Right. Sure. 2001 Tundra V8 owner here, and you're just flat out wrong.
Maybe you've had uniquely bad judgement in the vehicles you've acquired over the last 30 years. It happens.
That's not even considered a "car".
So you're both right, but it didn't need to be that way. The manufacturers have royally screwed up the direction in which the industry has gone.
And you say features are being added because the general population wants them. I'll revert to my go-to argument here. The general population want McDonald's too.
That's what I'm paying for. Sure I can't fix it myself but that's not the point.
The car was hit while parked in its first few months and I was very scared that the repair wouldn't be good but turns out the body shop knew what it was doing and did everything correctly putting it back together like new. Insurance was billed about 6k since there were hundreds of parts that needed to be replaced. Do I even want to learn how to do all that myself? Nope.
Cars are a utility for most people.
What about safety of people outside the cars? By this metric I believe they are getting worse.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/191216/reported-motor-ve...
Yes, modern cars are more comfortable, easier to use, and safer. I don't agree that they are more reliable since fixability is a factor in reliability.
The author listed a bunch of ways that they are not. Perhaps it would be more interesting to address those directly
To a degree, yes, but auto manufacturers are all too willing to make self-servicing difficult. They only make money when you buy a new car after all. We also see this with, well, almost every other field.
> they are being added because the general population wants them.
Much like phones with unremovable batteries leading to slimmer devices, I can only imagine this is a product of marketing convincing consumers of their desires, rather than them actually requesting all of that. It doesn’t even really make sense; why would the consumer want all of that when they’re not even using it the vast majority of the time in the vehicle?
I really don't get this - just put a space in the dash where I can stick a phone that charges it and connects to the car audio. I have an old GM car with Carplay that all still works pretty well, but it's basically just a second screen for my phone and as such I barely use it.
This tells me that his level of understanding of the wide range of cars and features. Are their bad cars and bad UIs, yes.
However, as someone who has been driving for 30 years, cars are better in every way now than they were before (From a driving, efficiency, reliability and safety perspective).
The only thing that is arguably "worse" is self servicability. However this is a function of complexity that exists throughout all technology.
Also, these features that everyone on HN complains about.. they are being added because the general population wants them. There are very few people who would buy a car without any screens, ui or infotainment. You wouldn't save any money because a lot of this tech is required for saftey and would be bespoke thus costing more.