News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by jltsiren on Thursday January 11, 2024 @03:20PM (#38958401)
The world is very small, and it can't support that many companies making passenger aircraft. If you want aircraft of that size, you have to buy Boeing or Airbus. Both are sold out until the 2030s. And if you are already operating Boeing aircraft, it's more cost-effective to buy more of them instead of switching to Airbus.

China spent ~15 years developing the C919, and it's finally entering mass production. But it also appears to be sold out until the 2030s.

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by stcredzero on Thursday January 11, 2024 @03:33PM (#38958588)
The world is very small, and it can't support that many companies making passenger aircraft. If you want aircraft of that size, you have to buy Boeing or Airbus. Both are sold out until the 2030s.

There's an apparent contradiction here.

China spent ~15 years developing the C919, and it's finally entering mass production. But it also appears to be sold out until the 2030s.

And here.

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by jltsiren on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:24PM (#38959303)
While there is a growing demand for passenger aircraft, the fixed costs of getting into the business are so high that the market cannot support that many manufacturers. Not on a commercial basis, anyway.

Airbus and Boeing are commercially viable, and they have customers all around the world. Comac is more of a political project, as China tries to reduce their dependence on Western technology. There are 1000+ orders for the C919, but effectively all of them are Chinese.

Similarly, the USSR had domestic passenger aircraft industry, and Russia retains some capability to manufacture them. Their latest model is the Irkut MC-21, which has a few hundred orders. Again, effectively all of the orders are Russian.

Then there is Embraer, which is the biggest manufacturer of regional jets. They have been decades in the business, but they have not made any attempt to build a competitor for the A320 and B737.

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by rootusrootus on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:31PM (#38962343)
Up until recently there was also Bombardier, but it seems like they basically bankrupted themselves and ceded all of their commercial plane production to Airbus. Now they just do business jets.
Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by lmm on Thursday January 11, 2024 @09:10PM (#38962705)
They didn't bankrupt themselves, the US government (at Boeing's urging) bankrupted them.
Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by Animats on Thursday January 11, 2024 @07:14PM (#38961643)
Airbus was a political project. It took them over 20 years before they produced anything good. But then they got it right.
Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by ahartmetz on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:47AM (#38966995)
In fact, their first product, the A300, was a technological milestone, and sold 561 after initial difficulties. The A310 had more industry firsts. The next product, the A320, was again a technological milestone. That was 16 years after the A300 release and indeed about 20 years after the start of the program - but by no means the first good product from Airbus.

Back to topic, Comac is not starting with a bang like Airbus did - but they don't have to. Same quality, slightly different, slightly cheaper could work after reaching governement-aided critical mass. Such government aid got Airbus started and notably did not cripple it.

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by mcv on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:54PM (#38959781)
But why are they not also getting into the 737-size market, if that's such a huge market? If even the questionable 737 MAX is sold out for decades, that sounds like a pretty lucrative market to be in. It sounds to me like if you build something that works, you will sell as many as you can build.
Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by SpecialistK on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:24PM (#38961038)
One chilling effect was what Boeing and the US gov't did when Bombardier in Canada developed their own 100-130 seat brand new ("clean sheet") aircraft. They levied so many tariffs that the project was economically unviable.

So Bombardier sold it all to Airbus. Now Airbus has two series of single-aisle aircraft that are more competitive than Boeing's 737 (the A220 and A320.)

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by Log_out_ on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:34AM (#38965969)
One can imagine how bad things must be behind the scenes if with that level of protectionism and political security deals backing the planes are grounded constantly. In working capitalism it's not the csuits that decide to make a great product, it's the competitive situation that forces everyones hand. Imagine Boeing as a ussr state owned conglomerate, who's directors try to game the metrics of the boss for a promotion. And we all know how that journey ended.
Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by jltsiren on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:17PM (#38960155)
For the same reason Boeing developed the 737 MAX instead of a completely new model. The fixed costs are too high, the risks are too high, and the profit margins are too low. If it takes 10-15 years to develop a new plane, several years to ramp up production, and several years beyond that to break even, it does not make sense as a business. If you think it purely as an investment, there are always better uses for your money.
Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by kelnos on Friday January 12, 2024 @01:20AM (#38964620)
Wasn't a significant part of Boeing's decision to "recycle" the 737 time-to-market? Sure, they saved a bunch of money not designing a new plane, but they were also under heavy threat from the A320neo and needed to get something out there relatively quickly.
Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by solarkraft on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:47PM (#38961329)
> Airbus and Boeing are commercially viable, and they have customers all around the world. Comac is more of a political project

I thought Airbus was heavily subsidized

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by rtpg on Thursday January 11, 2024 @07:01PM (#38961494)
So is Boeing! Companies without this massive amount of government support either barely survive on a tiny niche or fall over before actually shipping products.

