012 @01:25PM (#3900123)
I agree with the others: you'll be fine. And if not, feel free to apply to our company :-)
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by nickbauman on Friday April 27, 2012 @06:05PM (#3901223)
The symbol of the thing is not the thing: people (should) care about the thing. You don't need a degree to get your head around algorithms. If you can write a simple binary search, for example (arguably the most fundamental algorithm), that's a plus. Therefore a good interviewer will get you to write binary search (the thing) on a whiteboard without saying "binary search" (the symbol of the thing) and see if you can reason your way through it. They will be much more interested in your thought process than whether your syntax is correct.
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by RedwoodCity on Friday April 27, 2012 @04:21PM (#3900862)
If they don't hire you because you don't know the most recent buzz words you probably don't want to work for them. A good job especially in your cases is one where you will learn and feel challenged. If you really knew everything they wanted the job would get boring.
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by richardlblair on Friday April 27, 2012 @12:50PM (#3899927)
Good luck! I hope you end up with a Bob over a Ted.
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by wunderland on Friday April 27, 2012 @12:55PM (#3899963)
This story was poorly written. I had to re-read it a few times just to understand who was speaking when.
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by moomin on Friday April 27, 2012 @01:26PM (#3900130)
Personally, I'd kill to be able to write this badly. Not a human you understand, but something. Maybe a bush-fly.
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by WiseWeasel on Friday April 27, 2012 @02:46PM (#3900534)
I'd hunt down a whole family of bush-flies, and those buggers are prolific!
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by albertsun on Friday April 27, 2012 @04:46PM (#3900975)
Hey! If it doesn't go well or you change your mind you can always come back to journalism now. We are all desperate for people who can write good code and most of us aren't formally schooled either.
Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by horsehead on Friday April 27, 2012 @01:30PM (#3900146)
These are the same things I worry about in learning to code on my own -- Will I know the "right" terminology to "prove" to an interviewer I'm capable of doing X task in Y time?

A funny coincidence, i did journalism too -- you're not missing out on ANYTHING (I'm trying to escape the career myself, even contemplating school).

Re:Cargo Cults and Interview Questions by xsmasher on Saturday April 28, 2012 @03:09PM (#3903756)
That's part of the benefit of a CS degree - you get a common vocabulary for common problems and techniques.