News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by hurril on Sunday December 24, 2023 @11:14AM (#38754418)
And then it stops blowing so they buy all our Swedish electricity, making us all pay for the german environment. Except the germans.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by pgeorgi on Sunday December 24, 2023 @11:55AM (#38754737)
Germany's location means that it's a logistics hub. Gas, electricity, goods - large percentages of each are going into Germany on one end and leave it on another.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by danielbln on Sunday December 24, 2023 @11:23AM (#38754479)
We don't pay? We paid like 40 cents per kwh im late 2022, vs 26 cents in Sweden. Feel free to blame whoever, but German end consumers are probably not to blame.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by ffgjgf1 on Sunday December 24, 2023 @11:51AM (#38754712)
> but German end consumers are probably not to blame.

If they overlap with the German voters who voted for Merkel and especially Schroder (who literally became an agent working for the Russian government after he left office) before that then we can certainly blame them.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by oezi on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:00PM (#38755699)
Certainly mistakes were made, but please recall that it is primarily market forces which led us to the German gas dependence. Russian gas was just cheaper than American and Qatari gas.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by ffgjgf1 on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:12PM (#38756904)
There were other options than gas.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by oezi on Monday December 25, 2023 @07:52AM (#38762195)
Cheaper ones?
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by ffgjgf1 on Monday December 25, 2023 @09:10AM (#38762714)
No, of course not. The whole problem is because they just with the cheapest option (also outright unambiguous corruption in Schroder’s case) and ignored any issues that might have longterm
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by hurril on Sunday December 24, 2023 @12:00PM (#38754788)
We pay that and more because both Germany and Sweden decided that nuclear power is a bad idea. You would pay even more if we weren't selling, which in a sense would be more fair because then you would bear the consequences of your own actions.

Downvote me all you want, dear germans.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by Klinky on Sunday December 24, 2023 @12:56PM (#38755193)
They would pay more if there were fewer market options, but there aren't, so not sure your point.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by hurril on Sunday December 24, 2023 @05:46PM (#38757774)
-Who would pay more for what?-

Re-read.

That isn't why in the slightest. It isn't about the number of alternatives, it's entirely to do with the cost of producing electricity for the different alternatives.

When there's plenty of wind, then wind power is obviously cheap. Sometimes running into the negative, as in: we get paid to use it.

This causes _everyone_ to lose money.

When there's no wind in large areas, industry power draw (which is most of it by a wide margin), means that something else has to produce the missing energy. If too little electrical energy is produced, the entire grid breaks down, so there's a scuttle to either disconnect sub-nets or add more production.

The production that is added is more expensive. This sets the market price.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by oezi on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:05PM (#38755750)
Nuclear is a bad idea, period. There are less than 20 new reactors in planning in the entire western world and their cost and timeline overruns show that nuclear is a losing ticket.

The quicker we transition to renewable + battery, the better. I am sorry that Germans (or should we say Putin's war?) caused higher prices for Swedes, but all studies I have seen show great benefits of the European unified grid for consumer prices.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by hurril on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:26PM (#38755967)
Nuclear is the least bad idea and electricity prices have nothing to do with Putin's war. But sure, you are right that nuclear is very expensive but it doesn't have to be that way; plus: there are a lot of countries changing their minds here at this point.

I am not against renewables, I am for keeping our senses.

An example of something that just isn't sensible: Fueling my electric car with energy derived from coal, stored in batteries basically built by satan. (Read about the mines.) For decades, we stopped developing nuclear power because of confused environmental groups. (And against: I am not a coal thumper and definitely a green person!)

Electricity prices have basically increased five-fold at least, here. And it gets worse every years. When the wind stops, we run coal, oil and gas plants here that are extremely expensive and also destroy the environment. Instead of nuclear that we use to have.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by uecker on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:58PM (#38756282)
Nuclear economics doesn't work. China just pulled out from Hinkley Point C. EDF made record losses and sits on an ancient fleet and is being renationalized. Westinghouse went bankrupt over two projects. NuScales project just got canceled because - surprise - cost was too high. Really, nuclear looks good on paper but simply is as a technology far too complex and costly.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by hurril on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:55PM (#38756761)
It is very hard, yes. A lot of things in the regulations probably have to change because the technology works in reality, as opposed to wind and solar, which only works intermittently. We see news like these when there's a lot of wind power, but nothing when we use coal, oil and gas in its stead. Why is that? Ask yourself that question.

Opting for even more wind implies the need for backup coal power. Also: a lot of wind economics is pure bs in the sense that they calculate lifetimes that are completely bogus as well as the fact that they, themselves, are not recyclable in the slightest. This is a bubbly/ boomy economy.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by uecker on Monday December 25, 2023 @05:01AM (#38761298)
I do not have to ask myself the question: I follow energy policy closely and also look at actual data. Of course, we need a solution for time when there is no wind or solar. But this - very obviously - will not be nuclear. Nuclear is far too expensive and everybody who only blames this on regularization only is delusional. The solution will be demand shaping, storage, and gas peakers and this will be driven and optimized by market forces.

