News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by acdha on Sunday December 31, 2023 @09:16AM (#38824176)
The part I found most interesting is that it still activates on roads that its mapping system knows aren’t suitable, and that the smiley face sticker is enough to fool their driver attention tracking system. Mercedes seems to have a much more mature engineering culture around safety.
Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by mikem69 on Sunday December 31, 2023 @12:18PM (#38825602)
My experience post-recall has been different.

The system is extremely annoying now, but will leave you alone if it sees your face and knows you’re watching the road.

Covering up the camera just makes it nag more frequently.

It’s frankly unusable now, as it’s constantly beeping at me…almost as bad as Lexus, which will beep if you as much as glance down to get a bottle of water.

Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by theflyingelvis on Sunday December 31, 2023 @12:41PM (#38825844)
This mirrors my experience with the update. I hate it.

People like the author of the article and people who misuse autopilot are why we can’t have nice things.

Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by qarl on Sunday December 31, 2023 @01:08PM (#38826095)
> People like the author of the article and people who misuse autopilot are why we can’t have nice things.

Well - yes - exactly. The software protects us from people who will misuse the technology and hurt others.

Cars are extremely dangerous.

Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by mikem69 on Sunday December 31, 2023 @02:19PM (#38826670)
The software makes the car more dangerous.

Instead of watching the road, I’m now having to look and figure out why my car is beeping at me. Apparently, I need to “pay attention to the road”, which is what I was doing before the beeping.

After 6 years and hundreds of thousands of miles using autopilot without any issues, I am now considering just getting an older luxury car that doesn’t have any of this “safety” software.

Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by acdha on Sunday December 31, 2023 @02:58PM (#38827017)
If the problem is that they shipped a half-assed implementation of an important safety mechanism, the answer is for them to get better at technology, not saying that safety measures are unnecessary. They can disable the features which don’t work until they have time to fix them.
Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by qarl on Sunday December 31, 2023 @02:26PM (#38826740)
> The software makes the car more dangerous.

Ah yes, and seatbelts make cars more dangerous too - distracting the driving and impeding their movement. Motorcycle helmets impair vision. And gun safety switches make rapid use very difficult.

Right?

Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by mikem69 on Sunday December 31, 2023 @03:23PM (#38827206)
Your car has seatbelts that constantly beep and make you look down to see why? Your helmet constantly nudges you to tell you to watch the road? Your gun safety switch makes a loud noise every time you’re about to fire a gun, reminding you to shoot safely?

Learn to discuss things without hyperbole and straw-men. My Tesla had so many alerts in a short drive that my passenger asked if the car had an issue that required repairs.

I guess in your world, looking away from the road and at a screen to read safety messages promotes safety.

Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by qarl on Sunday December 31, 2023 @03:42PM (#38827370)
I'm not using straw men or hyperbole. I'm merely pointing out that there are arguments which are structurally the same as yours which are absurd.

I'm happy to learn you don't embrace these absurd arguments - it's hard to guess what an internet stranger will claim.

Sounds like you need to ask Elon to fix his terrible safety implementations.

Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by Zetobal on Sunday December 31, 2023 @09:54AM (#38824440)
I bet there is a rule at tesla (which is not in writing) to keep workarounds and loopholes like these intentionally open. There is no other reasonable explanation for them to do the shit they do.
Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by acdha on Sunday December 31, 2023 @10:16AM (#38824580)
Yeah, this is what you do when you disagree with the policy and are doing the bare minimum to say you’re in compliance.
Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by Grazester on Sunday December 31, 2023 @12:19PM (#38825606)
I feel like this is absolutely what is happening. I wish they would be fined an absurd amount to teach them a lesson. The public roads aren't your proving grounds
Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by FirmwareBurner on Sunday December 31, 2023 @12:43PM (#38825866)
Won't someone please think of the poor $TSLA shareholders?
Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by rad_gruchalski on Sunday December 31, 2023 @11:24AM (#38825140)
Move fast and break things.
Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by qarl on Sunday December 31, 2023 @01:49PM (#38826415)
Bones, lives, etc..
Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by ajhurliman on Sunday December 31, 2023 @11:23AM (#38825116)
Yeah, they’ll even let you drive if you don’t have your seatbelt on, how dare they allow the owner to have any control at all /s
Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by aplummer on Sunday December 31, 2023 @11:54AM (#38825396)
I don’t think there is a single car manufacturer that doesn’t allow you to drive without your seatbelt on. What point are you making?
Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by fragmede on Sunday December 31, 2023 @12:31PM (#38825732)
"allowed"... I mean, all it does is beep at you, and some manufacturers offer a way to turn that off by inputting a code.
Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by mikem69 on Sunday December 31, 2023 @12:22PM (#38825642)
That we should be allowed to drive our own cars without being annoyed by these terrible systems?

I’ve avoided the new Lexus vehicles as their eye tracking is horrible - just glancing down to get a drink will set off alarms.

Now they’ve made my Tesla just as bad - my drive yesterday had an alert every 10 seconds or so, from “pay attention to the road” to “autopilot speed limited”. Very dangerous and distracting.

Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by ajhurliman on Sunday December 31, 2023 @01:52PM (#38826442)
Yes, that’s the point, everyone has these expectations of Tesla to make it impossible to circumvent safety features, but the same standard isn’t applied to other car manufacturers; HN just loves to bash on anything related to Elon.
Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by acdha on Sunday December 31, 2023 @03:09PM (#38827096)
> the same standard isn’t applied to other car manufacturers

This belief is hard to reconcile with the Cruise threads. What you’re actually seeing is that other companies aren’t hyping their technology so far in advance of its actual capabilities. If Toyota sold “full self driving” as an expensive add-on and failed to ship it over the time most people owned the vehicle, you’d see plenty of ragging on them, too.

The contrast is especially noticeable when you look at what the market leaders are doing. Waymo owns their vehicles fully and isn’t claiming they’re suitable for general use everywhere, every time. Mercedes has an L3 system far in advance of Tesla but they only offer it in certain conditions and back it with insurance. If Tesla’s product was where their marketing claims it is, they’d do the same.

Re:Testing Tesla's Autopilot recall, I don't feel much safer... by qarl on Sunday December 31, 2023 @05:22PM (#38828048)
> HN just loves to bash on anything related to Elon.

I dunno man. In my experience, the community of people who are very very very unhappy with Elon is far larger than just HN.