It's fine that governments have decided to prop up these industries in their own ways, of course. Just hard to expect "free market" participants to show up and take on such a capital intensive industry

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by yukkuri on Thursday January 11, 2024 @09:42PM (#38962982)
We should get these welfare queens off the dole!

Wait these are big corporations instead of struggling single mothers? Nevermind...

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by codethief on Thursday January 11, 2024 @07:05PM (#38961538)
As is Boeing.
Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by scythe on Thursday January 11, 2024 @10:05PM (#38963150)
>Their latest model is the Irkut MC-21, which has a few hundred orders. Again, effectively all of the orders are Russian.

It doesn't exactly help that nobody wants to work with Russia for reasons.

>They [Embraer, Brazil] have been decades in the business, but they have not made any attempt to build a competitor for the A320 and B737.

They are actively attempting precisely this:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embraer_E-Jet_E2_family

To contextualize, both Irkut, now called Yakovlev, and Embraer received massive support from their respective governments to get started.

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by klausa on Thursday January 11, 2024 @10:13PM (#38963206)
These are not in any way competitors to A320 and B737.

They are much smaller, with 2-2 seating, compared to 3-3 in the bigger jets. There are some routes and airlines where these are competitive; but they are not similar planes.

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by scythe on Thursday January 11, 2024 @11:39PM (#38963813)
Mea culpa. Mostly. I relied on Wikipedia's characterization of the E2 series as similar to the Bombardier CSeries which was the subject of the American tariffs you reference. But the CSeries in fact became the A220, significantly smaller than the A320, so neither would it have been in the same category as the 737.

Both the E2 195 and the CSeries are well above the threshold of 100 passengers that Wikipedia uses as the maximum for a "regional jet", with the former holding up to 146 passengers and the latter up to 160. However, this is well behind the 737 MAX at 220 passengers. This classification apparently varies by source; 49 USC 41714 considers the maximum to be 71 passengers, while some sources take a threshold as high as 150 seats.

In any case, Embraer has gradually ramped up the maximum seating capacity on its planes, though you correctly point out that it has yet to take the middle-seat plunge.

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by LudwigNagasena on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:22PM (#38962261)
China, a country with the biggest industrial GDP (ie not services or agriculture), spent 15 years on R&D to deliver so far only 4 airframes of an airliner that is technically behind comparable Boeing and Airbus airliners.

So not really a contradiction unless you are reading it too literally.

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by inferiorhuman on Thursday January 11, 2024 @10:01PM (#38963126)

  China spent ~15 years developing the C919, and it's finally entering
  mass production. But it also appears to be sold out until the 2030s.
ahahahahahahahahahahah

no.

Since 2022 Comac has delivered a grand total of four C919s. The only non-Chinese airline to order any is owned by a rich Chinese guy. The rest are Chinese airlines that have been browbeaten into ordering some. Nobody outside of China is in any rush to order a Comac anything because:

1.) Comac hasn't gotten any non-Chinese certification

2.) Comac's support infrastructure is even weaker than Sukhoi and Bombardier (both of whom struggled to sell and support their aircraft that were actually certified in the west).

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by missedthecue on Thursday January 11, 2024 @11:30PM (#38963752)
True on all counts but it probably won't be long until it sells well. The Chinese government is throwing a lot of money behind it and even if the US doesn't certify it for political reasons, there is a huge global market starving for fresh air frames.
Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by drtgh on Friday January 12, 2024 @07:31AM (#38967273)
I think would not be exactly political. The part where the plutocracy benefits the interests of a few pockets would certainly be political, but by other part, the major aircraft manufacturers in the EU and the UE, the duopoly, build civil aircraft as well as military ones.

