News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by dubcanada on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @03:00PM (#38617576)
Israel's response tends to stem from a history of oppression which is where it gets touchy. Jewish have not exactly been treated well for most of the 20th century. Not saying that is a reason to invoke that upon someone else, but it tends to be where most thoughts come from. A sense of if we don't do something we'll lose "our" home.
Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by stoorafa on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @03:31PM (#38617997)
That’s an interesting parallel, Gazan’s response is also borne of a history of oppression. Living with food insecurity, being an intergenerational refugee unable to return to home a few miles away, watching family members harmed, etc seems to motivate a lot of Palestinian behavior.
Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by ifdefdebug on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @04:27PM (#38618818)
"being an intergenerational refugee" is one of the most absurd problems that exist in this conflict. Nobody should be a refugee just because their grandparents were. They should be plain citizens of whatever region they were born in.

If we extrapolate this stance to other past conflicts, we'd have today tens of millions of German "intergenerational" refugees sitting in Germany and waiting for their return to their home a few miles away, across the Oder river.

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by Georgelemental on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @08:05PM (#38621274)
Yes, that's why the Palestinians need a proper state of their own, so the absurdity can end.
Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by lolinder on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @08:45PM (#38621609)
The idea that every nation needs a state (and every state exists to serve one nation) is part of the absurdity! It's what got us into this mess in the first place—the Jews needed a state of their own because the rest of us couldn't stand to let them make their home near us.

The problem of intergenerational refugees will not be solved by carving out a new state and shipping everyone back there.

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by natch on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @04:54PM (#38619201)
Their ancestors lost their homes when they needlessly started, and then lost, a war against people who owned land outright and others who moved onto the land only after the UN divided it and gave a vast proportion of it to Jordan, and part to Israel… ancestors who also abandoned their land after the war defeat on the advice of their warlike leaders. The ones who stayed behind became Israeli (Arab muslims, Christians, etc.) and kept their land as long as they held valid documented title to it, and many of those who made that move (or whose parents did) say they would prefer to live under Israeli rule versus PA rule. The Youtuber TravelinIsrael has some good videos on history about this.

Obviously there are also modern alleged losses of land and homes but each case has its own details. In some, Israelis (often settlers) are clearly in the wrong, but in others, it is less clear and more disputed than common rhetoric about “oppression” and “occupation” would imply.

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by metta2uall on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @06:20PM (#38620219)
"Their ancestors lost their homes when they needlessly started, and then lost, a war" - the Palestinian villagers did not start any wars - the war was started by the rulers of neighboring states...
Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by Georgelemental on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @08:18PM (#38621392)
> moved onto the land only after the UN divided it

Why should people who have lived in an area for generations heed the dictates of nations thousands of miles away?

> ancestors who also abandoned their land after the war defeat on the advice of their warlike leaders.

This is a gross misrepresentation of what actually happened. A full accounting won't fit in an HN comment, but it's beyond question that many Palestinians were expelled at gunpoint from homes they had been living in for generations. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1948_Palestinian_expulsion_fro...

Personally, I would recommend the series "Fear and Loathing in the New Jerusalem" [0]. The guy behind it is a former US DoD contractor who worked for many years with the IDF, friends with Israeli soldiers, etc, but who is also married to a woman with Palestinian relatives. It's extremely well-researched, and explains the motivations of all the players without exculpating any side.

[0]: https://martyrmade.com/fear-loathing-in-the-new-jerusalem/

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by natch on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:41PM (#38622752)
This debunks some of the false narrative:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P8bkqqvoGpc

You may criticize him for taking a side.

On the other hand, I prefer that to someone who just pretends to be even handed.

For the record, I listen to the viewpoints of plenty of people on the other side, as well. But I'm afraid I find their narrative doesn't hang together.

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by Georgelemental on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:38AM (#38623124)
I watched the video, thanks.

I would recommend again the series I linked in my previous comment. The series creator says at one point, that had he been born a Jew, he would have been a hardcore Zionist; conversely, had he been born a Palestinian, he would have been a hardcore supporter of that side. One of the things the series does so well is, instead of presenting the history as a debate between two camps that needs to have a winner and loser, it tells the story. For all the major players in the story, it tells you not only what they did, but why they did it, and how they came to believe what they believe. And then it asks you what you would have done in their situation. After you've stared that question in the face, it's impossible to really hate either side IMO.

It's a long series, many hours of listening, but absolutely worth every second. Hooked me from the first few minutes. You won't regret it!

I'll leave you with a speech: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moshe_Dayan%27s_eulogy_for_Ro%...

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by natch on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:28PM (#38622655)
You are correct, in addition to those who decided to abandon their land, there are others who were expelled because their side started a war they lost, in which Israel captured vast amounts of territory, and expelled people on the losing side from that territory in some cases. As you yourself said, a full accounting won't fit; there's a lot more that can be said about history here.

The podcast person married into a Palestinian family thinks that Israel's founding consisted of Jews coming from Europe. Certainly many Jews came from Europe but many already lived in their homeland of Israel decades or more before modern Israel was founded, and many tens of thousands if not hundreds of thousands came from nearby Arab countries, where true actual genocide against them was underway and was carried through (you can count the results today in the demographics of nearby countries as compared to prior to the many pograms). Golda Meir herself was Palestinian.

