News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by chewmieser on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @01:48PM (#38845328)
Why do you think universities are more politically active? They have always been a safe-haven for ideas that go against the fray. I would argue they have always been "politically active."
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by throwaway-blaze on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:13PM (#38845689)
Today they are safe-havens only for ideas that fall on one side of the political divide in the US.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by enterprise_cog on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:07PM (#38847183)
What are the ideas of the other side you feel are not allowed?
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @05:13PM (#38847803)
"Israel has a right to exist and defend itself" is allowed but will certainly get you subjected to both overt and under-the-table harassment. https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/queering-an...
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by enterprise_cog on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @05:50PM (#38848157)
Opposing Zionism or what Israel is doing will get you doxxed, expelled, and blacklisted. I haven’t seen anyone receive the same treatment for being pro Israel.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by porkbeer on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @06:45PM (#38848777)
Not sure why your comment is fading, I have seen this firsthand. Maybe this is another example.
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @10:16PM (#38850258)
> Opposing Zionism or what Israel is doing will get you doxxed, expelled, and blacklisted.

Can you provide three examples in which no other infraction, violation, or crime was committed except for opposing Zionism?

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by runarberg on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @12:03PM (#38856465)
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @03:37PM (#38859513)
So the only two clean cases available are Jewish organizations? As in, Jewish organizations want to employ people who uphold those organizations' politics rather than oppose them?

This is your censorship?

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by runarberg on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:17PM (#38860056)
Finkelsteins crime was indeed opposing zionism. He just did it in a spectacular way which exposed a famous pro-israel as a hack, that is the only additional charge. I included it there because it is such a famous case and was easy for me to remember.

The other two are the result of a quick web search of the term “fired for opposing zionism”. I remembered the news about Sander’s case after being reminded. But the other one was me discovering it for the first time.

Here is another case from my search results that I just discovered now: https://mondoweiss.net/2023/09/i-was-harassed-by-zionists-an...

And another, this time not an explicitly Jewish institution https://www.jpost.com/Diaspora/Antisemitism/Fieldston-School...

Also notice that it should be harder to find clean examples, as institution are likely to hide their reasoning (fearing legal actions like Jessie Sander’s case). Like with Claudine Gay they trump up different charges. I don’t think it is a coincidence that all of the victims in my examples are Jewish. Zionism hurts Jews as well as it hurts Muslims. For some reason Zionists don’t feel like they have to hide their intention when they unfairly treat anti-zionist Jews.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by eli_gottlieb on Sunday January 07, 2024 @09:28PM (#38907590)
So you've got one example of someone fired for antizionism from a non-Jewish institution and it comes with the rather uncomfortable additional context that

> During that same academic year, swastikas began appearing in Fieldston halls and classrooms. In what would become a recurring theme for some Jewish families, parents told me that they were taken aback when school leadership responded to the initial appearance of the swastikas with a presentation for students that foregrounded “the ancient history of the symbol,” as one parent who saw the presentation told me.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by runarberg on Monday January 08, 2024 @01:30PM (#38916043)
You asked for three examples where “opposing Zionism or what Israel is doing will get you doxxed, expelled, and blacklisted.” I have given you 4 examples of somebody being fired from their jobs for opposing Zionism and 1 example of somebody loosing their career for opposing Zionism and exposing a fraud while they were at it.

Now you are asking me that these examples need to be from a non-Jewish institutions, and that actual antisemitism and hate speech cannot exist in the institution prior to the firing.

I think you don’t want to believe that people—mostly Jewish people—do get doxxed, expelled, and blacklisted for opposing Zionism. The examples are there. You just don’t want to look at them.

I would also like to add that many of my examples were from Zionist outlets, which also don’t want to acknowledge the reality that opposing their ideology can be very costly to some people. So off course they will find excuses by pointing out narratives which are only marginally related.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by runarberg on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @05:59PM (#38933537)
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by telotortium on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:08PM (#38845625)
When the administration of the University is making political statements and engaging in political activism, I would argue that they should lose the implicit protection that University faculty (I'd be willing to grant students that protection too) have for controversial ideas that they profess in the role of an academic. Even professors or students that take administrative roles should expect to lose such protection, since they have come to represent the university as an institution.†

For an example from the other side of the aisle, I opposed Steve Hsu being fired as VP of Research at Michigan State University in 2020 for his opinions, particularly regarding the genetics of race and intelligence (https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/06/16/open-thread-156-25/). Yet, ultimately, that was the risk of an administrative position such as his. He still is a full professor, and he has started several startups since then, so he's doing okay.

