News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by colanderman on Monday December 18, 2023 @10:55AM (#38684174)
Genuinely surprised at the prevalence of "Apple is right, Beeper is wrong" comments on Hacker News of all places. Beeper is filling a market need via a technologically creative solution. Since when is protectionism of large entrenched actors our cause?

I miss the days of GAIM/Pidgin/Trillium/Adium and hope Beeper prevails here.

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by joshmanders on Monday December 18, 2023 @11:10AM (#38684398)
Probably because while we're hackers at heart, we're also don't think that because a company is large and profitable we're entitled to their resources free of charge to sell to other people violating all of their terms of service.
Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by colanderman on Monday December 18, 2023 @11:29AM (#38684716)
I don't think Apple cares about the resource usage here. (Note that's not their argument, they argue that Beeper clients will bypass content protections.) The servers running iMessage, heck even the team supporting it, are probably a drop in the bucket for them.

Apple's goal is for iMessage to remain an exclusive feature of their hardware. That exclusivity is what Beeper -- or an Apple-vended Android client, or RCS interoperability, or federation generally -- threatens.

And -- it's exactly the proposition of, "to use our popular offering in market X, you must also purchase our offering in market Y" which is anticompetitive.

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by shazzdeeds on Monday December 18, 2023 @11:52PM (#38691961)
Lots of platforms like gaming consoles have exclusive content where the same company is both the hardware/services owner and the content creator. What would be anticompetitive is they leveraged their position as an app platform to stunt other legitimate chat apps from gaining popularity. Beeper claims that’s what’s happening to them but their legitimacy is debatable.
Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by minerva23 on Monday December 18, 2023 @01:05PM (#38686005)
My devil's advocate for Apple is that iMessage is relatively free of spam because of the exclusive architecture tied to hardware.

The issue isn't so much Beeper as it is the open the door to anyone on the Internet. I.e. Apple probably cares little about Beeper itself, and more about the risk of 3rd party software accessing its services/users.

A good number of us have had to combat spam/abuse in our careers, and we're sympathetic to the plight.

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by colanderman on Monday December 18, 2023 @03:02PM (#38687417)
This argument I'm sympathetic to. But I think it would sit a lot better with me if Apple were to produce an Android client. That it's a closed ecosystem doesn't bother me as much as that it's tied to their specific phone hardware.

(I'd still prefer to see 3rd party clients as I appreciate the integration those can bring. But the hardware lock-in is particularly egregious.)

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by YPPH on Monday December 18, 2023 @11:37PM (#38691880)
Does that stop you getting spam SMS messages?
Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by wraptile on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:12AM (#38692091)
iphones and imessages are incredibly easy to automate for spam. Today's free, grey and dark markets are often powered by real devices as it's easier to maintain than to reverse engineer and replicate. Usually real devices are mixed with automation code for best results (e.g. real devices generate fingerprints and sign stuff while code automates actions).

Creating barrier to entry for spam definitely reduces it but we know for a fact that's not a very effective spam fighting strategy.

I also think modern anti-spam tech is really good. My Samsung phone here is really good at blocking robo calls here in Thailand. In fact I handn't received one since my upgrade to S22. If Samsung can block robo calls and open protocols like federation and email can stop spam through simple tech and volunteer work then multibillion company with some of the best engineers surely can't find this that challenging right? So I find the spam argument for closing off iMessages not very convincing to say the least.

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by turquoisevar on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @02:26AM (#38692837)
> iphones and imessages are incredibly easy to automate for spam

You lost me here. iMessages in particular are not able to be automated because they always require user input before they’re sent.

There are very few OS processes that have an escalated privilege which allows sending iMessage without user input, but given the lack of widespread iMessage spam vs. SMS spam, it seems those processes aren’t actively being exploited.

Even iPhones in general are actually very hard to automate.

So honestly I have no clue what you’re talking about.

