News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by robofanatic on Friday December 15, 2023 @10:40AM (#38655196)
thats interesting. So if someone asks you to draw a picture of a lighthouse, are you able to draw it without looking at an actual lighthouse or a picture of it? if yes, then how?
Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by jermaustin1 on Friday December 15, 2023 @11:40AM (#38655832)
Yeah, I can draw one. I actually took a lot of art classes, so it is kind of hardwired into me how to draw. That said, my lighthouse will not have details in it that someone who can recall a photograph of one might. Here is kind of how my brain describes a lighthouse for me to draw it: cone-shaped, white brick, wooden door at base, a platform on top without walls, a small shingled roof, large rotating light.

As I am drawing the lighthouse the part that I'm working on will have more descriptors popup in my inner voice. Like say I'm drawing the door, I will hear: "vertical slats, arched top, dark weathered wood" and as I drill into each of those, I will hear more words in my head.

Maybe I trained myself to do that over many many years of art classes, but I can't remember that not being the case.

Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by namtab00 on Friday December 15, 2023 @12:12PM (#38656150)
hmm that's weird, you forgot that they're usually painted in stripes (red/white?)
Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by jermaustin1 on Friday December 15, 2023 @12:31PM (#38656385)
That is not something I have encountered (I don't think), or if I did, I didn't absorb that detail. The words don't exist in my brain.
Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by dumbo-octopus on Friday December 15, 2023 @12:20PM (#38656235)
That's funny - I also have aphantasia and described it in much the same as the parent. But your comment threw me, I think of them as plain.

Looked it up, and turns out the ones in Oregon are. https://www.bing.com/images/search?q=oregon+lighthouses&form...

Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by in3d on Friday December 15, 2023 @12:19PM (#38656223)
It probably depends on which ones they have encountered in real life. From a Google image search, it seems that less than half are.
Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by polishdude20 on Friday December 15, 2023 @12:48PM (#38656577)
That seems to be the way I see objects in my mind. It starts as a basic formless "idea" of a lighthouse. Vague images come to mind: Tall, pointy, seaside, seagulls, looming. Then I sort of focus on one part of the lighthouse instantly to figure out the details. Like the walls: Brick, painted over with white paint, moss and lichen growing on them. Then the door: Wooden, one handle, thick, dark wood, little peep hole.

Etc.

I never fully visualize it instantly. It's like my mind is creating the details over time. A minute later if you ask me to visualize it again, I still don't see it instantly, I need to remind myself "Oh yeah the door was wooden, the walls were white" etc.

I feel like a lot of differences in people's experience of this is less to do with their actual abilities of visualization and more to do with not being able to describe what is happening and observing yourself as a third party while you're thinking.

Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by Broken_Hippo on Friday December 15, 2023 @03:08PM (#38658196)
my lighthouse will not have details in it that someone who can recall a photograph of one might.

To be fair: most folks don't really remember as many details as you think. Definitely not photo-level. I generally tell folks that you'll be able to draw a bird, sure. Even different kinds of birds - but they will be fairly generic and simple. You'll know it is a duck or goose or little bird or owl. But unless you've studied birds and drawn a lot of them, it won't be a blue jay, an exotic duck, a snowy owl, and so on. Not without a reference picture, of course.

Those reference photos are important enough that I had an art teacher that tasked us with taking reference photos with disposable cameras. This was mid-90s, before phones were everywhere and there were so many resources for such things.

I'll also add that I keep a dialog in my head as I draw. I can visualize well enough, but the 'thinking voice' come along and narrates the things I'm drawing. "Put that line there and go down and across the page...." "Just add that little window down there and remember the handle!"

Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by bongodongobob on Friday December 15, 2023 @04:15PM (#38658933)
I am 100% convinced people who self-diagnose with aphantasia think normal people hallucinate images in their mind. They are just being dense. Unless they've had a MRI, they are just shockingly confused.
Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by mercutio2 on Friday December 15, 2023 @07:31PM (#38660586)
Umm... Are you sure you don't have aphantasia?

When I've asked a room full of people "close your eyes. Think of an elephant. What do you see?", 80% of the people say "I see a rough elephant". I've asked "do you really see it? Like, there are proportions, colors, etc.?" Most people say yes.

When I close my eyes and I do this, I see... nothing but dark eyelids with sparkles.

Are the other people I've asked this of lying? Or are you mistaken that normal people don't have a mind's eye which actually reproduces images?

EDIT: OK, I'm curious. I've created an HN poll. Obviously our readership isn't an unbiased sample, but I'm very interested to learn how different people experience this experiment.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38660632

Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by bongodongobob on Friday December 15, 2023 @07:44PM (#38660671)
The problem is what you mean by "see". It's not using your vision so there's no "overlay" as I'm assuming people expect. Unless someone has been diagnosed with an MRI, I'm not buying it.
Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by Broken_Hippo on Friday December 15, 2023 @08:21PM (#38660887)
It's not using your vision so there's no "overlay" as I'm assuming people expect.

