I think the big difference between the two sites is that it's much easier for these types of projects to gain momentum and continue being updated on GitHub.
On SourceForge, a project would linger with no activity, bugs and feature requests would pile up, and creating a new project for a fork was a pain. I've checked out project CVS/SVN trees from SourceForge to fix things and since the projects looked dead, I never contributed the patches anywhere. I certainly wasn't going to create a new SourceForge project just to host my one patch. The few times I've created bugs for the patches, they never got any attention.
With GitHub, it's much easier to fork a repo, fix a bug, and push the fix back up for everyone to see, even if it never gets turned into a pull request or accepted upstream, lingering in your own git repo never to be touched again. Since GitHub shows your fork on the original project's fork tree, it's easy for other users to find your fork with your bugfix and continue that momentum by forking your fork, fixing their own bug, and so on.
well documented AND maintained examples of code that
satisfies some need.
You're asking for the Holy Grail of open source.When I google for something really obscure, I'm always glad to find something old, ugly, and broken, over no results at all.
Sounds okay to me. He's basically putting up a portfolio of his existing work.
Do people find value in unmaintained codedumps? I registered a dedicated github account last year for all the small stuff I wrote during train rides (I do a lot of them, 5 hours apiece) and never really finished. The idea was that I put a README on each of those and just leave it there for anyone to look at. But most of them are just tiny experiments in Ruby, so I decided not to release them for precisely the reasons mentioned in the parent post.
For really small tests/examples, I have a playground directory: https://github.com/albertz/playground
Everything else which is slightly more than a single file or has some other justification to be an own project, I just created a repo for it. https://github.com/albertz http://www.az2000.de/projects/
I think the answer is "no" and that's why I'm having such a hard time learning Smalltalk.
Admittedly it doesn't happen often, but it does, so you may as well put them out there :).
(Next problem to solve: discovering open source projects that are maintained.)
What would make the world a better place? More well documented AND maintained examples of code that satisfies some need.