News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by dvh on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @10:26AM (#38782872)
I've been under the impression that we don't have new antibiotics because it is not economically viable.

When you invent new weight loss drug you can sell millions of pills to anyone.

If you invent new antibiotic it is immediately classified as "reserve antibiotic" and the sale is restricted.

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by ac2u on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @10:38AM (#38783011)
>it is immediately classified as "reserve antibiotic" and the sale is restricted.

Is that so medical professionals can break it out as a means of last resort to save a patient and ensure the course is finished?

If so that mightn't be a bad idea before we destroy the potential of new antibiotics too by having the general public misuse them render them useless over time.

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by garrisonhh on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @10:59AM (#38783221)
I think the above commenter is just pointing out how the fundamental conflict between these two things results in significantly lessened incentive for pharmaceutical companies to put money into researching new antibiotics
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by schneems on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @12:39PM (#38784350)
I extremely know nothing about this field. Would a naive approach would to have a coordinated “crop rotation” type tactic where all hospitals switched to a primary antibiotic every C years/months do anything?
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by RiDiracTid on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @12:56PM (#38784537)
Empirically, many bacteria seem to be able to acquire resistance in a way that doesn't significantly impact their fitness, meaning they can basically get new resistances and keep old ones for almost arbitrarily long, so the crop rotation idea would fail massively.

https://academic.oup.com/femsre/article/35/5/901/2680377

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by schneems on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @02:31PM (#38785592)
Good to know, thanks for the explanation!
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by Log_out_ on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:46AM (#38802926)
It has costs. Replication gets more expensive and slower, more error prone. Also bacteria exchanges resistance DNA among itself. Would be a cool vector to give them weekness.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by zbrozek on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @10:49AM (#38783130)
It's probably a good idea. But doing that alone--without substituting market incentives with something else--means that there won't be new products to use in that way.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by zdragnar on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @03:10PM (#38786075)
There's a secondary consideration as well; designing new chemicals is fairly easy, synthesizing them harder, and scaling that to commercial manufacturing very hard.

Oh, and you still have to prove it to be safe and effective through years of clinical trials.

AI is basically still only helping us with the easiest parts, and this particular class is drugs is essentially a limited resource (to avoid force-evolving stains of bacteria that are resistant or immune).

At the end of the day, there's not as much research because there's a finite amount of resources to go around and there are easier / lower hanging fruit.

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by Log_out_ on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:44AM (#38802905)
Restricted? As in used by vetrinarys and cure for all in the poorer parts of the world? Also good if there is something to stop hospital bacteria eating patients in slices. Wish we had a wheel of antibiotics, were resistance makes the bacteria vulnerable to something on the opposite of the wheel.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by UncleOxidant on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @01:00PM (#38784581)
This is good example of the limits of capitalism.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by fasterik on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @04:00PM (#38786683)
I think capitalism has plenty of solutions for this. We can allocate government funding for research, pass new laws that create tax incentives, create prize funds to incentivize development of specific drugs, or make advanced market commitments where institutions commit to buying a portion of a certain type of drug after it's produced.

The underlying problem is the lack of political will and cooperation to implement these solutions.

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by UncleOxidant on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @06:44PM (#38788279)
> I think capitalism has plenty of solutions for this. We can allocate government funding for research ...

Market-driven capitalism without any government incentives (or disincentives) has no answer here. You just proposed something that's not market-driven capitalism. That the government should get involved in some way to fund and incentivize what it deems to be good for society in the long run. The market on it's own can't do this.

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by fasterik on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @07:15PM (#38788477)
It's a straw man to define capitalism in such a way that anything involving a government doesn't count as capitalism. Unless they're radical anarcho-capitalists, most people would agree that you need some sort of stable society with laws and regulations for markets to function correctly.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by heyoni on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @09:19PM (#38789247)
Nothing about your particular solution suggests it should be labeled capitalist, in fact, it would fit well under a number of radically different economic ideologies.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by fasterik on Thursday December 28, 2023 @12:32AM (#38790373)
If it involves private ownership, profit, and pricing through competitive markets, then it's capitalist. Everything I mentioned is already done under the current capitalist system. A few examples of non-capitalist solutions would be nationalization of drug production, enforced worker's collectives, and price controls. I don't think these are good alternatives, given their historical track record.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by hatenberg on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @10:08PM (#38789550)
so basically Libertarians.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by rjtavares on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @01:38PM (#38785020)
The whole concept of patents already is a solution to one of the limits of capitalism (they're basically government enforced monopolies). There are interesting ideas on how to improve the system, hopefully we won't throw the baby with the bath water here.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by infamouscow on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @08:53PM (#38789078)
Can you give any examples of antibiotic discoveries of this caliber happening recently in any economic system besides capitalism?