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by pxmpxm on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @07:44AM (#38694846)
I've yet to receive a single piece of spam coming from an iMessage account.
Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by awgneo on Monday December 18, 2023 @07:51PM (#38690442)
I too thought this was "Hacker" News, where we found ways to break down barriers and expand access to services to the benefit of society. Apple is absolutely abusing their market position and we should all be finding ways to establish healthy, multi-platform communication standands. It is disheartening to see many folks here fighting for the status quo, which clearly isn't working. Beeper devs are the hackers I will always support, the kind that drive a subconscious shift of our morals to something more inclusive.
Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by xvector on Monday December 18, 2023 @10:01PM (#38691271)
How is Apple abusing their market position?
Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by tadfisher on Monday December 18, 2023 @11:31PM (#38691831)
They are tying one market (phone hardware) to another (their messaging network). Whether that rises to the level of "abuse" is up to you.

I consider it so because of recent reports that 87% of US teens own iPhones, and colloquial knowledge of how "green bubbles" negatively affect teens' social and mental health.

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by xvector on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:46AM (#38692293)
That teens like iMessage and are dumb enough to cyber bully each other over it is not Apple's fault in the least. Their idiocy definitely does not constitute market abuse on Apple's part.
Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by meepmorp on Monday December 18, 2023 @11:30PM (#38691828)
Green bubbles, plus making iPhone using friends and family too lazy to install a 3rd party messaging app (accusations not valid outside of the continental US).
Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by averageRoyalty on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:24AM (#38692174)
How is Apple to blame for the laziness of your family and friends? I've never seen Apple disencourage in any way third party messaging apps on their devices.
Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by meepmorp on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:54AM (#38692334)
I wasn't being serious.
Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by averageRoyalty on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @12:32AM (#38705774)
Oh my bad, that did not come across.
Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by latexr on Monday December 18, 2023 @09:13PM (#38690991)
This conversation has been had at length at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38576857

The top reply addresses your points:

> The hacker spirit is the fun of reverse engineering. The hacker spirit is about personal use.

> It's not expecting to be able to turn it into a business, or a popular app, that wouldn't quickly be shut down. That's just common sense.

Beeper’s CEO is acting high and mighty, speaking like he’s some kind of ideological liberator, while charging for a service using another’s infrastructure. Had it been free and open-source from the start¹ you’d see a lot more people on their side. As soon as you start charging, you lose a lot of “hacker” sympathy.

It’s possible to disagree with Apple for not providing iMessage on Android while at the same time disagreeing with Beeper’s approach.

¹ And I do mean the whole app, not the proof-of-concept from the teenager.

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by modeless on Monday December 18, 2023 @11:55PM (#38691986)
> The hacker spirit is about personal use. It's not expecting to be able to turn it into a business

I reject this idea completely. The "hacker spirit" in no way excludes doing business or making money. Hackers creating businesses to bring the benefits of their hacking to the world are the very foundation of YC who created and operate this site.

> charging for a service using another’s infrastructure

Beeper doesn't get any benefit from using Apple's infrastructure per se. The resource usage is trivial. If there was a way to go around Apple's infrastructure and communicate with Apple's iMessage users directly Beeper would be all over it and more than happy to replace all that "infrastructure" themselves at no cost to Apple.

Apple has inserted themselves between their users and the world, making it impossible for anyone to send proper group or video messages to their unchangeable default messaging app without going through Apple. Beeper is simply doing the only thing that will work to fix Apple's intentional crippling of communication with Android for their own benefit.

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by fallat on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:17AM (#38692118)
> Hackers creating businesses to bring the benefits of their hacking to the world are the very foundation of YC who created and operate this site.

https://www.ycombinator.com/companies

What hacking benefits are brought by the top 5 companies in this list?

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by averageRoyalty on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:29AM (#38692196)
> Hackers creating businesses to bring the benefits of their hacking to the world are the very foundation of YC who created and operate this site.

I disagree. There is a clear line in many business from "cool hacking shit" to "cool/profitable business", but that hacker spirit is lost every single time.

The "hacking spirit" is never about money either - see any 90s/00s movie about hacking, or any of the 80s/90s manifestos online.

