I don't see why Google don't redownload them using If-Modified-Since, and reusing the original downloaded photos in the case that the origin server says they've not changed.
can't you also view a url as a password? (If only I know the url, then only I can download the file).
I am able to give out a url to someone else, so they can access the file, likewise, I can give out my file server's username and password, and whoever has it can also access my files.
There have been similar complaints about attempts to aggregate the contents of Hacker News posts, for example.
Where would we be without Google taking such a noble and strongly principled stance on user privacy, applied equally and consistently, striving to avoid legal responsibility, even when it costs unrelated parties thousands of dollars.
About the by-the-hour downloads, well there again is a trade-off between providing data quickly and doing a lazy evaluation.
I think, as the author notes, it was just an unfortunate event that was a consequence of good design decisions gone bad circumstantially and wreaking havoc for the author.
It was certainly nice of Amazon to have made that refund. The resources (read bandwidth) were used after all.