Freud taught that early childhood experience has a profound impact on adult life. Did anyone have this perspective before Freud? Was there a precedent? If I think of literary depictions of childhood in the 19th century, for example in Dickens, there can be great pathos, but not a psychological awareness of the consequences.
This emphasis on early childhood experience is tectonic in Western culture and we still haven't caught up to it in practice. If it really was Freud's contribution, that alone makes him great.
Another dimension of Freud is that he was a taboo-breaker, and in that sense a heroic figure. Some of the steps he dared to take are still so out-there that they can't be openly discussed. That's pretty remarkable after a hundred years.
Such as?
Freud's insight wasn't about training children—it was about the psychological impact of early relational experience. What we now believe about childhood trauma, for example, or the idea that later relationships are patterned after what happened in one's family of origin—all of this, unless I'm mistaken, derives from Freud.
As smeeth was pointing out, it's easy to see things that Freud got wrong, and not so easy to see what he got right, because they have become so foundational that even Freud's staunchest critics take them for granted.
Psychiatry is a branch of medicine. Psychology isn't.
On the other hand, Pavlov became famous for the positive reinforcement study he developed to optimize a brutal methodo to extract dog drool, but somehow the animal abuse part was mostly ignored for a long time.
You can't choose what part of your work will become more popular or the most common association with your name...
It’s ironic you say this. Like Freud, and unlike Newton, alchemists did not use scientific methodology. Also like Freud, alchemists get an unfair treatment by modern society, being remembered only for their mistakes. Medieval alchemists developed and refined distillation and crystallization, discovered acids and minerals, and developed metallurgy through the extraction of metals from ore. Just like psychology after Freud, the scientific field of chemistry grew rather naturally out of the advances made in alchemy.
The unconscious mind, dream interpretation, importance of early childhood, psychosexual development, talk therapy as we know it today, transference, etc.
What do we remember him for? Oedipus complex. Poor guy. It's like if all we remembered about Newton was alchemy.