News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by WalterBright on Friday December 15, 2023 @05:28PM (#38659609)
If an artist wants to make a living making art, the art has to be something people are willing to pay for.

If that's "selling out", then so be it. Why should society support the artist if his art has no value to anyone?

Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by thih9 on Friday December 15, 2023 @05:34PM (#38659663)
Note that our initial goal was different - not an artist who wants to make a living, but an artist who wants to perform fulfilling work.
Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by WalterBright on Friday December 15, 2023 @05:40PM (#38659730)
Draw two circles, 1. fulfilling art 2. art that pays the bills. Create the art that is in the intersection.

Otherwise, you'll need another source of income in order to create fulfilling art.

There's lots of software I'd like to write. I've spent my time writing code that lies in the intersection.

Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by thih9 on Friday December 15, 2023 @05:53PM (#38659860)
Sounds like you’re happy in that intersection - and good for you.
Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by Eisenstein on Friday December 15, 2023 @09:58PM (#38661338)
Let's draw another circle: things you make when 'financial obligations' are not a concern. Where does that intersect? Why aren't we drawing it? How much science was done by 'gentlemen scientists' who never worried about money? How much more would we know if that one person who could have figured out electromagnetism in 1400 didn't have to plow fields all day?
Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by WalterBright on Friday December 15, 2023 @10:57PM (#38661588)
There are an awful lot of professions in the world. Surely people can find one that suits them. Life is what you make of it.

My personal dream was to become a swimsuit model, but it just wasn't working out, so I switched to software.

Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by Eisenstein on Friday December 15, 2023 @11:22PM (#38661700)
You can't think of any other things besides genetics and self-determination that allowed you to be where you are now?
Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by WalterBright on Saturday December 16, 2023 @01:17AM (#38662157)
Opportunity presents itself to you and me every day. You can choose.
Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by yterdy on Saturday December 16, 2023 @07:15AM (#38663695)
You're conflating individual decisions with social structures that determine opportunity systemically.
Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by WalterBright on Saturday December 16, 2023 @01:03PM (#38666372)
The US has all the opportunity able-bodied adults need.
Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by yterdy on Saturday December 16, 2023 @02:58PM (#38667186)
Incorrect.
Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by WalterBright on Saturday December 16, 2023 @03:15PM (#38667309)
Viewing life that way leads to a diminished life, a self-fulfilling prophesy. The good news is one can always change one's frame of reference.
Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by bumby on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:09PM (#38667695)
It’s possible that viewpoint is the correct one at an individual level while also being the incorrect one at a societal level, if the goal is a meritocratic society.
Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by smoldesu on Saturday December 16, 2023 @05:15PM (#38668258)
There are a lot of people who fail to self-actualize entirely due to environmental differences. Starvation, hypothermia, robbery and petty crimes, unemployment, destruction/loss of property, social rejection, discrimination, self-doubt, and even a lack of respect is enough to prevent someone from enjoying life fully.

Accepting the hardship of reality is the only way you can realize deterministic change. Making blanket statements about "opportunity" in the US will have you immediately proven wrong no matter what you claim. Your opportunity is not the same as a Puerto Rican's which is not the same as an impoverished and sickly rural teenager in Montana. Changing your frame of reference is not any easier than it is to stop looking foreign or get a bunch of money really quickly.

Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by WalterBright on Saturday December 16, 2023 @07:58PM (#38669378)
I've said repeatedly "of sound mind and body and living in America". I see no reason to change that.
Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by yterdy on Monday December 18, 2023 @09:22AM (#38682889)
No one is going to argue that the world isn't your oyster as a tall, fit, cis white man (many people's definition of "sound mind and body"). However, the rest of us deserve a chance. That we're not always able to get one is not an in-born character flaw.
Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by allarm on Monday December 25, 2023 @04:33AM (#38761155)
> a tall, fit, cis white man

gosh I thought you’d get to this punchline earlier.

Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by fragmede on Friday December 15, 2023 @10:10PM (#38661385)
That is a really great place for you to be in! Where code useful and thus valuable, there is a lot in that intersection. Unfortunately where art is concerned, that intersection may be an empty set.
Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by WalterBright on Friday December 15, 2023 @10:52PM (#38661566)
I personally derive a lot of satisfaction from other people enjoying using the programs I write, and I love it when they make money using it. (Many have described to me how D gave them a competitive advantage.) Many give back by funding our annual D conference and providing funding for several of our critical staff members.

I wrote Empire for my personal satisfaction eons ago, and when other people copied it and spread it around, I discovered that it was a lot of fun to get unsolicited emails from people who liked playing it and wanted to let me know. I still get them regularly!

Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by freejazz on Friday December 15, 2023 @05:48PM (#38659810)
Do you actually know any artists or musicians? Any of them that are successful? What you described wouldn't be "selling out," it'd be success. Selling out is the food service job they do to pay their rent, or the lessons they teach, etc. The person you were responding to was pointing out that it's not likely that there is a market for everyone's art, even if everyone was true to their own creative vision.
Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by WalterBright on Friday December 15, 2023 @08:15PM (#38660850)
> Do you actually know any artists or musicians?

Yes, many among family and friends.

> Any of them that are successful?

No.

> What you described wouldn't be "selling out," it'd be success.

"Selling out" is a common epithet leveled at artists who became successful. Nirvana, for example, was often accused of selling out.

Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by freejazz on Saturday December 16, 2023 @01:56PM (#38666763)
Yeah but that wasn't the context the person you were responding to was using it in. By your own example, Nirvana doesn't make any sense as they were tremendously successful doing their thing
Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by WalterBright on Saturday December 16, 2023 @08:05PM (#38669417)
Oh, it certainly is the context. Nirvana had its beginnings and appeal by being uninterested in success and only played to a niche as "their" group. When Nirvana suddenly became wildly successful, that group felt betrayed.

Nirvana is the perfect example of what I was talking about.

Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by freejazz on Monday December 18, 2023 @12:03PM (#38685125)
Yeah, what you were talking about... not what the other poster was talking about. Try to read and understand other's posts.
Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by filoeleven on Friday December 15, 2023 @09:37PM (#38661237)
It’s almost like the idea of “making a living” is what needs disrupting the most. I didn’t ask to be here, and it’s kind of a shit deal for most folks the way things work now. “How many Einsteins” etc.

If the art I’m interested in making doesn’t fit into this “utilitarian” monetary income model, it means that I can only pursue art in my “spare time”, outside of a necessary job and (for lots of us) family obligations. I guess I could become an art star, or a viral sensation, but we all know how unlikely that is for any one person. There’s not much middle ground.

The thing that we have to acknowledge as a culture is that we don’t generally value art, or highly-specific research avenues, or much of anything that isn’t “productive” in the most myopic sense. That’s a cultural choice, and it’s a bad decision. It fits in well with our naked pursuit of short-term optimization at the expense of everything else though, so at least we’re consistent. Yay.

Re:McDonald's ice cream machine hackers say they found 'smok... by WalterBright on Friday December 15, 2023 @10:46PM (#38661535)
Look at the immensity of the music business, hollywood, books, furniture, buildings, landscaping, toys, the shape of my desk phone, and we pay plenty for it! I look around my office and see the work of artists in most everything in it.