And byw (unless we are talking about different things) it was possible to get to the image on target page, but it was walled off behind a log in.
For context, my team wrote scripts to automate catching spam at scale.
Long story short, there are non spam-related reasons why one would want to have their website show different content to their users and to a bot. Say, adult content in countries where adult content is illegal. Or political views, in a similar context.
For this reason, most automated actions aren't built upon a single potential spam signal. I don't want to give too much detail, but here's a totally fictitious example for you:
* Having a website associated with keywords like "cheap" or "flash sale" isn't bad per say. But that might be seen as a first red flag
* Now having those aforementioned keywords, plus "Cartier" or "Vuitton" would be another red flag
* Add to this the fact that we see that this website changed owners recently, and used to SERP for different keywords, and that's another flag
=> 3 red flags, that's enough for some automation rule to me.
Again, this is a totally fictitious example, and in reality things are much more complex than this (plus I don't even think I understood or was exposed to all the ins and outs of spam detection while working there).
But cloaking on its own is kind of a risky space, as you'd get way too many false positives.
And then there’s whatever Pinterest does, which seems awfully like cloaking or bait-and-switch or something: you get a high ranked image search result, you click it, and the page you see is in no way relevant to the search or related to the image thumbnail you clicked.