News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How I attacked myself using Google and I ramped up a $100... by sp332 on Wednesday April 25, 2012 @05:42PM (#3891257)
It's not a DDOS becuase it's not distributed and there was no denial of service. And it doesn't work "across the entire interwebs" because the Google bots are rate-limited against most websites. There are some whitelisted sites, like S3, that are not rate-limited. S3 did not go down in this "attack". In fact the app didn't even go down. So the decision not to rate-limit against S3 was sound, since there was no DDOS.
Re:How I attacked myself using Google and I ramped up a $100... by goblin89 on Wednesday April 25, 2012 @07:05PM (#3891567)
Ironically, it might be DoS in the sense that it drives app maintenance costs so high that the owner could decide to, naturally, deny the service (shut down).

Otherwise, maybe it's the new type of flood attack, cost-of-service (CoS), applicable against those who use ‘invincible’ cloud infrastructure such as Amazon's.

Re:How I attacked myself using Google and I ramped up a $100... by gizzlon on Thursday April 26, 2012 @03:32AM (#3892878)
Is that a term? "Cost of service attack" ? If not, let's coin it :)

Cost-of-service-attack: Consuming bandwidth or other resources in cloud based solutions to drive up the cost of running the service.

Very easy when the cost is so tightly coupled with the resource use...

Re:How I attacked myself using Google and I ramped up a $100... by ryantownsend on Thursday April 26, 2012 @05:53AM (#3893133)
I believe this kind of attack is already referred to as EDoS (Economic Denial of Service/Sustainability) - basically killing of a service through bankruptcy.

This is why most cloud services have a customisable limit on how many virtual servers can be booted automatically, a solution is yet to be found for protecting S3.

Re:How I attacked myself using Google and I ramped up a $100... by gizzlon on Thursday April 26, 2012 @07:03AM (#3893263)
Thanks..

"[snip]..one might envision that instead of worrying about a lack of resources, the elasticity of the cloud could actually provide a surplus of compute, network and storage utility that could be just as bad as a deficit"

http://rationalsecurity.typepad.com/blog/2009/01/a-couple-of...

Re:How I attacked myself using Google and I ramped up a $100... by goblin89 on Thursday April 26, 2012 @05:12AM (#3893043)
OK, so now we have DoS and CoS!

I dunno though, it's all technically bandwidth flood in the end. The consequences (or goals) of flood may include immediate or eventual denial of service, high cost of service, various security attacks, or probably all at once—further classification surely is complicated.

Meanwhile, both terms DoS and CoS are a bit vague, too. Say, turning off a server or forcing providers to alter their DNS records more or less qualifies as denial of service attack (which, by Wikipedia's definition, is “an attempt to make a computer or network resource unavailable to its intended users”).

Re:How I attacked myself using Google and I ramped up a $100... by gizzlon on Thursday April 26, 2012 @05:49AM (#3893120)
I wold argue that "DoS" is not vague, just a broad term.

Aanyway.. You're right, it boils down to bandwidth flood (or maybe CPU..) in the end.

Maybe CoS is not really a technical term, just made more relevant by the technological changes. OP would have been charged much less had he not been using "the cloud".

Lets say I have small'ish competitor hosting their app on EC2. Using classical DoS techniques, how much can I ramp up their bill before they notice? Or can actually stop it? What if I run it on a smaller scale, "just" doubling their bandwidth bill.. Will they notice? Maybe they'll believe it's extra users ;)

Re:How I attacked myself using Google and I ramped up a $100... by tuxguy on Thursday April 26, 2012 @04:30PM (#3895967)
Maybe Amazon should add smart log mining ?

If it requires a lot of effort to productize, Amazon could potentially offer it as a service $0.5/hr to ensure you are not making major goof ups.

Re:How I attacked myself using Google and I ramped up a $100... by eridius on Wednesday April 25, 2012 @06:59PM (#3891547)
Are you saying Google isn't distributed?

In any case, it may not be a denial-of-service, but if you can find someone with an S3 bucket with large files you could maliciously cause them to rack up a huge bandwidth bill using this mechanism. I guess you could say it's a DDOM (Distributed Denial of Money).

Re:How I attacked myself using Google and I ramped up a $100... by genu1 on Wednesday April 25, 2012 @08:19PM (#3891761)
lol I'll take DDOS any day over DDOM!!