When making brain-dead claims, at least be fair and compare it to the track record of other economic systems. To do otherwise is shameful.

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by UncleOxidant on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @09:14PM (#38789213)
It may not be recent, but I can give the example of Alexander Fleming, discoverer of penicillin. He did not patent his discovery saying that "nature invented penicillin, I merely discovered it." He wanted it to be as widely available and affordable to everyone who needed it. (Similar for Jonas Salk and the polio vaccine). Fleming discovered penicillin in a government funded academic environment and was not incentivized by money. Maybe that was just more common back during that era (also given the Salk example). Maybe we're at a later stage of capitalism where it's less likely to happen.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by infamouscow on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @10:19PM (#38789616)
Alexander Fleming and Jonas Salk are akin Atticus Finch, but in real life.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by Waterluvian on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @12:09PM (#38784014)
It requires a socialized solution: to fund it for future needs rather than for profits.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by marcusverus on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @12:46PM (#38784411)
A government which can't regulate effectively can't be trusted with a monopoly.

Anyway, how does holding antibiotics in reserve help anything? Why let the bugs evolve resistance to one antibiotic at a time, rather than hitting them them with multiple antibiotics and thus raising the evolutionary hurdle to resistance? Was this strategy designed by the bad guys in a Jacky Chan movie?

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by devilbunny on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @04:19PM (#38786874)
> how does holding antibiotics in reserve help anything?

If they have novel mechanisms of action, quite a lot. If it's just another entrant in a class of antibiotics for which we have numerous drugs (and thus resistances) already, probably not as much.

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by Broken_Hippo on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @01:09PM (#38784693)
A government which can't regulate effectively can't be trusted with a monopoly.

If only the world were as simple. But it isn't, and everyone knows that those with power (in general, governments) will never be regulated effectively enough for everyone - but that doesn't make them never to be trusted with monopoly, nor does it mean that the government's monopoly is bad.

Sorry, I don't really want private militaries nor private tax collection. I'm happy the government runs things like IDs and drivers licenses. In fact, various department of motor vehicles (or whatever your local thing is called) is an excellent example of how a monopoly can be a good or bad experience. I'm originally from Indiana and the motor vehicle folks are great there and the service is easy to use - by design - but it isn't like that everywhere in the US. This has nothing really to do with how "effective" their regulation is.

I'm not sure actual monopolies are better - are you really satisfied with your electricity provider or ISP?

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by bakedoatmeal on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @08:50PM (#38789060)
Antibiotics harm the host as well. Giving grandma 4 antibiotics to treat a typical case of pneumonia goes against “do no harm”. Not to mention the added cost of prescribing more antibiotics.

When we can safely give multiple therapies without harming the patient, we do it. Standard HIV treatment uses 4 different drugs to raise the evolutionary hurdle for the virus.

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by marcusverus on Thursday December 28, 2023 @03:15PM (#38798061)
> Sorry, I don't really want private militaries nor private tax collection.

You can't have a government without a military or taxes, so it makes sense that government handles those things. They are requirements for the existence of government, and can't be delegated without existential risk. Medical research is not a core government function.

> I'm happy the government runs things like IDs and drivers licenses.

You'd probably be happier if you weren't required by law to get a license in the first place.

> In fact, various department of motor vehicles (or whatever your local thing is called) is an excellent example of how a monopoly can be a good or bad experience. I'm originally from Indiana and the motor vehicle folks are great there and the service is easy to use - by design - but it isn't like that everywhere in the US. This has nothing really to do with how "effective" their regulation is.

"Sometimes governments can handle basic services" doesn't strike me as a great argument for entrusting the government with complicated, vital services.

> I'm not sure actual monopolies are better - are you really satisfied with your electricity provider or ISP?

The alternative to government monopoly on the development of antibiotics isn't a private monopoly, it's no monopoly, and ideally without regulations which destroy the market incentives to develop antibiotics.

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by shzhdbi09gv8ioi on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @01:23PM (#38784857)
Anyway what? You don't win an internet argument by dumping some random quote.

If you have some ideas, do share them.

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by sfilmeyer on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @02:31PM (#38785596)
They did share an idea.

> rather than hitting them them with multiple antibiotics and thus raising the evolutionary hurdle to resistance?

It was surrounded by some rudeness and is probably a poor idea (but I'm no expert), but it was an idea.

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by marcusverus on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @10:01PM (#38789506)
> some rudeness

It was a joke. Please laugh.