These aren't freedom fighters, trying to fight Goliath and bring messaging to the people. The original project they built on was. Beeper are profiteers, seeking to middle man some money. There nothing wrong with that - good on them - but that's hardly "hacker spirit".

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by ShamelessC on Monday December 18, 2023 @10:21PM (#38691404)
Yeah honestly normally I’d probably support something like beeper, but they just give me bad vibes. They’re being painted as a scrappy startup but to me they seem like another bunch of get-rich-quick, move fast and break things “disruptor” types. Which, ironically, is what the hacker in hacker news has largely come to symbolize in my opinion. Apple has an established culture and history of not operating that way, to make matters worse. It’s “growth hacking” versus the only company that still understands polish, however monopolistic they may be.
Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by eredengrin on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:30AM (#38692206)
Beeper has been around since 2020 and its primary product (now called beeper cloud) is an all-in-one chat application which supports many protocols from the same client, not just imessage. Even if imessage/beeper mini is the product generating discussion right now, beeper cloud has been the primary focus of their company since the start and beeper mini is just a recent tangent. They use matrix bridges as the backend and some of the devs now working for beeper were already working on the open source bridges which beeper now uses even before beeper the company existed. Beeper was the first organization (and one of the few it seems) to become a corporate sponsor of the matrix foundation, and they also routinely sponsor developers to work on the open source bridges that make up much of their infrastructure, even beyond the ones they hired on as staff.

I'm not sure how all this points to "get-rich-quick" silicon valley startup type to you but the behavior looks pretty different to me. Given their history, my guess is they put beeper mini out there primarily to put pressure on apple. If apple doesn't shut it down, cool, everyone has access to imessage through beeper. If apple does shut it down, at least it leaves little doubt about the situation: interoperability is not impossibly hard, apple really doesn't care about the security or privacy of their customers as much as they like to say they do, and at the end of the day imessage is only limited to apple devices because apple is apple. (For most companies I would say imessage is locked to apple devices because it's about the money but apple is one of those companies that takes weirdly principled positions even when it makes no sense, kind of similar to nintendo in that way.)

I suppose if all I had seen was the past month of buzz around them then I might perceive them differently.

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by latexr on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @06:55AM (#38694490)
> interoperability is not impossibly hard

Who ever argued it was? Apple never claimed they wouldn’t bring iMessage to Android because it was hard. Them making an Android app would be trivial, they simply choose not to. Which I disagree with, but that doesn’t mean I have to agree with Beeper’s approach.

> apple really doesn't care about the security or privacy of their customers as much as they like to say they do

That’s a bogus argument from Beeper. Why would Apple trust them? Beeper probably isn’t siphoning messages from user’s devices to spy on them but Apple doesn’t know that, none of us do. And if they allow that use, the app that comes next might be nefarious.

> For most companies I would say imessage is locked to apple devices because it's about the money but apple is one of those companies that takes weirdly principled positions even when it makes no sense

https://www.techemails.com/p/imessage-for-android

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by eredengrin on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @12:02PM (#38710838)
> Who ever argued it was?

I think lots of lobbyists were making such arguments about the DMA in Europe.

> That’s a bogus argument from Beeper. Why would Apple trust them?

This has little to do with beeper's client. The point is, apple could easily bring imessage to android and doing so would increase their customers privacy, because now all their android conversations could be e2ee. apple of course chooses not to do this even with how trivial it would be, showing that their privacy focused marketing is really just empty words. Beeper's role here is simply bringing more attention to this two faced apple propaganda.

> https://www.techemails.com/p/imessage-for-android

It's possible that imessage wasn't brought to android for monetary purposes early on, but at this point it's pretty clear there's a large segment of android users willing to pay a subscription to get imessage and that would be practically free money for apple. I think the main reason they still haven't included android is it goes against their vertical integration philosophy. They want to control everything (they don't control android, or the android app store) and are willing to make sacrifices and gambles in pursuit of that (eg them sinking loads of money to try and engineer their own modems even though it is likely to be worse than qualcomm's for quite some time, and who knows if they'll ever even ship an iphone with an apple modem before they shut the division down).

