News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What good is experience? by dustingetz on Friday April 20, 2012 @04:15PM (#3869594)
two implications:

1. there's a huge difference between "oh, i can pick up rails in a week" and "7 years of rails experience". being super smart is insufficient for certain employers. you want the guy making foundation technical choices to have already learned from his mistakes

2. if you're in your twenties, and you're the best coder/entrepreneur/whatever you know, your hubris is blinding you to your potential, should you work with people more experienced than you. this is not to say you can't win the startup lottery when you're young, but your long term expectation is higher if you learn from others before you do.

Re:What good is experience? by InclinedPlane on Friday April 20, 2012 @05:28PM (#3869858)
Experience is non-linear though. X years of parking your butt in a chair staring at code doesn't make you an expert automatically, it doesn't even necessarily make you better than someone who has only spent 2 weeks learning the language or platform. I'd rather have a JWZ, Brendan Eich, or Linus Torvalds in their 20s working on my project even if they didn't know the language than some paycheck coding drone from the enterprise trenches who has a million years of experience in doing mutate-compile-repeat development in the exact same development stack.
Re:What good is experience? by barik on Friday April 20, 2012 @05:38PM (#3869906)
That's because most corporations seem to define experience incorrectly. Experience is not simply time. Instead, I prefer Hunt's definition of experience: "By experience, I mean specifically that performing this skill results in a change of thinking. As a counterexample, consider the case of the developer who claims ten years of experience, but in reality it was one year of experience repeated nine times. That doesn’t count as experience."

Unfortunately, the reality is that most companies equate experience with years; just look at the typical job postings as an example of this mentality.

Re:What good is experience? by jazzychad on Friday April 20, 2012 @04:31PM (#3869646)
re 2: exactly right. when I came out of college after 4 years of C classes, I thought I was the greatest. Then I went to work for Cisco with battle hardened C masters and found out I knew nothing. Learning from my co-workers was the best education I got.
Re:What good is experience? by sliverstorm on Friday April 20, 2012 @04:44PM (#3869696)
Never forget; "big fish, small pond"
Re:What good is experience? by heretohelp on Saturday April 21, 2012 @03:21AM (#3871201)
Hi from ##C on Freenode.

We love college kids like you :D

Re:What good is experience? by jamesbritt on Friday April 20, 2012 @05:34PM (#3869885)
Try not to be the smartest person in the room.
Re:What good is experience? by jsyedidia on Friday April 20, 2012 @05:44PM (#3869928)
Unless you're the smartest person in the world. In that case, trying not to be the smartest person in the room is wasted effort. Of course, if you're the smartest person in the world, you already know that.
Re:What good is experience? by vog on Friday April 20, 2012 @05:55PM (#3869966)
Taking this thought experiment a bit further:

In case you are the smartest person in the world, the advice is still a reasonable thing to do: How will you ever know you are the smartest-in-world if you don't try to find smarter people?

On the other hand, you'll probably never know for sure, as it is wasted effort to compare yourself with literally every other person in the world. So pretending not to be the smartest person in the world is a totally sensible thing to do even if you are.

Re:What good is experience? by jsyedidia on Friday April 20, 2012 @06:11PM (#3870020)
My previous comment was an attempt at humor, but actually, the notion of "smartest person" is too ill-defined to be very useful. People are smart at different things. For example, one person might be smarter at playing chess than another, while the second might be smarter at writing computer programs.

So let's replace the notion of "smartest person" with something better defined, like "most successful at playing chess, as measured by their chess rating." In that case, we know who the best in the world is, it's Magnus Carlsen. It would indeed be a waste of time for him to seek chess matches where there was somebody better than him, but it is in fact good advice for everybody else to seek to play against better opponents.

However, the strongest players all find that inevitably, they are nearly always stronger than their opponents. For example, the #2 in the world, Levon Aronian, is stronger unless he plays Carlsen. Every grandmaster finds that the large majority of his games are against weaker opponents.

So if you're really "smart," it's good advice to try to surround yourself with "smarter" people, but don't beat yourself up if you find it hard to do--it's an inevitable consequence of mathematics that the "smartest" people will tend to surround themselves with less "smart" people, at least if you're only measuring "smartness" in one way.

Re:What good is experience? by jaredsohn on Friday April 20, 2012 @08:22PM (#3870363)
In your chess example, there may be certain people that Magnus Carlsen should play chess against if he wants to improve. I don't know the specifics, but at least logically it is possible that even though Carlsen has the best chess rating, there could be players who can consistently beat him due to how they match up with each other.
Re:What good is experience? by mustafa0x on Friday April 20, 2012 @06:22PM (#3870052)
> but it is in fact good advice for everybody else

If so, then please don't nitpick advice which is good for everybody else. Magnus Carlsen can do that for himself.

Re:What good is experience? by hippee-lee on Friday April 20, 2012 @10:38PM (#3870679)
To extend your thought experiment ...

When you really are the smartest person in the world, and everyone knows it, you could seek out seek out students and teach them to be the smartest person in the world. I have heard it several times in different ways but the gist is this, 'If you really want to learn X, teach someone how to X.' I don't think the quote is exactly right but I hope the intent comes through.

Re:What good is experience? by lightscalar on Saturday April 21, 2012 @10:14AM (#3871797)
Depends on the room.
Re:What good is experience? by j45 on Friday April 20, 2012 @04:26PM (#3869630)
Nice points.

One thing that I'd be sure to think about is that more experience isn't just in years, it's in hours spent, and how well/quickly one learns to find and connect the dots to get that picture of experience.