News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by geysersam on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @11:43PM (#38863095)
That's the opposite of meritocracy. And abuse of power on your bosses part. Don't know why so many in this thread seems to support obviously corrupt behavior.
Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by sokoloff on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:17AM (#38863320)
Is it? If I have serious on-going disagreements with my CEO's strategy and tactics to lead the company and I choose to take those disagreements public in a scorched earth style, I fully expect that I'd get sacked for it. And I think I should be (presumably with the typical severance for a other-than-cause termination).

I'm standing here thinking "yup, that's about right" and other posters are thinking this is "so not right as to be obviously corrupt".

Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by TerrifiedMouse on Thursday January 04, 2024 @01:01AM (#38863609)
I would hardly consider this as “take those disagreements public”. It’s not like they talked to the press. This letter was circulated internally using internal employee communications channels. Ironically, we would never have heard of it if they didn’t fire these employees in retaliation resulting in this lawsuit.
Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by chii on Thursday January 04, 2024 @02:25AM (#38864151)
> This letter was circulated internally using internal employee communications channels.

if an employee undermined leadership's authority, it is likely that they won't last long.

Good leadership means being able to recognize criticism from your employees, but this can't come from grassroots effort within the company - it must come from the top.

If the employee disagrees with the direction of the company, and the leadership doesn't want to change (e.g., after voicing the opinion thru sanctioned feedback channels), their only option is to quit, or acquire a controlling share and _become_ the leadership.

Trying to undermine leadership through collective action via other employees is akin to a threat and an internal coup in a country ruled by a dictator - and you know how that will go.

Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by kibwen on Thursday January 04, 2024 @08:35AM (#38866792)
> Trying to undermine leadership through collective action via other employees is akin to a threat and an internal coup in a country ruled by a dictator

This comment is so close to realizing why our current corporate structures are bullshit. Keep going, you're almost there.

Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by chii on Thursday January 04, 2024 @09:52AM (#38867687)
corporate structures _are_ dictatorships. The difference between that and a dictator country is that you can't change your country, if the dictator doesn't want you to leave.
Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by ak217 on Thursday January 04, 2024 @11:02AM (#38868583)
> if an employee undermined leadership's authority, it is likely that they won't last long.

It is hilarious that you (and many other people in this thread, it seems) would consider this letter "undermining leadership's authority". If someone's authority is undermined by a letter like this, they are not much of a leader.

I have worked at companies led by other zillionaires you may have heard of, and seen letters circulate and questions asked live in an all-hands meeting that went much farther than this letter. Those employees got good faith answers to their questions, and still work there. Now that's leadership.

Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by cycomanic on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:44AM (#38863498)
Since when is an internal letter public? Also what happened to the whole "I'm a free speech advocate" spiel? I guess free speech only applies to thinks Musk likes.

Seriously, under which definition is firing employees for their criticism considered good leadership?

Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by sokoloff on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:53AM (#38863557)
There are productive and destructive ways to handle disagreements with the chain of leadership. If I choose a destructive way, I shouldn't be shocked that I find destruction at the end of that path.
Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by saghm on Thursday January 04, 2024 @01:13AM (#38863691)
Circulating a letter internally is "destructive"?
Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by shawndrost on Thursday January 04, 2024 @02:23AM (#38864142)
A semi-open letter is an escalation. It's an admission that initial discussions have failed, and it is intended to prompt management to make a choice in a more concrete way. It's a powerful tool and it can be destructive or corrective.
Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by ImPostingOnHN on Thursday January 04, 2024 @01:12AM (#38863677)
They chose a constructive way, yet received destruction in return.

To be absolutely clear, politely communicating with fellow employees is absolutely the constructive way to handle work disagreements. The problem here obviously wasn't the constructiveness, but that there was any disagreement at all.

That's toxic leadership, but no surprise given the leader of the company.

Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by wahnfrieden on Thursday January 04, 2024 @01:02AM (#38863613)
Even if it's illegal to retaliate in the case of protected speech, however destructive?
Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by meheleventyone on Thursday January 04, 2024 @02:41AM (#38864262)
This whole sub-thread in general makes it pretty obvious to me that there are a bunch of people who love petty authoritarianism.
Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by geysersam on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:37AM (#38863462)
Was this a professional disagreement about the strategy of the company? No, it was a disagreement about politics. Rich people shouldn't have the right to use their power to silence others, that's why I called it abuse and corruption.
Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by Terr_ on Thursday January 04, 2024 @02:21AM (#38864137)
> If I have serious on-going disagreements with my CEO's strategy and tactics to lead the company

That's like claiming bank-robbery is fine because "there's no law against holding money in your hands, everyone does it." For some reason you're leaving out all the most important details that make things different than normal.