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by Spivak on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:34AM (#38692220)
Hey if Beeper successfully parlays this into regulators forcing Apple to open up iMessage then I'll pay them on principle.
Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by tinus_hn on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @04:35AM (#38693610)
While obviously the true Hacker News opinion is ‘hurr durr Apple bad’.

Beeper is requesting money for illegally distributing Apples copyrighted code which they then use in a questionable way. Cry me a river.

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by colanderman on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @07:55AM (#38694928)
What "copyrighted code" are you referring to? Are you alleging that Beeper has stolen Apple's IP? I haven't read this anywhere.
Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by tinus_hn on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @10:53AM (#38697137)
They include a library from MacOS that makes it register:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38534247

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by modeless on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @02:05AM (#38706166)
That's why there's are exemptions to copyright for interoperability reasons. You can't hide behind copyrights (or trademarks) solely to exclude competitors. (I believe Beeper uses this library solely for registration, not normal operation.) Such tactics have lost in court multiple times.
Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by tinus_hn on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @10:45AM (#38709899)
That’s a totally different kind of case where the barrier to interoperability is the ability to reproduce copyrighted content, like in the case of the DSMOS chip which contains a poem which has to be provided for the OS to work. These tactics have sometimes been successful and sometimes been unsuccessful. It’s just the legal lottery.

Here they simply provide someone else’s library to perform the authentication. That’s just basic copyright infringement, however lofty the goal.

https://stackoverflow.com/questions/858511/what-is-com-apple...

https://www.theregister.com/2003/08/11/habeas_cans_spammer/

You can’t write an emulator and sell it including the bios written by Sony. Has been enforced many times. Similarly, you can’t do what Beeper is doing here.

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by modeless on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @11:57AM (#38710764)
> the barrier to interoperability is the ability to reproduce copyrighted content

This is exactly the case here. The barrier to interoperability is the ability to reproduce this obfuscated code which, crucially, serves no other purpose. Even if it would be theoretically possible to achieve interoperability otherwise by heroic reverse engineering of said code, that doesn't matter just as it didn't matter in Sega v. Accolade where the exact same argument was made unsuccessfully by Sega.

This is not analogous to reproducing a whole BIOS which is not obfuscated code and is used for miscellaneous purposes having nothing to do with access restriction. This is clearly fair use according to precedent and blind assertions to the contrary don't prove anything.

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by tinus_hn on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @01:35PM (#38712011)
If you think copying an authorization library is ‘obfuscated code which serves no other purpose’ you’re just wrong and this discussion is pointless.

Ultimately either Apple will successfully block Beeper permanently or they will DMCA them and the courts will have their say. We’ll see.

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by yaky on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:50AM (#38696200)
Especially surprising since consolidating multiple messaging protocols under Matrix is literally Beeper's service, and has been for a few years.

Several other comment mention "piggybacking", but there are plenty of services piggybacking on tech giants: SearX, Nitter, Invidious, Teddit, Libreddit. One can even argue that LineageOS and GrapheneOS are piggybacking on Google's efforts.

Re:Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ... by xenadu02 on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @03:50PM (#38701341)
Because most of us didn't think AOL was doing something illegal by blocking third party clients. AOL created the service and ran the servers. AOL was free to make it work however they liked. And we never tried to insist that AOL was legally liable for making any changes to their own protocol without notice or approval to third party clients - what a hellscape of a world that would be for anyone trying to run a service!

Sentiment at the time was that we wished AOL would welcome third party clients but it was not their duty or obligation to do so. Likewise most people believed the third party clients were free to adapt to the changes. Both had the right to play cat/mouse as long as they wished.

Beeper is making a very different argument: that the courts and/or law should force anyone exposing an endpoint to the internet to bend over backwards so third parties can use the endpoint too (for free) because that would be convenient for end users. That Beeper can decide, at its own discretion, what is or is not allowable for something that was never intended to allow third party access.

Every company is almost by definition a monopolist with regard to its own products and services because even mostly equivalent things are still different in some way that could matter to a customer. It is all about where you draw the lines.