News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by kube-system on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:36AM (#38696002)
US schools are some of the best funded in the world. Everyone wants a scapegoat for this problem, whether it be funding, teachers, or administration, but unfortunately the problem is societal.

Test scores are probably declining because parents are more worried about the sexual orientation of cartoon characters rather than their child's test score, among other distractions. The root of the problem is that respect for education in the US is low.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by michaelt on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:46AM (#38696136)
I've received extremely mixed messages from Americans about how well funded education is.

On one hand, I've heard that a class of 30 kids gets almost half a million dollars of taxpayer money per year.

On the other hand, I've heard that teachers get a salary of about $50k, and have to beg on gofundme to equip their classrooms with basic stationary.

I really have no idea how to get these two facts to line up.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by maxsilver on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @10:14AM (#38696561)
It's both. School systems are often heavily funded (but not always and not consistently, it varies by literal district). School employees are often drastically underpaid (but not always, and not consistently, it varies by district).

My local school district (generic midwest USA), there's a 17:1 teacher ratio, each student represents $13,011/yr in funding (so a single classroom gets $221,187 in government funding each year). Of that, the teacher in that room collects a salary of $40k to $60k W2 salary each year (plus benefits). Or, a teacher's salary is basically ~20% to 25% of the budget for that classroom, and the rest goes elsewhere.

And yeah, our teachers get literally nothing for their rooms, so they have to beg parents to donate crayons and tissue paper and pencils and basically anything else in their classroom, every year. (generally, each parent is expected to pitch in about $100 per student per year, in donate-ables to cover the stuff the district won't provide for teachers)

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by frumper on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @01:16PM (#38699315)
Often the per student funding number is skewed because of all the services a school provides, but not every student gets. Extra services may be specialized staff like speech therapists, occupational therapists, nurses, aides, bussing, or lunch programs. As an example, a special education class may have several aids, more specialized equipment and a need for more accommodating rooms. So it may not be a good method to take number of students x average cost = classroom budget.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by runjake on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @10:07AM (#38696441)
At least in my state of the US and I’d venture to guess the rest of the US, a disproportionate amount of that taxpayer money goes to special education and other services.

So while the statistics may break it down to a half million per classroom, that classroom doesn’t actually see that money. It’s chewed up with special education and the bureaucracy.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by 2devnull on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @10:21AM (#38696671)
Salary varies a lot by location. I think median salary for teacher in California is ~90k. But teacher salary is not the only cost of running a school district. Multiple buildings to manage, maybe busses, various staff, etc…
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by whywhywhywhy on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:58AM (#38696298)
Does it make sense calculating teacher salaries by year when they don’t work the full year, it’s actually significantly less when we take working hours into account maybe as low as 70% so it’s more like they’re paid a 70k rate with low hours and two months off.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by jwestbury on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @10:02AM (#38696353)
Go ask a teacher about how many hours they work -- it's more than the 40 hours a week we in tech work, generally. And their summers are often full of required continuing education courses which they pay for out of pocket, much like many other professions which are desperately understaffed (see: counselors).
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by hotpotamus on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @10:09AM (#38696477)
How many hours a week do they spend drilling leetcode or being on call. On maintaining their homelab because they need to keep up with the latest fashionable tech nonsense?

If you ask anyone, they'll tell you they're busy because that's the socially acceptable thing to say. If I'm honest, I don't do that much work (I tend to believe that's actually why we create and maintain all of these machines - so we don't have to work very much, but I'm apparently a disagreeable sort), but I still say that I'm keeping busy because if I said that I'm basically lazy and just want to meditate or watch TV most of the day away, people (particularly my employer) might take issue with that.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by Konnstann on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @10:18AM (#38696619)
The extra hours a week teachers spend have to do with lesson planning, grading, etc. which is directly related to their job unlike leetcode or your homelab or whatever, those aren't equivalent at all.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by hotpotamus on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @10:28AM (#38696777)
They say that, but how many times do they need to lesson plan if they teach the same subject year after year? And doesn't the curriculum rather decide the plans anyway? We had scantrons and other grading tech way back when I was in school or even just having the kids grade each others work; there are strategies for that as well.