Speak for yourself. Just because it doesn't happen to you doesn't mean it doesn't to others. This is a skill you might be able to develop, if you can visualize already. If you lack resources, you might visit various occult groups for tips. Visualisation is a big part of practice for some people.

An MRI will not "diagnose" you.

Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by bongodongobob on Friday December 15, 2023 @09:12PM (#38661125)
Google aphantasia MRI.
Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by Broken_Hippo on Saturday December 16, 2023 @08:53AM (#38664197)
Ok. I did.

"Yet, there is no consensus on whether aphantasia should really be described as a 'condition', and there is no battery of psychometric instruments to detect or 'diagnose' aphantasia. Instead, researchers currently rely on the Vividness of Visual Imagery Questionnaire (VVIQ) to 'diagnose' aphantasia." [1]

There is not a test that can realistically be relied on. At least one of the top results was someone getting an MRI because of sudden aphantasia. At least one of them was about mouse studies.

And I'll just go back to what I've said: You can't get diagnosed with an MRI, and honestly it'd probably be irresponsible to do so since folks with actual issues need the MRI (aphantasia generally seems to be a simple difference in the way one thinks rather than an actual condition. More akin to which hand is dominant than to anything physically wrong).

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8186241/

Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by bongodongobob on Monday December 18, 2023 @11:56AM (#38685043)
I completely agree and think it's nonsense.
Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by goatlover on Friday December 15, 2023 @08:35PM (#38660951)
The visual experience happens in your brain, not your eyes. There's multiple ways to have a visual experience. It doesn't have to come from the optic nerve.
Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by Broken_Hippo on Friday December 15, 2023 @08:19PM (#38660872)
Seriously: How is someone else going to diagnose you with it? If not self-diagnosed, how is it done? Do you think there is a test? And MRI generally isn't going to tell you this (this article was research on mice, after all) and even if it did, it would be fairly irresponsible to use up medical resources on something like this.

And sometimes, yeah, they might - especially with the way some folks describe it. It is very difficult to describe such things to other people who do not experience them.

Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by bongodongobob on Saturday December 16, 2023 @06:19AM (#38663443)
I mean, how is someone else able to diagnose any mental condition? Why do you ask this as if it can't be done?

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8186241/

Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by rhinoceraptor on Friday December 15, 2023 @11:11AM (#38655528)
I also have it, I can draw a lighthouse because I know what it should look like. But if I close my eyes and try to visualize it, I don't have any sense that I'm seeing something, in the same way that I have a sense that I'm listening to a song when I play it back from memory.

When I dream there's only a faint visual component, there's no color or detail.

Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by magicalhippo on Friday December 15, 2023 @11:52AM (#38655942)
Same.

Also, when reading fiction, I never have any use for the long-winded descriptions of a place and a character. I don't picture the scene or character, but I create my own "space" where I can place the characters and the action, and I can feel beeing there. This "space" can have details, but usually not a lot.

Recalling memories are similar. I can vividly feel the moment, and I can remember a lot of non-visual details, and often some distinct visual details. But I can't really picture it.

Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by dumbo-octopus on Friday December 15, 2023 @12:22PM (#38656255)
> I never have any use for the long-winded descriptions of a place and a character.

Same, and oh my goodness did my teachers in High School chastise me for not wanting to produce those same strings of adjectives in my own works. I fundamentally could not understand why someone would want to read that much description about the appearance of something.

Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by namtab00 on Friday December 15, 2023 @12:13PM (#38656161)
now that I think of it, in my dreams colors are not something I recall, but I definitely can say that I don't dream in greyscale..
Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by the_af on Friday December 15, 2023 @12:36PM (#38656435)
Would you be able to go beyond the abstract notion of a lighthouse (basic geometric shape, white with red stripes, etc) and without a reference know where to paint shadows, how to dither them, how to achieve some "weathering effects", marks left by the water, etc?

My guess is that kind of "untrained intuitions" about drawing require two preconditions:

1. Having seen lighthouses or buildings and paid attention to how rust/marks/decay and the interplay of light and shadow looks like.

2. Being able to visualize this when drawing.

Otherwise, how can the drawing (without a photo reference) be anything but idealized and abstract?

Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by Karawebnetwork on Friday December 15, 2023 @10:44AM (#38655239)
There's actually a few interesting articles out there about this: https://theconversation.com/the-art-of-aphantasia-how-mind-b...

"Edinburgh: “I can remember visual details,” he commented, “but I can’t see them”."

In this one, they show step by step how the artist does it: https://aphantasia.com/article/stories/visual-artist-with-ap...

Re:What Happens in the Brain While Daydreaming? by tiborsaas on Friday December 15, 2023 @11:34AM (#38655771)
It's stored conceptually and I don't need to recall it visually to copy it to paper.