In this case, those details are that certain "disagreements"--an obvious case being "we're underpaid, let's unionize"--are disagreements which that CEO is not legally permitted to fire you for.

Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by YetAnotherNick on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:09AM (#38863260)
Abuse of power is a relative term. If something is the norm, then doing it is not abuse. It's fine in most companies to complain about the boss to HR or to the boss themselves, but not fine to complain it to someone else.

If I had bad boss who isn't doing anything illegal or breaks company's policy, I would likely switch my job rather than taking the impossible task of fixing them if they don't want to fix themselves.

Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by etchalon on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:16AM (#38863310)
> If something is the norm, then doing it is not abuse

The sheer number of historical atrocities this would excuse is almost hilarious.

Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by YetAnotherNick on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:23AM (#38863369)
The world swings and the things which looks like abuse changes. And it's not like people are not dying due to their norms. We need to change their norm from within.
Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by jrflowers on Thursday January 04, 2024 @02:02AM (#38864002)
This is very wise. The first step to changing the norm from within is to acknowledge that the norm cannot be bad because it is the norm, as the most powerful position of change is to say that nothing worth changing should be changed if it is somewhat common
Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by etchalon on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:31AM (#38863419)
I don't think what looks like abuse changes. I think what abuse we're OK with changes.

Domestic abuse was always abuse. It always looked like abuse. We always knew it was abuse.

But, for a very, very long time, society was totally cool with it.

Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by kibwen on Thursday January 04, 2024 @08:38AM (#38866821)
> We need to change their norm from within.

And what happened to the employees in this case who tried to challenge that norm from within?

Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by Eisenstein on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:14AM (#38863294)
> If something is the norm, then doing it is not abuse.

Abuse is abuse regardless of whether it is normalized in a company, but it is also against the law in this case specifically, so it is obviously not 'the norm'.

> If I had bad boss who isn't doing anything illegal or breaks company's policy, I would likely switch my job rather than taking the impossible task of fixing them if they don't want to fix themselves.

That's nice. It is also irrelevant.

Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by YetAnotherNick on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:25AM (#38863388)
> but it is also against the law in this case specifically, so it is obviously not 'the norm'.

Law IS the norm. And I could definitely bet there is no law in US which says that employee can spam other employees about how their boss is bad.

Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by Eisenstein on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:42AM (#38863484)
> And I could definitely bet there is no law in US which says that employee can spam other employees about how their boss is bad.

That is exactly what this case is alleging is the law that was violated. What do you think this is all about?

Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by YetAnotherNick on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:58AM (#38863586)
Most cases like these are just to get money from the employers because they have publicity risk. There is no law they can point that is broken. The article even clearly says this:

> The case is scheduled to go before an administrative judge in early March unless SpaceX agrees to a settlement beforehand. A spokeswoman for the labor board said it was seeking make-whole remedies like reinstatement and back pay for the workers.

Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by geysersam on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:41AM (#38863482)
We should aspire higher than moral relativism and "might is right".
Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by shiroiuma on Thursday January 04, 2024 @04:02AM (#38864752)
We should, but looking at events over the last year or 20 shows that things aren't moving that way at all.
Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by saghm on Thursday January 04, 2024 @01:23AM (#38863747)
> If I had bad boss who isn't doing anything illegal or breaks company's policy, I would likely switch my job rather than taking the impossible task of fixing them if they don't want to fix themselves.

What they initially wrote the letter about the boss doing might not have been illegal, but it sounds like the government agency whose job it is to monitor this sort of thing thinks firing them for it is in fact illegal.

> It's fine in most companies to complain about the boss to HR or to the boss themselves, but not fine to complain it to someone else.

There's "fine" and "not fine" as personal opinions, and then there's "legal" and "illegal"; both of those things you listed are in fact legal regardless of whether you personally consider them "fine", but firing someone for them is not.

Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by cycomanic on Thursday January 04, 2024 @02:02AM (#38864000)
Did you read the letter? It was specifically about the boss breaking company policy very publicly. So according to your own measures I guess they were correct then.
Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by charcircuit on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @11:59PM (#38863188)
Human relationships are not that cold. It is against human nature. Sure acting human may be suboptimal from a business sense, but there should not be a surprise when a human acts human.
Re:SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal ... by geysersam on Thursday January 04, 2024 @01:14AM (#38863698)
If the rich and powerful are unable to show self restraint then they should not have that power. Humans are Human, but we don't have to give some humans the power to sack others without just cause.