The main objection I have to positions like yours is that you believe that university administration should not be subject to pressure from politicians who grant universities the great privilege of being untaxed nonprofits with immense endowments and great influence in all the pillars of society. On the other hand, you believe that administrators should be subject to influence and control by left-wing student and academic protestors (I'm sure you think right-wing protestors would be illegitimate). I'm arguing that pressure on administration from both sides is legitimate, and that the former should flex its muscle more.

† I would also argue that academic fields that adopt activism as policy (so, all critical theory-influenced fields) should lose protection for their ideas, since they are clearly not pursued in a commitment to the truth, but that's a bit of an aside from my point here.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by thebradbain on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:25PM (#38845833)
You’re advocating placing limits on free speech of those best situated to speak truth to power — this is straight out of the fascist playbook.

Go after the Churches and religious organizations first, in that case, as they’re also tax advantaged and their leaders and congregations have a profound pull upon politics and politicians.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by snapcaster on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:32PM (#38845919)
I liked the discussion you both had. I think heavy scrutiny should be applied to any institution with that much power. Universities, churches, etc. all seem like valid targets
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by thebradbain on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @05:57PM (#38848224)
Funny enough, I actually think it’s a bad idea to go after either: both of those institutions, ultimately, are checks on the State — and historically, when a state turns to fascism, universities and religious organizations (save the “favored/officially sanctioned religion”) are the first thing to go.

I think the State should stay out of religion’s business entirely (that also means no “religious freedom” exemptions to treat others like second-class citizens that the evangelical right has been winning recently), along with universities too.

Leave both organizations tax-exempt, but they should not receive any public funds for any reason, nor get any other special protections from the government, lest there’s an explicit agreement to pay it back in the form of bonds or loans. Publicly-funded research at private institutions could remain the same as it is, with the caveat that results by-default should be public to all, rather than locked behind institutional paywalls.

(State universities are a valid edge case, but I’m specifically talking about private non-government organizations here)

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by snapcaster on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @08:20AM (#38853710)
Good point, I think if we look at quadrant of "Receives public finds" and "pays taxes" I'm fine with either "no funds, no taxes" or "taxes, and funds" sections
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by candiodari on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @02:41PM (#38846057)
Are you saying you can't see the reason why institutes of higher learning should be neutral - to a fault?
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by thebradbain on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @06:54PM (#38848855)
I actually would argue universities should not be neutral. They're a historical check on the State. Universities should do whatever works to attract intellectual talent, and if their ideology sucks, they'll naturally lose talent and influence to other institutions who have a different pedagogy.

That's the marketplace of ideas – not platforming every single idiot who wants to speak. Is Harvard supposed to, hyperbolically, entertain the notion of a flat earth if enough people believe it? I'd argue absolutely not (that's what the internet is for). Maybe the reason that the makeup of Harvard and similar schools is so liberal is because the right hasn't offered much in the way of intellectual fodder other than "Harvard bad" ?

If you don't agree with Harvard's policies, don't go to Harvard.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by anon7725 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @11:50PM (#38850867)
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by thebradbain on Friday January 05, 2024 @02:10AM (#38876564)
That's what makes them an important check on the state -- if they solely existed in a vacuum than what would speaking truth to power entail?
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by fzeroracer on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @03:06PM (#38846437)
Unfortunately, the territory has already been marked when it comes to the political slapfight. Florida for example has been waging a battle on all forms of education so that they can funnel the money towards religious initiatives and schools (See: New College of Florida). The goal is to find any flaws they can in universities or schooling then twist the knife until they can take it over.

Expecting people to be consistent when it comes to treating organizations the same way is a fools gambit.

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @05:14PM (#38847813)
Yes, the broad class of tax advantages used to launder political spending through churches and universities should be revoked and that money should be paid up to the government in taxes. Elections should be publicly funded, too!
Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by cscurmudgeon on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @01:32PM (#38857763)
> those best situated to speak truth to power

Why are they the best situated to speak truth to power?

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @05:11PM (#38847788)
> They have always been a safe-haven for ideas that go against the fray.

Every academic knows that you have to "play ball" to get to tenure, and that's regarding the direct subject matter of your own scholarship. Electoral endorsements are practically the only form of outspokenness that cannot and will not be used against you, only because the courts would come down too hard on the institution.

Everything else is office politics!

Re:Harvard President Claudine Gay resigns by infamia on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @05:15PM (#38847820)
I think the difference between now and back then is that now the top administration of the universities have become politically more active. Before it was mostly students and faculty, which makes sense.

edit: I would also note that the such actions by top administration imperils and has a chilling effect for faculty and student's contrarian thoughts and free speech. You you're not as likely to speak out against your boss/principal's ideas.