As I understand it, to torpedo these companies by dumping prices would be to indirectly torpedo the EU's and the UE's defense aircraft production. A cost based production battle would be never won against China. And I guess many taxes would be earmarked to counteract this, again.

By other side, Chinese products' rampant lack of quality, and the incapacity for to produce enough aircrafts if they were contracted, in my guess would translate into the quick construction of factories with the worst production quality yet to be seen, for to feed the dumping.

The matter is, in such scenario we as consumers would be deeply affected, as civil aircraft manufacturing is already at the limit of what can be done without compromising safety (seriously, some managers should have been fired a few years ago, The aim should not be to imitate the lack-quality of the Chinese industry).

I don't want to think about what would happen if a race to cut manufacturing costs were endemically launched in the civil aircraft sector. As European I don't want to see it. If it were, lets say, the Japanese industry, the high quality one, not the one that is offshoring production to China, I wouldn't worry about it or comment on it.

This is mere guessing, I'm not in the sector (It would be interesting to find objective researches on this matter in fact).

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by missedthecue on Friday January 12, 2024 @09:57AM (#38968739)
Why do you assume out of hand they would be low quality? We see in other industries, such as the Chinese military industry, that they are capable of producing a lot of high quality air frames. Their stealth J-20 has never had an accident in the 13 years it's been flying and they are building 120 per year, and flying them tens of thousands of hours per year.

You can look at other models. Their Xian Y-20 freighter has also never had an accident and flies tens of thousands of hours per year.

This isn't 1992 anymore where the only things coming out of China are plastic molded injection crap.

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by drtgh on Friday January 12, 2024 @11:41AM (#38970284)
The military ones are Russian engineering assisted. The ones involved for airlines would be Comac C919 ( and progressively C929 and C939).

https://theaircurrent.com/china/china-eastern-comac-c919-ret...

> Launch airline China Eastern’s tentative February 28 entry-into-service date never materialized [..]

> After regularly operating as part of its route proving, the aircraft appeared to change tempo on February 2. The aircraft flew a half dozen more short flights before February 27 then sat for nearly a month before being ferried from Hongqiao to nearby Pudong on March 23 when it was last seen. There’s been no definitive explanation for the jet’s return to the manufacturer.

Apparently they didn't copied well the stolen designs from American and European manufacturers[1]. And they (China government) want EU approval for to use European citizens as alpha-testers.

About prices dumping that should be expected,

https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/china-eas...

> China Eastern Airlines (600115.SS) said on Thursday it will buy another 100 C919 airplanes in a deal worth $10 billion at list prices, in what would be the largest ever order for the jet made by the Commercial Aircraft Corporation of China (COMAC).

> The state-owned carrier said it had received a "substantial discount" for the deal and that the planes will be delivered in batches from 2024 to 2031. The list price for the C919 is $99 million but aircraft can be sold at discounts of up to 50%, especially for new models.

50% of the EU and the UE aircraft prices. It should be expected prices dumping, the same that happened when Hawuei and ZTE was subsidizing antennas and selling equipment at lower prices than manufacturing costs in the European Union.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comac_C919#US_espionage_allega...

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by missedthecue on Friday January 12, 2024 @02:44PM (#38972959)
The J-20 and Y-20 have absolutely zero russian input.
Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by inferiorhuman on Friday January 12, 2024 @11:20PM (#38977304)
Aside from the engines.
Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by missedthecue on Saturday January 13, 2024 @12:16PM (#38982037)
J-20 is now powered by Chinese WS-15.

Y-20 is now powered by Chinese WS-20.

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by drtgh on Sunday January 14, 2024 @02:16PM (#38993465)
the the rumors say J-20 Russian MiG based design, Y-20 North-American based designs,

from whom have designs been stolen this time?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xi%27an_Y-20#Controversy

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by inferiorhuman on Friday January 12, 2024 @11:03PM (#38977234)

  Why do you assume out of hand they would be low quality?
The short answer? Peers and past performance as a predictor of the future. Transport aircraft are way more complex and held to higher standards than military aircraft. Or look at where the SSJ100, SpaceJet, ARJ-21 and C919 are today. COMAC's delivered four C919s in three years and has yet to get EASA or FAA certification. Most of the C919 orders are from big Chinese banks or leasing companies with no clear interest from airlines (domestic or foreign).