My cousin is a teacher and manages that job plus a couple side businesses plus 3 kids. Somehow he finds the time.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by Konnstann on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @10:45AM (#38697009)
scantrons and grading each other's work only makes sense if your assignments are multiple choice, which is probably the least effective way of teaching in my opinion. As soon as the assignment requires any essay portion where you can get partial credit that breaks down. Curricula change every year, and relying on whatever standardized test your students are required to pass to develop your plans is a good part of why US education is lambasted elsewhere in the developed world, I'm glad your cousin can run 2 side businesses while teaching but I'd rather pay teachers more so they could put the effort into the kids, because there's a staggering difference between the ones that phone it in and the ones that don't.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by hotpotamus on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @11:36AM (#38697780)
I think it's entirely possible that the belief in education is one of the many beliefs that I've lost as I get older. Or perhaps like people say they believe in god, but not organized religion, I don't believe in organized education. That reflects my own experience I suppose; I wasn't much of a student, but once I actually got put into a position where I needed to learn things (a computer infrastructure/software engineering type job), I learned them well enough I suppose.

One takeaway from the covid lockdowns I took is it seems that to a first approximation, school is where children go for babysitting and perhaps learning happens there somehow. That would reflect my memories (plus it was a good place to score drugs).

I didn't think much of the system at the time, and even less upon reflection some years later, and it's not a system I'd want to put kids through, but I seem to say that about an increasing number of aspects of the modern world, so it's likely I'm just some sort of antisocial malcontent.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by 2devnull on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @10:29AM (#38696797)
Leetcode so you can get big bucks working as a programmer? Teachers put in extra hours because they see a kid in their class who will suffer through life if they don’t intervene. Compare your motivations to those of teachers, and leave the comparison at that.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by hotpotamus on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @10:36AM (#38696899)
I'm not a programmer and I said I don't actually work that hard. I do think that teachers work harder than I do on any given day, but I don't believe that they're as busy as they might have you believe, and they do still get summers off which I do not.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by jmye on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @11:34AM (#38697756)
Have you like, talked to an actual teacher? Or is this just "common sense" posturing about something you haven't actually looked into at all?

I'm regularly confused by people whose entire knowledge of classrooms comes from being a student, who nevertheless feel like they are experts and have all of the right answers.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by lupusreal on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:25PM (#38698496)
I know several teachers, a few of them in my family and a few of them in the group of friends I kept in touch with after highschool. Some of them work very hard during the school year, and some of them reuse the same lesson plans for years and say the others are working too hard. All of them don't work for most of the summer break, but they all do some work particularly in the first and last weeks.

Do you know why teachers get paid so little? Because there's a surplus of people who want to be teachers; actually getting a teaching job, let alone one at a good school, is a serious accomplishment. The schools that have a hard time keeping teachers are the ones with shitty students (due to shitty parents) which burn out teachers fast. The ones who can hack it at those schools use their experience to seek employment at better schools (positions at good schools are so competitive that having experience before applying is almost essential.)

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by jmye on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @02:01PM (#38699953)
> there's a surplus of people who want to be teachers

What on earth?

- https://www.npr.org/2023/03/23/1164800932/teacher-shortages-... - https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/education/2023/10/17/tea...

> I know several teachers

So, because 'some' of them don't work very hard, it's your 'belief' that all teachers aren't as busy as they say they are? Or are you now back-tracking your earlier comments? Does re-using lesson plans mean that those teachers aren't grading course work, or doing other activities, or are you assuming that "lesson plans" is the sum total of any extra work they may be doing?

I feel like this is just a cop out comment (particularly with the mealy 'I totally know some people' as evidence), moreso given the clear lack of understanding of the acute teacher shortages in this country, particularly in rural areas and particularly exacerbated over the last 4 years that you nevertheless think not only doesn't exist but is actually a surplus, in complete contradiction of literally all available evidence.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by lupusreal on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @03:54PM (#38701401)
There are no teacher shortages at good schools, getting one of those jobs is extremely competitive. Shitty schools constantly lose teachers and need new ones.

And to reiterated, the difference between a good school and a bad school is the quality of the student body, who reflect the quality of their parents. It's not funding. Often the worst schools have the most funding because people think that will make the school better, but over-funding schools won't fix kids who are fucked up by their parents.

Anyway, you asked for comments from people who know teachers. I know teachers, but I'm not here to back up your preconceptions. Deal with it.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by jmye on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @07:07PM (#38703768)
> There are no teacher shortages at good schools, getting one of those jobs is extremely competitive. Shitty schools constantly lose teachers and need new ones.

This is not supported by any evidence, unless you assume that all rural schools, for instance, are "shitty schools". But hey, let me throw yet another link you'll not look at while repeating things that are patently untrue:

https://www.texastribune.org/2022/07/25/texas-teacher-shorta...

