The remaining startups will need to find a middle ground of some sort.
And why couldn't there be 100 or 1000 times as many public companies? Stranger things have happened in history.
They would need to be smaller or the economy would need to be bigger. Ties in with your other essay.
Efficiency and reason tend to win in the end. There is much to be gained by having less bureaucracy and red tape for public companies, assuming that they are public companies of a different type than what they are today.
1 - Assuming the capital gains tax remains similar to what it is currently.
And incidentally, I don't see why it's easy to upper bound wealth creation over any time period. If everyone woke up tomorrow and started working twice as hard, what would limit their output?
But isn't the entire YC experience designed to get angels and VCs at demo day to make an investment in each company?
demand and supply, as always
it is trivial for some hypothetical foobar corp to spit out twice as many widgets as they do now. but why would they? without viable demand, they indeed show a loss for their effort-spurt. as you heard the CEO of ford say today, oversupply was a major problem for the automakers. working twice as hard will kill you if you don't have twice the demand
the better question is how currency growth can be employed to stimulate demand over a period of time. growth comes from healthy inflation (3-5%). inflation is always a monetary phenomenon. this is why you will often hear opponents of "secured" currencies (gold etc) tell you that you can't get growth in an economy in the mid term unless you have a fiat currency.
Or that they already have them? In the U.S., isn't the ratio of eligible driving population to drivable autos approaching 1? So, twice as many cars would likely not find buyers and drive down prices a lot.
Sorry if I'm missing the bigger picture stuck on this specific detail.
(Of course, if you think about this carefully enough, the distinction between "more" stuff and "better" stuff falls apart.)
monetary cycles typically manifest over an eighteen month period. i.e. the increase or decrease in Fed policy would impact demand directly likely no less than a year. the only way to dramatically alter this...i.e. to actually get people to wake up and work twice as hard takes drastic currency action.
this is all undergrad economics
Edit: one might also expect current economic conditions to accelerate this process, since downturns are harder on inefficient players than efficient ones. It occurred to me the other day that for this reason, downturns are a healthy part of the economic system, kind of like forest fires in ecosystems.
no there isn't. come back in five years, the top ten internet companies will control 95% of all traffic and 99% of all revenues. this market has almost zero friction...how is it that google has already sewn up over 80% of ad revenues on the web? where are all the mom-and-pop ad networks? they're on deaths door
by the same token anyone can build a PC...so what happened to the 10,000 little PC makers that used to be in every strip mall? today we have basically three pc makers....hp, dell, apple. so much for "low barrier to entry = high res"
The fact that some markets have matured and been commoditized hardly implies that there is no new value to be created.
Ultimately, there's no strategic advantage to be gained by entering an industry where the barrier to entry is so low that everyone can do it. When you're competitor N+1 in a market like that, your only hope is to compete on efficiency (i.e. the Dell model), or novelty (i.e. the Apple model). Otherwise, you're just a guy in a strip mall, selling beige boxes; you might make a living from it, but you're not going to get rich.
In short, don't think of the PC industry -- think of the teriyaki restaurant industry. It's cheap to open a teriyaki joint, and anyone can do it, but unless you're going to serve gourmet teriyaki, or find a way to produce it for less (/shudder/), it's not the place that you want to be as an aspiring entrepreneur.
Obviously, one of the ways to get rich is to create a new market and exploit it. But that's probably not as easy as building the better Teriyaki restaurant, judging by how rarely lucrative new markets emerge.
They are not the same thing.
(Seriously: I am not a pessimist, but compared to some of the wild-eyed optimism that gets thrown around here, I may sometimes seem like one. My world view is that, given a choice, you should live life in a way that maximizes health, happiness and satisfaction, not money. Start a company because you want to work for yourself, not because you want to get rich -- because you probably won't.
If your whole goal when starting a project is to achieve fame and fortune, you will go through life in an almost perpetual state of disappointment. If, instead, you make choices that allow you to live a good life now, you'll be happier by definition.)
A good list (including more than web) is at http://startup.partnerup.com/2008/01/02/2007-acquisitions-we...
Seriously, I think over-supply of start-ups will crash prices. Yes, there is no limit to wealth creation, but even so, it is easy to upper-bound wealth creation over, say, the next 5 years. We can say with confidence there won't be more than, say, $10 billion worth of web start-up acquisitions over the next 5 years (in total, not per year) - that was about the total in the last 5 I would estimate and I think I am being fairly optimistic here. Even that $10 billion would be parceled out in the 80-20 rule - a couple of YouTube home runs, a few singles and doubles, and the remaining mass of start-ups have to fight over a fairly small pot of gold.
My objection is consistent with economic theory: over-supply leads to serious price crashes, even when you make the favorable assumption (which is not exactly true in the start-up case) that in the long run, the over-supply can be absorbed.