News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by gwern on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:35PM (#38755493)
Many points of interest here, including the answer to an earlier HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38384090 Why were the YC posts about Altman stepping down as YC president & becoming chairman so confusingly edited, and Altman seems to have either never been chairman or have quickly left? Well, because his post lacked candor about him becoming YC chairman:

"To smooth his exit, Altman proposed he move from president to chairman. He pre-emptively published a blog post on the firm’s website announcing the change. But the firm’s partnership had never agreed, and the announcement was later scrubbed from the post."

Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by anotherhue on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:38PM (#38755525)
Gun jumping seems to be his style.
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by vorticalbox on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:47PM (#38755588)
Not that I agree with this method but it's a pretty effective way to force something.
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by kdwikzncba on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:16PM (#38755866)
No, it's an attempt to force, and has the same flaw as all attempts to force, which is: the other side might just call your bluff.

"Oh you think that going ahead before a decision is made and just publish a post will get us to decide in your favor because we're afraid of looking like we're backtracking? How about we don't decide in your favor and delete your post? What you gonna do now?"

Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:33PM (#38756053)
> How about we don't decide in your favor and delete your post?

This response, the one YC went with, is milquetoast. It’s rational. But the true fuck you is to counter-programme and publicly call out the lie.

Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by BeefDinnerPurge on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:22PM (#38755929)
End up running the place anyway? Kind of like trying to fire Homelander from The Seven here...
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by hutzlibu on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:03PM (#38755720)
Also this other bit was news to me:

"Graham said it was his wife’s doing. “If anyone ‘fired’ Sam, it was Jessica, not me,” he said. “But it would be wrong to use the word ‘fired’ because he agreed immediately.” "

Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by bmitc on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:25PM (#38755964)
Why are these people so sycophantic, especially to such an inexperienced person?
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by hutzlibu on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:35PM (#38756069)
"“I saw in a 19-year-old Sam Altman the same thing that I see now: an intensely focused and brilliant person whom I was willing to bet big on,” said Chung, now managing general partner of Xfund, a venture-capital firm."

They believe in his focus to get things done, not in his ethics. And with ChatGPT, he got things done. Which means, he connected the right people and raised money so they can work on the important things.

Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by bmitc on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:45PM (#38756665)
> said Chung, now managing general partner of Xfund, a venture-capital firm.

Emphasis mine. I mean, that's just backs up my original question. These people will say anything to garner favor, perceived or otherwise. I've seen Altman speak. At what point should I expect to see a representative example of this focus and insight?

Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by sebzim4500 on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:52PM (#38756735)
> At what point should I expect to see a representative example of this focus and insight?

Probably never. He says nothing of substance in public.

Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by amazingman on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:23PM (#38756979)
His keynote at this year's OpenAI DevDay is an example of his focus. Have you watched it?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U9mJuUkhUzk

His pacing, clarity, and proficiency with the product are impressive; regardless of how one might feel about him.

Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by jstummbillig on Sunday December 24, 2023 @05:51PM (#38757809)
But of course, as with these things, nobody needs to admit to anything and any claim can easily be rejected.

The more polarising the figure, the more polarising the assessment of anything concerning them. Disconnecting different facets of a figure is not our strong suite.

Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by FridgeSeal on Monday December 25, 2023 @02:53AM (#38760690)
No you don’t get it, you’re not VC enough.

He has VC catnip, and he sprinkles it on his clothes, most notably between the 6 polo shirts he wears at once.

Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by bmitc on Monday December 25, 2023 @03:05AM (#38760749)
Lol. I was once at a place of real business and research that hosted some machine learning talk by a guy at Uber. When he walked in, late I might add, to an auditorium full of business casual and suits, he looked like a cartoon character with his spiky hair, jeans, colorful shirt, and all. He also spent every answer to questions making it clear he doesn't work on self-driving cars or call-a-taxis, which was strange given his employer.
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by queuebert on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:32PM (#38757057)
He's surrounded by VCs with confirmation bias.
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by AndrewKemendo on Sunday December 24, 2023 @06:22PM (#38758032)
The dirty truth is that the ideal Silicon Valley CEO is whomever can be a perfect sockpuppet for investors and still understand technical velocity.

The more ability you have to be kind of waterproof so to speak - like a duck - because of a mixture of positioning, ruthlessness, access, intelligence, perseverance, etc the better you are. Most importantly you have to regularly show allegiance to specifically investors over all other considerations, and boom you’re perfectly crafted.

Altman has brilliantly positioned himself as that perfect fulcrum between venture and technical skills such that he is (in his own mind and to a tiny subset of incredibly powerful people in SV) indispensable to the silicon valley crowd who doesn’t really know how to navigate the intersection between venture and technical skills.

Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by tim333 on Monday December 25, 2023 @07:17PM (#38767680)
Is firing someone being sycophantic?
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by choppaface on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @01:19AM (#38769328)
It is when your rich spouse asks you to do it and you do it despite attempting to pose as a leader in critical thinking in tech and potential counterbalance to your spouse. It’s an open admission that sama behaved blatantly unethically (perhaps illegally) but also pinned your financial opportunity cost so that you couldn’t play against him. Note that Loopt sold the profiles of poor people to low-income credit predators, and Sama did this to pay for his first pair of matching Mclarens (he literally bought the same car twice). Moreover pg claims he didn’t do it yet apparently flew back to CA from the UK to deal with it.
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by gumballindie on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:39PM (#38755533)
The more we learn about this person the more we understand how dubious he is. I am not entirely sure what the end game is for those protecting and promoting him. He’s clearly not steve jobs. Behaves and talks more like a cheap imitation.
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by jstummbillig on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:54PM (#38755640)
Is the idea that Steve Jobs never strong armed anyone?
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by queuebert on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:33PM (#38757068)
No, but he sure stinky feeted quite a few.
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by gumballindie on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:24PM (#38755948)
The idea is that steve jobs built something. And those promoting altman try to somehow make him look like steve. But altman built nothing, has no plan whatsoever, and is an impostor. I think even he knows it, which explains his attempts at making something stick - be it dodgy crypto, corrupt business deals, an ai that fails to live to its hype, and so on.
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by dclowd9901 on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:51PM (#38756225)
I’m with you. I think the point here is that he _is_ like Steve Jobs, and everything that goes with that comparison.
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by CPLX on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:56PM (#38755657)
His values are completely aligned with the ruling class.

Billionaires need on the ground types like him to actually do stuff.

It’s hard to find people who are young and ambitious and effective, and yet fundamentally and ruthlessly aligned with corporate hegemony.

And I suspect he must be spectacularly good at flattery.

Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by alternative_a on Sunday December 24, 2023 @05:02PM (#38757350)
> [elite’s HR issues]

We share this thought.

My pet theory regarding the recruitment efforts of this class: two broad fronts, one to drive the herd and the other to pick candidates.

The first front permeates our head space in form of content in the full spectrum of the bandwidth of this class: entertainment, news, organizations. Here the message is insistently that “Only suckers play straight”, “crime pays”, “winners and losers”. This is a consistent message.

The second front is more selective and here I am speculating (unlike the former which one gets to experience first hand, whether one likes it or not.) Here I suspect a more ‘direct’ sales pitch is used, and likely references the former.

Imagine you are a bright young thing from ‘not money’ raised in that “cultural” environment just mentioned. Now you open your favorite “journal of record”. You read barely disguised lies, note how these lies lead designated demographics by the NOSE with them not even aware of this fact, and finally your mentor has a conversation with you:

“Do you really think that the general population, these same people we were discussing being led by the nose with lies, are actually capable of self-governance and should have a say in “important” matters?”

Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by nvy on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:10PM (#38755791)
Steve Jobs was a massive piece of shit; not a good figure to worship.
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by chongli on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:15PM (#38755853)
Steve Jobs was a human being. No human should be worshipped.

Like all human beings, he wasn't a one-dimensional character from a crappy sitcom. He had negative and positive traits. Whatever one feels about him personally, it is absolutely a mistake to dismiss him. What he achieved -- multiple times -- puts him in extremely rarified air in the business world.

[dead]
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by Clent on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:36PM (#38756070)
Knowing which giants shoulders to stand on is crucial.

Steering those giants towards a unified vision is rarer.

Recognizing someone that does it multiple times is the very definition of merit.

[dead]
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:42PM (#38756130)
> Being involved in a some impressive things doesn't excuse

It doesn’t. It also doesn’t negate those accomplishments. The world is a better and a worse place for him. This is humanity.

Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by gosub100 on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:46PM (#38757200)
if apple had gone bankrupt he'd have started his own company. his best accomplishment was with UI and actually giving a fuck about the end user. thats not brilliant or genius. Actually having empathy for the user was such a novel concept in computing that it drove him to the top, even though he lacked empathy for anyone around him. His other notable accomplishments were negotiating with the record companies to license iTunes music. I would love to have been a fly on the wall for those conversations. Without a critical mass of licensing, iPod would have never happened. his glory for iPhone is nonsense, it would have happened within a year or 2 anyway as electronics matured.
Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by natdempk on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:37PM (#38757105)
> In early October, OpenAI’s chief scientist approached some fellow board members to recommend Altman be fired, citing roughly 20 examples of when he believed Altman misled OpenAI executives over the years.

I also thought this was interesting, not sure if this detail had been reported before this article, but seems like there were maybe more incidents than initially thought.

Re:Sam Altman's knack for dodging bullets with a little help... by gwern on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:49PM (#38757228)
There had been two incidents reported: Sutskever seeing in Slack from other OA execs that the attempt to fire Toner was not over the paper but over her EA ties, and McCauley (apparently) being told by Altman that another board member wanted to fire Toner over the paper.

This list of 20 examples is new, albeit unsurprising given that there was no reason to think that there were only 2 incidents, and I highlight it in my longer commentary: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/KXHMCH7wCxrvKsJyn/openai-fac...