News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by bilsbie on Monday December 25, 2023 @04:26PM (#38766284)
I wish someone would make a truly dumb car. Sure you can have microcontrollers for emissions, safety, etc but beyond that give me a 1970s user interface and make the car as independent of technology as possible.
Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by markx2 on Monday December 25, 2023 @04:35PM (#38766354)
My eldest daughter knows her way around cars, and she refuses to buy any car that has any sort of computer in it.

She knows how to change this, repair that, fit whatever and is very happy doing that. But she also knows that as a female if she goes into any garage for a 'diagnostic' she will be overcharged. In fact even for something normal with a 'non-computer' car she will be overcharged.

Cars without computers are like gold.

Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by trentgreene on Monday December 25, 2023 @04:43PM (#38766413)
As a fellow “analog” automotive enthusiast, I’m curious how she defines computer in this situation?

Given that ECUs / microprocessors have been standard on cars since the late 60s / early 70s.

For me it’s the network connections and updates that scare me. The software on my ‘99 Benz hasn’t changed in 24 years, and I don’t need it too.

Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by trentgreene on Monday December 25, 2023 @04:59PM (#38766536)
I’ll add a small point to this. The computers my old cars do have, I’m quite thankful for. Being able to purchase a ~100-200 buck code reader and easily plug it in and figure out what my warning lights are trying to tell me has been a great educational tool and saved me a ton in maintenance.
Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by mistercheph on Monday December 25, 2023 @07:29PM (#38767752)
Advanced software can be used for good. It's sad that the same advanced systems that can perform extremely accurate self-diagnostics that empower even the most amateur mechanic to do their own work on extremely complex ICE setups for years and years will also be the component most likely to render the vehicle a 6000-lb brick made of animal skin and rare earth metals
Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by userbinator on Monday December 25, 2023 @05:04PM (#38766573)
I suspect she may be referring to the stereotypical carbureted V8 + manual / hydraulic auto combination that's still highly popular amongst US enthusiasts, which certainly has no ECU at all.

Microprocessors didn't exist until the early 70s. Late 70s / early 80s is when they started becoming common in cars.

Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by trentgreene on Monday December 25, 2023 @05:11PM (#38766638)
Heh, thanks for the info, I have a bit of a gap of knowledge about that era of vehicles outside of a type II fun experience with an older Ranchero.

I see VW advertising a car with an ECU in 1968, but likely just transistors.

Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by heywhatupboys on Monday December 25, 2023 @04:41PM (#38766393)
any car builtin the last 100 years have electrical components. Any car built in the last 50 have "computers".
Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by inportb on Monday December 25, 2023 @06:15PM (#38767247)
Even the camshaft-crankshaft system could be considered an analog computer that renders (in realtime) the positions of the valves based on the phase of the pistons. Any car with an internal combustion engine has "computers."
Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by thot_experiment on Monday December 25, 2023 @04:29PM (#38766298)
100% this, an electric car could be so reliable and simple to work on and repair if we wanted it to be.
Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by pyaamb on Monday December 25, 2023 @04:33PM (#38766329)
Absolutely this. Been hoping that this will become a cool trend someday. Perhaps when teen-age Gen-Alpha or Gen-Beta kids seek to differentiate themselves from their Algorithm-controlled over-sharing IG/Tiktok parents.
Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by shwouchk on Monday December 25, 2023 @04:30PM (#38766301)
Nissan Versa. It’s also one of the cheapest cars available.

Enjoy

Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by Avshalom on Monday December 25, 2023 @05:06PM (#38766591)
I know motorcycles are basically just an occasionally-useful game of russian roulette but every fucking automotive news cycle has me thinking about how they're basically the only way to buy just a motor and some wheels anymore.
Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by sam_lowry_ on Monday December 25, 2023 @05:15PM (#38766693)
You'd better check twice. Some had dial-out networking for years, like BMW.
Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by Avshalom on Monday December 25, 2023 @05:45PM (#38766996)
oh, well, shit, there goes the g310gs I had being eyeing for noodling around the state.
Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by poulpy123 on Monday December 25, 2023 @05:03PM (#38766560)
My 2012 Dacia Sandero is as dumb as you can be nowadays I think.
Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by whstl on Monday December 25, 2023 @08:11PM (#38767994)
Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by josephcsible on Monday December 25, 2023 @04:54PM (#38766498)
Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by clumsysmurf on Monday December 25, 2023 @04:30PM (#38766309)
That's why I have kept my '97 dodge dakota all this time... Like you said, dumb, but also using standard components like headlamp bulbs for repair-ability.
Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by KennyBlanken on Monday December 25, 2023 @05:06PM (#38766587)
It would not be economically feasible to build. CANBUS has revolutionized cars; now cars look more like a human body, with power and data being distributed to major points and then branching out. Before, everything ran from the fusebox. That meant a LOT of wiring, among other things. Copper is expensive and heavy. Car makers had a lot of incentive to save weight and cost so the wiring was as thin as they could get away with, so stuff never worked quite right.

It would be dangerous, because various driver warning systems and such would not be possible. System that are having a significant impact on per-mile safety for vehicle occupants (road safety for vulnerable road users has plunged.)

It would not be economically viable to operate, because engines are efficient as they are thanks to things like variable valve timing, direct injection, and so on. Some ECUs can sense how good the combustion was on a particular firing cycle via resistance across the spark plug after the ignition event. None of that would be possible with a "dumb" car.

It would also not be economically feasible to repair, because the diagnostic time would be crazy. Trying to diagnose "dumb" cars from the 80's and 90's was a nightmare. You could spend hours just trying to figure out what was wrong in a maze of wiring, relays, resistive packs, analog sensors, vacuum lines, etc. Dealerships are staffed by low-level techs, people on their way to something else or starting their own shop. Car companies couldn't possibly train them on all the intricacies of analog "dumb" car technology anymore.

Now? I plug in a OBD2 wireless module, tap "scan" on my phone, drink a cup of tea while it systematically talks to every module in the car, and I not only get fault codes, they've likely got time and mileage stamps, an indication of whether they were intermittent or continuous.

I can trigger a test on a component.

I can see what the ECU or body control module THINKS is going on versus what's actually going on.

I can tell the body control module to adapt to a new analog sensor.

all without needing to so much as pop the hood, remove a single screw, or upholstery clip.

It's a fucking dream.

The shittiness in "smart" cars is because legislation in the US hasn't kept pace with technology, and that is because legislation and regulation in the US is dominated by corporate interests.

Re:A recent software update was not successful. Your vehicle... by lando2319 on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @07:39PM (#38777693)
Great idea for another country, I the US there are just too many laws.