I've no idea why you're talking about funding, as if that has anything to do with anything I've said, but article after article suggests the absurdly low teacher pay is a major issue - talking about ephemeral 'funding' in that context is dishonest.

But sure, you "know" teachers. You're not answering the questions because... you don't want to back up my preconceptions that are based on direct experience, er, I mean, "preconceptions"? Um, ok.

> but I'm not here to back up your preconceptions.

Says the guy who just keeps repeating himself when faced with linked evidence his preconceptions are incorrect.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by serialNumber on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @10:10AM (#38696509)
During the school year, teachers put in significantly more than the 8 hours they're physically at school. Marking, course planning, etc take up quite a bit of time that teachers must put in outside of work.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by lupusreal on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:16PM (#38698386)
Honestly it depends on the teacher. You're describing the ones who give a shit.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by kar5pt on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @10:15AM (#38696584)
It's pretty simple actually. US schools are run at the local level, not the national level. So different school districts (a district is usually the size of a town or county) get different amounts of funding.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by Izkata on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @12:09AM (#38705660)
> I really have no idea how to get these two facts to line up.

The proportion that goes to the management levels above the teachers keeps going up, instead of to the teachers or teaching materials.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by orangepurple on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:40AM (#38696053)
Based on my own tiny "clinical trials" how much and how quickly children learn is proportional to the time spent working through problems together with their parents.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by hnthrowaway0328 on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:44AM (#38696104)
Yeah. My dad literally sits with me for extra Math and English materials (He is a Math prof and my mom is an English prof). I hated it but TBH that's probably I'm going to do to my son :P Of course to a lesser extend as I need to take care of my career at the same time. Back then once you are prof you are safe for eternity.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by gumby on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @10:10AM (#38696500)
> My dad literally sits with me for extra Math and English materials…that's probably I'm going to do to my son

Yep, that’s the way to do it, and it can be fun, especially since it’s just helping rather than full on home schooling.

Most school curricula have different and concrete objectives (basically meeting aggregated KPIs) rather than “is the student actually learning?” Also teachers have a lot to deal with, and always have, tangential to actual teaching, like disruptive students.

I think the best part of the supplement is that most school work has no context (“will this be on the test?”). Especially in math, where you spend 12 years “learning the alphabet” and only after high school do you get to the fun parts, if ever. So at home you can actually see how the stuff you’re getting in school actually relates to the realm world, and can pursue interesting paths.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by hnthrowaway0328 on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:02PM (#38698155)
Yeah I agree. I'm probably going to do it differently as I hated that experience and TBH it doesn't benefit my study as he so wished.

I found the biggest problem of his approach is that he didn't care about figuring out my interest (TBF I didn't know either). The extra-curriculum study is mostly aimed for getting into a better school later so he first taught me Math in advance and then some extra for competitions. And even for programming he extremely hates gaming (to this day he thinks game developers are bad people, like people who do narcotics) and ONLY wants me to do competitive programming. Anyway I did not have any interest for anything he taught so it has been a painful drag for both of us until he kinda gave up when I reached grade 10.

Now that my kid is 3.25, I want to try something different. But I do find myself lacking the time or knowledge to prepare material for such activities. I want to expose him to a variety of activities after he reaches 4, say arithmetic and simple reading (so he can then spend more time reading books by himself), but I do not know how to approach teaching the topics. He is as impatient as a child can be and of course he is not interested in learning stuffs, which is definitely less interesting than, say, watching tanks crashing cars.

All in all, I know nothing about pediatrics education and need to know more before damaging our relationship as my father did back in the day. Neither do I have the mental energy reserve to burn candles to research on such topics. But I'll try.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by orangepurple on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:35PM (#38698645)
Quick way to get started: find numbers and letters in anything they are interested in. Kids love helping their parents and cooking with them using recipes and measuring stuff uses letters and numbers.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by hnthrowaway0328 on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @01:02PM (#38699102)
Thanks! We do do this like counting cars or clothes. He is good at counting from 1-20 so I think we are going to move to the concept of adding/subtractions. Probably going to use fruits.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by gumby on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @01:12PM (#38699255)
I personally think focusing on discrete math is a mistake, though everybody does it. Kids know the world is continuous* — just consider Piagetian experimentation in the bath — so opportunities to think that way are just as important, and I suspect more intuitive. The downside is my kid wanted to major in pure math.

* well, down to the Planck length I suppose :-)

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by gumby on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @01:16PM (#38699310)
Read the text books, or when little the handouts, to see what they are being taught. When they are big enough for textbooks it will probably shock you, especially history and the like. Anyway, just play with stuff related to what they are learning, and play is the key word.