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by wolverine876 on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @12:57PM (#38784551)
Whatever the theory, the government achieves quite a bit. Look at NASA, as one example, not to mention nuclear energy in all its applications, etc.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by travoc on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @03:30PM (#38786340)
70-80% of NASA's budget is spent on contracts with commercial companies, research institutions, and other external organizations.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by wolverine876 on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @03:58PM (#38786669)
I'm not sure how that matters. The commercial companies also subcontract.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by marcusverus on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @09:54PM (#38789467)
SpaceX created a reusable first stage in ~10 years, for less than NASA spends in a single year. In that same time period NASA spent a quarter of a TRILLION dollars… to send out a handful of probes. NASA does interesting things, sure, but nothing that the private sector couldn’t do in half the time for 1/10th the sticker price.

The government may have contributed to the discovery of nuclear power, but for the last 50 years it has been the largest impediment to nuclear power.

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by wolverine876 on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @11:46PM (#38790155)
> NASA does interesting things, sure, but nothing that the private sector couldn’t do in half the time for 1/10th the sticker price.

The private sector has never done anything like what NASA has accomplished, and NASA is far and away the most successful explorers and engineers in human history. I have no reason to believe anyone else could do it.

Has Space-X left Earth orbit?

> NASA spent a quarter of a TRILLION dollars… to send out a handful of probes

Look at NASA's budget (or any other source) and you'll find they do far, far more.

The all caps, btw, are against HN guidelines. Why have so many started using them this week?

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by marcusverus on Thursday December 28, 2023 @10:52AM (#38794627)
> The private sector has never done anything like what NASA has accomplished

Nonsense. NASA spent 50 years using disposable lift vehicles. Only the government could bring itself to create single-use articles that cost hundreds of millions of dollars. SpaceX has fixed this by building the Falcon 9, which is not only reusable, it has the highest success rate of any orbital rocket in human history. They're not only "doing something like what NASA has accomplished", they are objectively doing it better and far, far cheaper.

> and NASA is far and away the most successful explorers and engineers in human history. I have no reason to believe anyone else could do it.

No belief necessary. SpaceX has already done it.

> Has Space-X left Earth orbit?

Yes.

> Look at NASA's budget (or any other source) and you'll find they do far, far more.

My point wasn't that they didn't do a bunch of stuff, but rather that they didn't do enough to justify their $0.25 Trillion per-decade budget.

> The all caps, btw, are against HN guidelines.

Ah, I see that in the guidelines. I'll avoid them in the future, thanks!

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by wolverine876 on Thursday December 28, 2023 @02:15PM (#38797315)
NASA has done so much more than lift vehicles. To focus only on that doesn't address the question.

What exploration and engineering has SpaceX done to match NASA (except in one narrow area). NASA has a telescope at L2 looking back over 13 billion years, a helicopter flying on Mars, it has left the Solar System, it has satellites and probes all over orbit and other planets.

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by stupidcar on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @01:08PM (#38784680)
How would you ensure things like industrial farms use a more expensive multi-antibiotic approach instead of a cheaper single-antibiotic one without effective regulation?
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by CatWChainsaw on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @03:17PM (#38786181)
I don't know if multiple antibiotics helps prevent resistance necessarily. Resistance usually comes about when the dosage given allows survivors with resistance mutations to become the main population. I mean, I can see where multiple antibiotics and sub-lethal dosages that disrupt function in multiple ways could be enough pressure to break the bacteria, but sufficient dosing is important, and making sure a patient does their regimen properly is entirely the patient's responsibility. In order to prevent the exact same situation playing out with any new antibiotics, we shouldn't allow history to repeat itself.

Plus the normal gut flora would be disrupted by the multiple antibiotics as well, so there would be more work involved in the recovery of the symbiotes and commensals.

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by pshirshov on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @06:37PM (#38788231)
> rather than hitting them them with multiple antibiotics and thus raising the evolutionary hurdle to resistance?

You want to preserve your own bacterias, you won't survive without them. Combinations are effective, but they might kill too much of your friendly gut bacterias.

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by scotty79 on Thursday December 28, 2023 @09:34AM (#38793809)
We are routinely trusting completely random commercial entities that have overtly misaligned incentives (make money). Government monopolies in modern democracies are orders of magnitude safer.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by WorkerBee28474 on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @03:49PM (#38786575)
> If you invent new antibiotic it is immediately classified as "reserve antibiotic" and the sale is restricted.

Are there examples of this? I've heard people say this happens, but I've never heard a concrete example.

I googled 'reserve antibiotic' and found Ceftobiprole, and see it's for sale for $40,000/gram, so clearly it's possible to charge money for a 'reserve'.

Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by scotty79 on Thursday December 28, 2023 @09:31AM (#38793788)
That's probably the only good reason to allow exorbitant prices for this specific kind of medicine. To keep it in reserve while keeping pharma companies incentivised.
Re:Scientists discover the first new antibiotics in over 60 ... by bilsbie on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @06:54PM (#38788347)
The headline says this is the first one in 60 years so I’m not sure how you can suggest this pattern.