But there are now several serious safety issues. The 2 crashes killing hundreds in 2018. The quality issues with the manufacturing of the pressure bulkheads with "snowman" holes thst had to be fixed or the rudder bolts that thst hold the assembly to the fuselage that an employee noticed that weren't the same as the spec drawings?
There are probably more cases...
With the multiplication of these problems. It's obviously a systemic issue and a corporate culture that doesn't put as much importance on safety.
Ho and there's this one where Boeing is asking the FAA for a safety exemption so they can ship planes faster while they try and fix the problem...
https://fortune.com/2024/01/06/boeing-737-max-safety-exempti...
https://simpleflying.com/boeing-737-max-10-certification-fli...
That's the real counterfactual here. Would Boeing have iterated yet again on the 737, or would they have done a clean sheet design instead?
Boeing said at the time the changes would improve quality.
https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/boein...
https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/boein...
https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/boeing-fifth-estate-costs-s...
And that space capsule, Starliner, was contracted in 2011 and has yet to be safe enough to carry humans. Meanwhile in the same time, the upstart competition has gone from zero to flying some 11 crewed missions (not all were to ISS) and charged the government much less than Boeing charged, and that despite Boeing's storied 100 year aerospace history and culture.
It’s more like non-engineering culture resulted in a push to create a new plane as quickly and cheaply as possible. In other words, the execs at the start of the process created an impossible task that the downstream employees couldn’t follow through on. In this sense, it is consistent that under “normal” conditions, Boeing could still produce a good plane; the problem is that nobody wants to or is able to enforce those conditions.
I’m curious - how much of it is true? Is it really systemic, or has it manifested only with one specific model plane?
It seems to fit very well with the “financialization is bad” narrative, too, but is there any other data to support the claims?
It’s possible that engineer-driven Boeing could have fucked up the Max, too.
I am skeptical of simple, tidy explanations regarding actions and arcs of any organizations as large as Boeing.