News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by fngjdflmdflg on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:24PM (#38630695)
The correlation of IQ with income is 0.30[0]. Educational attainment is 0.32. So if you are intelligent (talented) or educated then you are statistically likely to have above average income. If you have both even more so.

[0] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01602... (https://sci-hub.se/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.intell.2007.02....) page 5 table 1.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by SketchySeaBeast on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:40PM (#38631024)
I didn't read the paper, but are we sure that A (wealth/education) follows B (IQ) and not vice versa?
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by fngjdflmdflg on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @01:09PM (#38631522)
We are almost sure that genetics (and perhaps nutrition) are the main determinants of IQ. We won't have a complete answer until most of the genes that affect intelligence are found. With regard to your specific question of if educational attainment is the main factor in causing IQ to increase, that would mean that everyone at high-school would have the same IQ because they all have the same educational attainment (inasmuch as what "educational attainment" means in this paper). Wealth of one's parents is a harder problem. I believe that it is not a significant contributing factor beyond not being malnourished. This is based on the fact that the average IQ of some poor countries is higher than the average IQ of some richer countries. But like I said a complete solution to this problem, or – more boldly – an answer that blank-slatists would have no choice but to accept, would involve a more complete understanding of the genetic component including most genes as well as relevant ncDNA sequences.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by SketchySeaBeast on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @01:55PM (#38632365)
Even if genetics is the "main determinant" what does that mean? Is it the the plurality of determinants? 51% correlation? 99%? Depending on the number, there's lots of room there for other factors.

I think you're oversimplifying with your example regarding educational attainment. The results say it's not a 1:1, so not all high school students would be marked the same, but it would mean that if you finished your post doc you're likely to score higher than someone who didn't complete grade 9. Would we argue that graduating high school or going on to do graduate work is simply as a matter of intelligence and not a more complex web of economic, social, and cultural factors?

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by fngjdflmdflg on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:35PM (#38633038)
I think you missed my point re. educational attainment. My point is that if education attainment only exists as a difference after high-school (for the most part). Therefore if "IQ follows educational attainment" IQ would be the same until after high-school. I do think wealth, nutrition and education have some effect on IQ. I do not know to what extent. You had asked if we are sure that IQ follows those other factors. To answer completely, IQ follows genetics as well as other factors, mainly genetics. I truly believe that this is a scientific question that can be answered with observation. I think in twenty years or less we will have cataloged most of the genes that affect intelligence and the nature vs. nurture argument will have a direct answer. (or, at least, the nature side of the equation will be mostly solved.) Currently the hardware to collect this data is expensive (Illumina machines are $1M last I checked) and the methods of analyzing the data are somewhat crude (eg. GWAS). As these two fronts advance more and more genes will be found until most of it is known.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by shkkmo on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @01:35PM (#38632014)
Genetics account for roughly half of the variation of intelligence between individuals.

That leaves a ton of room for other factors, such as nutrition, health, and education, to create significant disparities.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by PeterisP on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:56PM (#38634016)
My subjective impression from the correlation studies that I have seen is that the remainder largely is a long list of purely negative factors - i.e. in the "nurture" stage there are many ways to screw up the development of children with a large impact, but limited ways to meaningfully improve it over the genetic 'baseline'.

I.e. the correlation of nutrition in IQ is mostly driven by malnutrition, not by differences between great nutrition and mediocre nutrition; the impact of parenting is heavily driven by the outlier cases of severe abuse or deprivation, not the differences between great parenting and mediocre parenting, the impact of peer groups is largely set by the minority of cases that result in severe addiction or gang membership, not the difference between lousy friends and great friends, etc - that's the pattern that I seem to see there.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by fngjdflmdflg on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:20PM (#38632768)
Do you have a source for that claim? Might you be misquoting a different popular statistic that g accounts for roughly have of intelligence between individuals? Or perhaps the figure that intelligence is about 50% heritable?[0] It is important to note that heritability of a trait and the extent to which a trait is genetically caused are not the same. It is possible for a trait to be eg. 80% caused by genetics and only 60% heritable, even on the average. This can be the case where the trait is defined by multiple genes (and non-coding DNA) where the proportion of the different genes matters and where specific combinations of genes are necessary. Also heritability of intelligence has been reported as higher than 75%.

[0] Eg. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41380-021-01027-y#Sec8

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by shkkmo on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:37PM (#38633061)
I pulled that number from this article and I am pretty sure I paraphrased it correctly: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/is-intelligence-h...

The article may be conflating genetics with other types of biological hereditability, (such as epigenetics?) however I think that is generally pretty common and fine in every lay conversations.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by PeterisP on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:29PM (#38633729)
If you control for socioeconomic status of the parents (which does have a big impact and definitely has to be controlled for, and is controlled for in every reasonable study), the socioeconomic status and educational attainment of the kids is still correlated with their IQ.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by 0xbadcafebee on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:01PM (#38634085)
Since men make more money than women, does that mean men are smarter than women?

Hmmmmmmmm. Maybe statistics isn't the crystal ball it seems.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by roflyear on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:07PM (#38633467)
IQ tests are not exactly designed for poor people, eh?
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by kapp_in_life on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:15PM (#38637710)
Are they not? Most I've seen tend to be sorts of abstract pattern matching things. As opposed to basing IQ on ability to play piano or other traits less prevalent in poor communities.

Obviously nothing is perfect but it seems disingenuous to claim they're not designed for poor people to be able to complete them.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by jack2312 on Friday December 15, 2023 @01:39AM (#38651634)
I don't believe that IQ tests are designed with a bias for or against the poor, so I'm not going to argue either side of that.

I would like to point out however that poverty (or even a hypothetical worry about financial matters) has been shown to reduce fluid intelligence (which IQ tests measure) significantly. This is because people facing poverty have less mental bandwidth. The effect is strong enough to bring a person with "superior" IQ down to "average", or an "average" IQ down to "borderline deficient".

If you're interested in the subject, I'd highly recommend the book _Scarcity_ by Sendhil Mullainathan and Eldar Shafir. If you'd like a shorter and more concise version, there's also an article titled "The Science of Scarcity" [0] in Harvard Magazine about the book that summarizes it quite well.

I'm not an expert on the subject though, so if anyone has reference to any evidence that poverty has no effect on IQ testing, I'd (sincerely) be interested to see it, to get a different perspective.

[0]: https://www.harvardmagazine.com/2015/04/the-science-of-scarc...

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by Cpoll on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:32PM (#38630838)
That's correlation at best (as you said, but worth emphasizing).

And IQ is a problematic metric for anything other than how good you are at taking IQ tests.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by RationalDino on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:42PM (#38631072)
IQ measurement definitely has major flaws.. But IQ is better correlated with job performance than job interviews are.

As they say, perfect is the enemy of good. IQ tests are good. We do ourselves no favors by attempting to downplay what standardized testing tells us.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by 10xDev on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:59PM (#38631360)
After a point, say 130 IQ, the differences between people's capacity become intangible. But there is certainly a big difference between someone under 80 IQ and someone with 130 IQ, which is why the US military doesn't even accept individuals under 80 IQ.