It's like when someone really likes reddit. Okay, it's not HN. They can tell a complicated story about how they like cats and populist rage politics, but it's a hard negative signal to get past.
I see the parallel but your signalling system is rather poor if it penalizes someone for liking reddit.
Stanford definitely has leg up in terms of Startups. Especially the dot com era. At Cal we don't have equivalent of Google or Yahoo. However, Startups are just one dimension of innovation in technology. Berkeley can easily boast some of the groundbreaking research (not just engineering but overall sciences) during last 100 years.
Disclosure: UC Berkeley Alum here.
I've heard one joke on Cal's campus - "Stanford creates companies, Cal creates industries".
The Stanford equivalent is "Stanford produces CEOs, Berkeley produces VP-Engr".
Which one would trade places with the other?
I agree that YCombinator is head and shoulders above its competitors but is Stanford really considered that much better than Berkeley? Honest question.