Most math education is syntactic transforms, not understanding. There are lots of skill-appropriate puzzles in books and online you can do together so your kid can see that math can be fun. Same applies to other subjects — learning about US history? Make a trip to some local historical thing and when kiddo is bored just run around or whatever.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by 2devnull on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @10:32AM (#38696841)
“What a child can do today with assistance, she will be able to do by herself tomorrow.”
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by hosh on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:45AM (#38696121)
Personal attention matters. You can’t really outsource that.

While not scientific, it is a sentiment described in _Diamond Age_.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by alienicecream on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @11:08AM (#38697336)
Why is the sexual orientation of cartoon characters being pushed on kids though? Seems like something to be worried about if you're a parent.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by jmye on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @11:41AM (#38697851)
> being pushed on kids though

What do you think this means? Is having a picture of me and my wife on my desk "pushing my heterosexual orientation" on my co-workers?

I'm really confused by what you think is upsetting in a cartoon with multiple Mom/Dad characters, also including a lesbian couple. Why is it ok to "push" one sexual orientation, but "worrying" to "push" another?

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by alienicecream on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:11PM (#38698304)
It's not confusing if you just remove the premise you're trying to assume. One of those displays has been a given in our culture for as far back as recorded history, the other is something new that is being imposed from above with unknown, potentially detrimental effects. So suspicion is warranted.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by jmye on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @01:53PM (#38699840)
> One of those displays has been a given in our culture for as far back as recorded history, the other is something new that is being imposed from above with unknown, potentially detrimental effects.

This is patently and demonstrably false. Numerous cultures and societies have happily tolerated homosexuality.

Again, what is being "pushed" on kids? What are you suspicious of? I don't understand why you don't want to answer a very basic question.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by alienicecream on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @02:10PM (#38700069)
I thought I did answer the question. But to be clear, what is being pushed on children is that homosexuality is normal and healthy with the subtext that they should experiment with it. I am suspicious of the claim that it is those things and that the claimants are doing nothing more than promoting tolerance.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by jmye on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @06:58PM (#38703694)
> is that homosexuality is normal and healthy

It is.

> with the subtext that they should experiment with it.

This is purely something you've invented, whole cloth, out of nothing. No one is suggesting kids experiment with any sexual behavior in elementary school, and the belief that telling your child that "Jane has two mommies" is encouraging your kid to hook up with their same sex friend is absolutely as patently absurd as the notion that telling your child "Jane has a mommy and a daddy" is encouraging them to hook up with an opposite-sex friend.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by alienicecream on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @10:42AM (#38709868)
Telling young people that it's normal and healthy is by it's nature an encouragement to experiment with it. The people pushing this do not want to talk about that. Saying that I've invented that is just an attempt to mask it.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by kube-system on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @04:42PM (#38714008)
Does telling young people about heterosexual couples encourage heterosexual sex?

I've never seen an abstinence curriculum that avoids mentioning the existence of heterosexual couples.

The fact of the matter is that homosexuality isn't learned, it is something that people inherently feel.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by kube-system on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @02:57PM (#38700672)
The idea that a parent's ideological worries are something that a school should do something about is inherently problematic. Children are always going to have families with ideological differences from their peers. However, this isn't a reason to turn the school itself into the arbiters of those ideological differences.

The school didn't come up with the cartoon, others in society did. Children are going to talk about cartoons that they watch. My parents didn't always like the cartoons some of my classmates watched. Their solution was to not let me watch them, and instill their own set of values in me. They didn't ask the school to shelter me from the existence of other's ideologies.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by alienicecream on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @04:06PM (#38701540)
I would agree with you but it's not that simple. In Toronto there was a "controversy" when the schools allowed parents to exempt their children from drag queen story hour.
Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by kube-system on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @05:40PM (#38702905)
I am not familiar with that situation, but I think my previous statement could apply in any situation. I'm not picking sides here.

There are ways to discuss sensitive and ideologically divisive topics in an academic and neutral way. The way religion and politics are covered in social studies courses is often a good example of this.

You don't have to pick sides to cover a topic in a neutral manner.

Re:It Sure Looks Like Phones Are Making Students Dumber by alienicecream on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @06:07PM (#38703219)
Well my point with that example was that in your case your parents wouldn't have had the option to not let you watch the cartoon, the school would have decided for them. It's not just about kids discussing what they've been exposed to at home.