Also: What is bullshit are estimates for nuclear cost: Projects are started with clearly "optimistic" ideas about cost and end up being completely over budget and it never works without the tax or rate payer footing the bill. Wind, on the other hand is now a huge industry which would not have the growth rates it has even the economics wouldn't work.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by hurril on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:34PM (#38756063)
We, where I live, regularly pay over 26 Cents. Just last week, every day cost us north of 15 EUR a day on the electric bill, and it's not even _that_ cold yet. Because of a lack of nuclear power that used to be there.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by icehawk on Sunday December 24, 2023 @11:48AM (#38754689)
I don't understand what you mean by that?
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by hurril on Sunday December 24, 2023 @12:04PM (#38754807)
When your energy mix is biased towards wind and solar, the market price for energy fluctuates with the weather, basically. So when there's a lot of wind in an area, then energy is cheap (and the wind farms lose money.) When there's no wind, energy becomes expensive and the wind farms lose money.

This means that base power generation from nuclear also loses money when there's a lot of wind, and that coal power is needed when there isn't any [wind.] So we all pay more _and_ destroy the environment more.

When there's no wind in Germany, they buy from the energy market, driving up prices all the way up to what Coal and Oil power generation costs (which is expensive and terrible), since that is the competition. And since everyone pays market prices, we all suffer from Germany's lack of nuclear. (And ours.)

In a sense: Germany has socialised their energy production.

If I was conspiratorical, I would say that Russia played Germany like a fiddle in this regard. Cancel your nuclear so that you have to buy gas for energy production. And here we are.

Thank you Sweden and Germany.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by wazoox on Sunday December 24, 2023 @12:17PM (#38754901)
Actually it has been revealed that Gazprom supported financially anti-nuclear and pro-renewable NGOs in Germany for many, many years. That's not conspirational, just a fact.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by lispm on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:04PM (#38755249)
Actually Russia sells nuclear fuel into Europe & the US.

https://www.voanews.com/a/putin-profits-off-us-and-european-...

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by hurril on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:54PM (#38755638)
Akschully, these are not mutually exclusive.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by oezi on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:11PM (#38755808)
I think you might be right in the short term or considering the past, but it doesn't explain why a lot of money is pouring into renewables nevertheless and that there just isn't any other path forward than building another magnitude more in renewables (as TFA says: Germany is aiming to triple(!) solar by 2030). This will change massively change the markets.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by hurril on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:31PM (#38756028)
It won't work. What needs to happen for that to work is extreme progress in accumulation technology. It's a pipe dream.

You cannot run any industry that requires power or energy on: oh, I wonder what the weather is like tomorrow. And if we want to replace coal and other really bad parts of reality, we have to come up with alternatives that work and actually exist.

Solar and wind now is not that. Doing more of this will lead to even greater non-linear effects on prices, which will bankrupt normal citizen. And industry won't want to be here. They need stability and _lots_ of energy.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by uecker on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:12PM (#38756415)
Industry can definitely adapt to electricity prices. This is the power of free markets, they can optimize production and demand. Fluctuating prices cause by renewables will cause investments in storage and demand-side flexibility.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by hurril on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:58PM (#38756777)
Only to an extent. But sure: let's hope for better storage technology. But this also immediately eats away at cycle efficiency.

There's a reason nuclear remains, despite cost and apparent risks. It's because it is still less bad than the alternatives.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by uecker on Monday December 25, 2023 @04:58AM (#38761282)
In contrast nuclear, storage gets cheaper and better. Nuclear does not remain in Germany and is largely irrelevant almost everywhere else. My prediction is that it will increasingly become completely irrelevant, because it does not really help: We need storage, demand shaping, and peaker plants. Nuclear does not have any useful role in this world because it need to run all the time to be able to be profitable, so it can not be used to cover the missing gaps where there is no wind. So it does not make economic sense to today, and this will get even worse.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by icehawk on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @12:05AM (#38769070)
> When there's no wind in Germany, they buy from the energy market, driving up prices all the way up to what Coal and Oil power generation costs (which is expensive and terrible)

Neat! Can you show me graphs where that happens? Who makes that power from coal and oil?

> And since everyone pays market prices, we all suffer from Germany's lack of nuclear.

We? We who?

I don't think I pay market prices for it, since I don't live in Europe.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by Zetobal on Sunday December 24, 2023 @11:17AM (#38754440)
Germany is a net energy exporter... in the last two years especially helping out the crippled french nuclear power systems.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by skywal_l on Sunday December 24, 2023 @12:23PM (#38754948)
In the last two years only. FTFY
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by pgeorgi on Monday December 25, 2023 @12:45AM (#38760167)
The "help out the French" thing was a temporary situation due to France's power plant maintenance issues but on an annual basis Germany has been a net electricity exporter since 2003: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1331853/electricity-impo...
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by ffgjgf1 on Sunday December 24, 2023 @11:53AM (#38754723)
That was only possible because of coal plants. If that’s unavoidable I’m sure most French people prefer that’s burned in Germany rather than France.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by lispm on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:13PM (#38755323)
Half of the French nuclear power plant fleet was offline in 2022. -> https://www.catf.us/2023/07/2022-french-nuclear-outages-less...
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by oezi on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:13PM (#38755829)
The Germans certainly don't want to export dirty coal power but my understanding was that they were essentially aiding France to overcome a summer of draughts which crippled the mono-culture in France.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by uecker on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:00PM (#38756312)
Summer droughts and also high energy use in winter with electric heating is where France regularly depends on imports.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by hurril on Sunday December 24, 2023 @12:01PM (#38754794)
Exporting coal power. Lovely.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by KptMarchewa on Sunday December 24, 2023 @12:47PM (#38755124)
Your power plants earn that money. Tax it or something.