Same!
Starting with a Stage 1 install was what got me (with some guidance of a friend and the perfect Gentoo Wiki) into Linux circa 2004 (IIRC).
Now, some 20 years later, i much prefer to have not to deal with something as... dare i say.. fragile... anymore.
Yes, much of the breakage i dealt with was probably self-inflicted but always a good learning experience - but most of the time not at the most convenient time :(
I did Stage 1's as well around the same time but eventually got tired of doing that every so often or fighting Portage and switched to Arch.
Then I got tired of dealing with Arch... and ended up on Fedora.
I always liked Gentoo and Arch, but I don't have the energy to put up maintaining them anymore.
Around 2004, I was building Gentoo up from stage1 just like many other commenters.
For 2024 and personal stuff I’m back on Debian and it’s safe enough I pull security updates daily - entirely automated and no review on my part. It essentially never causes a problem. Updating once a year sounds terrifying to me given the rate of vulnerability discoveries of late.
As ever your mileage may vary and your systems aren’t my systems, but Debian truly is a wonderful OSS project and as of August 2023 it celebrated its 30th anniversary!
Gentoo going binary feels weird :) I’ve still got a soft spot for Gentoo and what it enabled me to do 15 years ago when I had more time for personal hacks.
Now I'm in the process of moving my desktop computers to Archlinux, to enjoy better control and up-to-date software.
Servers I keep in Debian for the same reasons you mention: stability and safe automated updates.
I dunno, there's a fair amount to be said for having an up-to-date kernel, systemd, and Docker. :)
The main problem is that if I provide a specific repo for docker (to keep a fresh version) it can request some dependencies and bam! I have a Debian-Turend-Arch system to maintain :)
I then moved to debian/ubuntu and recently switched my main server to Arch. And you are right - I got back this feeling of having all my 10 fingers in the system and living on the bleeding edge.
Now: this was probably not the brightest choice, as this server rund my docker containers and basically nothing more so it should have been Debian(a fire-and-forget OS)