News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by outside1234 on Saturday December 16, 2023 @03:45PM (#38667502)
Honestly we should be taxing vehicles worldwide by weight. Damage to the road is x^4 to this value and it also would have the benefit of driving vehicles to be lighter and more fuel efficient and kill less pedestrians.
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by evmar on Saturday December 16, 2023 @03:59PM (#38667620)
Ironically in the US if your car is heavy enough you get a tax break, which the auto manufacturers know and target: https://www.mbotw.com/section-179-tax-exemption/
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by spockz on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:01PM (#38667633)
In the Netherlands vehicles are taxed at sale, before VAT so VAT is also payed over this tax, based on emissions. Then there is a quarterly tax based on the weight of the car. Currently zero emission cars get a 100% discount on the latter and hybrid get 50% discount. Diesels cost about triple.

Cars in NL are way more expensive then in the neighbouring countries.

Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by nsajko on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:08PM (#38667689)
What stops someone from buying their car in a neighboring country?
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by jhenkens on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:14PM (#38667732)
I'd guess same as across states in the US, registration?
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by ponector on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:27PM (#38667859)
Not across the states. Across the border. What stops people in US to buy and drive car from Mexico?

Huh, you can't even buy in US a decent new European car if someone decided not to sell the model through the dealership. Wait 25 years and only then you can import and register it.

Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by 4ggr0 on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:30PM (#38667889)
import tax, probably.
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by brnt on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:34PM (#38667914)
You need to import it and register it in order to drive it, and then you'll be paying that tax same as when bought from a Dutch shop.

The tax does decay for second hand cars, so there's a big market for foreign newtimers.

Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by netsharc on Saturday December 16, 2023 @05:03PM (#38668164)
https://expatinfoholland.nl/help-guides/transport-mobility/b...

They'd still be taxed, unless they lived in the foreign EU country for 12 months and bought the car and owned it for 6 months.

I suppose the EU is a customs union, but "some restrictions apply".

Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by 9dev on Sunday December 17, 2023 @02:01PM (#38675339)
I doubt it will stay this way for long, considering Wilders will be in power soon…
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by quantumwannabe on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:11PM (#38667713)
Be careful what you wish for.

Under a fair weight tax scheme, a passenger of a fully loaded bus would pay more than a solo driver of a Hummer EV (one of the heaviest SUVs on the market).

Some data on bus weights [1]:

      Transit Bus Type           Passengers         Curb Weight (lb)   Fully‐Loaded Weight (lb)
                            Max Seated Max Total 
  2‐axle 35‐foot               27 – 40   46 – 72     15,450 – 28,510       23,360 – 39,020
  2‐axle 40‐foot               35 – 44   61 – 92     20,520 – 32,520       30,600 – 44,100
  2‐axle 45‐foot               44 – 46   80 – 86     30,130 – 30,450       41,480 – 42,530
  3‐axle 45‐foot Double‐deck   79 – 82   116 – 122   36,560 – 37,930       54,670 – 55,850
  3‐axle 60‐foot Articulated   41 – 61   89 – 123    37,920 – 49,520       55,975 – 64,690
The Hummer EV's curb weight is 9063 lbs (add 150 lbs for an average driver) and it has two axles for a loaded axle weight of 4607 lbs.

A three axle articulated bus with 123 passengers has a loaded axle weight of 21,563 lbs using the data from the table above.

This means that the bus has ~4.7 times the load per axle as the SUV, so per the fourth power law, it does 488 times as much damage to the road as the SUV. Since it carries 123 people, that means that each bus passenger is doing ~4 times as much damage to the road as the SUV driver.

[1] https://onlinepubs.trb.org/onlinepubs/tcrp/docs/TCRPJ-11Task... (Table 7/Page 25)

Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by ponector on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:23PM (#38667812)
It is easy to exclude vehicles used for mass transit. Let's say every vehicle which required a driver license D is exempt of such tax.

I generally agree, personal vehicles should be taxed based on weight and power. Small taxes for small cars(fiat 500) and extra high taxes for ridiculously heavy and/or powerful vehicles like 911 or cybertuck.

Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:25PM (#38667835)
The point is you’d have to create an exception. The rule doesn’t work naturally, which implies it might be flawed.
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by ponector on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:29PM (#38667884)
You think any rule should have a one flat rate. One size fits all?

To be fair, rule should have different multipliers. Small rate for small car and buses, huge rate for trucks. Easy.

Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:34PM (#38667918)
> You think any rule should have a one flat rate. One size fits all?

No, but it's more elegant and less gameable that way. Otherwise, we wind up with the Section 179 problem [1].

[1] https://over6000pounds.com/electric-vehicles-that-unlock-the...

Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by 9dev on Sunday December 17, 2023 @02:08PM (#38675408)
I don’t understand why we can’t have this, and exemptions for public transit, or human transportation companies providing municipal services?

Don’t let perfect be the enemy of good. If a solution isn’t as elegant as possible, but significantly reduces the amount of SUVs on the roads, it’s a good thing - period.

Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by avianlyric on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:29PM (#38667882)
Does all that take into consideration the number of tires per axel, and size of the contact patch for each axel?

I would assume that road damage is proportional to surface pressure at the contact patch, so greater contact patch means less damage. As a result you can have a heavier vehicle do less damage than a lighter vehicle with the same number of axels, if the number and size of tires on the larger vehicle is greater than the smaller vehicle.

Most busses I see around run large truck tires, and normally have 4 tires on the rear axel vs the normal 2 you’ll find on a Hummer. So a bus spreads it weight over 6 tires rather than 4, and if we generously assume the Hummer tires and bus tires have the same contact patch, that means a bus can be 50% heavier than the Hummer, but not cause any additional damage.

I know loading regulations are normally done based on axel number, rather than tire number. But I assume that’s mostly down to ease of regulation, rather than axel count being the most accurate way to calculate road damage. Indeed the document you link too even breaks down loading limits based on number of axels, but also single tire limits, which maybe different depending on pressure of the tire.

Edit: I also note that U.S. buses seem to be much heavier than necessary. As a point of comparison a two axel double decker, New Routemaster in London[1], which carries up to 87 people, has a curb weight of only 28,000lbs, which would give it a fully laden weight of only 29,000lbs. That’s substantially less than equivalent buses in that document.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Routemaster

Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by anigbrowl on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:30PM (#38667888)
Now consider how many hummers you'd need to transport 123 people.
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by alamortsubite on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:46PM (#38668034)
Ironically, they did open by writing, "Be careful what you wish for."
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by scythe on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:42PM (#38668000)
This is not apples-to-apples, because buses don't drive on all of the roads, whereas cars drive on (presumably) any road. The total mileage of roads used for bus routes is a small fraction of all road mileage, even where bus systems are extensive. So more roads must be maintained for cars. Road damage is also affected by vehicle speed, acceleration, braking and so forth; buses drive regular routes at regulated speeds and do not brake very hard.
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by eesmith on Monday December 18, 2023 @03:49AM (#38680426)
I think that rather than use this source as a way to highlight issues with a strict interpretation of the 4th-power law, you should have commented how your source says you should not use a strict interpretation of the 4th-power law.

For example, it highlights how the damage also depends on the road construction, with highways and major arterials built to a higher standard.

As a general rule, a fully-loaded 123 passenger bus is running on an arterial, not a residential street like someone driving their Hummer EV home does, so you can't compare the road damage simply by axle weight.

Your source even highlights how "it is possible for fewer, heavier buses to damage pavement less than more, lighter buses."

That's all part of larger cost/benefit analysis, like how building for a longer service life for the bus means using heavier parts, which increases the weight, or how running fewer, larger buses reduces emissions per passenger-mile.

The owner of the Hummer EV does a different cost/benefit analysis, with some of the costs born by the government and thus shared across the taxpayers. Without extra fees for heavier vehicle owners, they end up paying the same as light vehicle owners despite the higher negative impacts of their heavy vehicles.

Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by outside1234 on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @06:59PM (#38715311)
The tax would be divided by occupancy
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by buildbot on Saturday December 16, 2023 @03:48PM (#38667526)
Yep. Pushes the industry to research lighter composites too, let’s see more carbon fiber chassis like the BMW i3! (A really underrated great little vehicle, my sibling has one and it rocks!)
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by doh on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:04PM (#38667663)
I do agree with this with the caveat that EVs are heavier than ICE. So it could be weight + emission = tax. That way while EVs are heavier they have no emissions and thus the price equalizes at some point.
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by reisse on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:08PM (#38667686)
This will significantly hurt all the EVs.
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by alamortsubite on Saturday December 16, 2023 @05:00PM (#38668141)
Not all, only the big ones. The small ones will benefit from this (and there are many).
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by kehrin on Saturday December 16, 2023 @05:06PM (#38668183)
Doubt it. The next chapter for EVs will be truly affordable vehicles, which naturally tend to be smaller. And with a more compact size (and most likely less batteries) will come lower weight. Besides, ICE cars have gotten heavy, too. So the extra 400kg headroom that EVs have should give them a decent fighting chance.
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by sidewndr46 on Saturday December 16, 2023 @03:52PM (#38667559)
In the US, this would work out to taxing the shipping industry. This would in turn raise the price of goods. In short, it is unlikely to ever happen
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by jfim on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:07PM (#38667679)
The road repairs have to be done either way, taxes just change who pays for them, whether it's gas taxes, overweight vehicle taxes, or general tax revenues.

Besides, trucks carrying goods are already taxed based on weight, they're measured at the truck weighing stations on the highway.

Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by Eric_WVGG on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:03PM (#38667656)
It’s not difficult to carve out exemptions for commercial and industry.
Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by delfinom on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:19PM (#38667780)
Shipping is already taxed by weight throughout the US. It is enforced by a nationwide network of state run weight stations that are actively enforced by police.

https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/policyinformation/hvut/mod1/whatish....

Re:Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut ai... by sidewndr46 on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:52PM (#38668086)
"taxed by weight" does not imply that it is taxed at amount commensurate to the damage to the roadway