There are flaws on both sides. But I'll take the side who doesn't r**e with family members cheering them on. Sickening. Of course, saying that they haven't had an easy time would be a huge understatement. Some of it is self inflicted, starting wars and conflicts, but they also have been lied to about the most fundamental things, and about history. And so I would take everything in that podcast with a grain of salt, especially given that it only took reading the summary of Episode 1 to find wild distortions.

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by Georgelemental on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:43AM (#38623174)
> many already lived in their homeland of Israel decades or more before modern Israel was founded

He actually devotes a lot of time in the podcast to this. Don't judge by a one-paragraph blurb.

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by ignoramous on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @08:55PM (#38621690)
> beyond question that many Palestinians were expelled at gunpoint from homes

You'd surprised how many out right reject this ever happened, including some prominent "Zionists" in tech. There's some alternate reality that some of us were simply not part of, but yet find ourselves with them in this shared reality.

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by ngcazz on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:33AM (#38623817)
It's a matter of public record and well articulated by Ilan Pappé at the very least, that the Zionists were intent on capturing Palestine for themselves and removing everyone they could by any means necessary. If they could buy out the properties they would, but as they faced mounting resistance they resorted to violence. Ben-Gurion and his ilk were criminals even if lionized
Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by hef19898 on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @03:16PM (#38617785)
That explains what happened in 50s and 60s. Leveling Gaza in 2023 doesn't fall in that category, Hamas never had the power to do anything about Israel's existence as a state.
Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by lolinder on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @03:33PM (#38618027)
From the perspective of Israel's defense forces, Hamas doesn't have that power because Israel responds the way it does. I'd imagine that for many in Israel the lesson of the 60s is that if given an opening all of their neighbors will attack, so Israel cannot ever be seen as responding lukewarmly to an attack, even one by a party that couldn't destroy them singlehandedly.

(I'm not arguing that this position is correct, just trying to explain another possible perspective.)

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by hef19898 on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @03:40PM (#38618151)
That's the problem, isn't it? If you put yourself in the shoes of either side, you can see how they have very good reason to do what they do (except Israelian settlement policies, those basically amount to borderline ethnic cleansing, and force the IDF to move in after the fact, but that's a different beast).

And since both sides are "right", there is no way this can end without outside intervention. An intervention that won't come, becaues nobody who could intervene is neutral enough, nor willing to be drawn into this.

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by falserum on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @05:16PM (#38619454)
It’s multigenerational vendeta. Both sides have what to avenge for.

Three ways how piece can be achieved here:

- side a is wiped out

- side b is wiped out

- both sides turn the other cheek and shake hands.

Both sides know that, and neither of them believe in cheeky business.

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by hef19898 on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @05:32PM (#38619640)
I saw an interview a while ago of an Israeli father who lost his kid in one of the previous wars, and who now works a Palestinian father, who also lost his kid, in order to find a peaceful solution. He confirmed your point by saying, I paraphrase, "we are doomed to live share this land together, or the graveyard under it".

I really, really hope it will be tze "cheely" solution, the alternatives are, unfortunately, very much imaginable and incredibly painful and ugly.

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by prewett on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @06:00PM (#38620001)
Sadly, both have to be willing to forgive for option 3 to work, so even if one side would be willing to, they are stuck unless the other side is also willing.
Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by bloaf on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @05:45PM (#38619806)
I disagree. Palestinian terrorism is objectively counterproductive and driven by unreasonable domestic politics, not reasonable geopolitics.

You can't be a successful politician in Palestine with a position of "lets make concessions to Israel so we can stop suffering." The only successful politicians for the past 60-odd years have been the ones promising to fight Israel and get the Palestinians their stuff back.

The problem is that Palestine as a state has no military, economic, cultural or geopolitical bargaining chips to get their stuff back.

That means every successful Palestinian politician is elected with a mandate to "get our stuff back" but without the means to do it. So they have two options: either make concessions to get some stuff back, or try to fight.

If they make concessions, they lose their grip on power to the groups saying "Those guys are giving away stuff to Israel! We'll get your stuff back!"

If they try to fight a conventional war they lose in a matter of weeks (evidently.) So their only option is to fight just enough that their constituents are convinced they're doing a good job, but not so much that Israel wipes them out. Hence, the 60-year history of terrorism and targeting civilians.

In conclusion:

Palestinians need to make concessions for peace so that they can accumulate the bargaining chips they need to get their stuff back from Israel. They are not doing that because the Palestinian people will not support any leaders that pursue that strategy; they believe violence is a viable means of getting their stuff back even though that has been factually incorrect for the past 60 years. It is possible that the geopolitical landscape may change in the future, and violence becomes a viable option, but wasting resources on fruitless wars does not help change it.

Therefore it is not true that both sides have very good reasons to do what they do.

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by ignoramous on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @09:04PM (#38621762)
> I disagree.

The armed struggle hasn't done them any favours, yes. Neither has peace (Oslo).

> The problem is that Palestine as a state has no military, economic, cultural or geopolitical bargaining chips to get their stuff back.

Hamas agreed to 1967 borders back in 2017. PLO has long given up armed struggle.

> If they make concessions, they lose their grip on power to the groups saying "Those guys are giving away stuff to Israel! We'll get your stuff back!"

A typical racist characterisation.

  Arab male or female is continually fair game to either poke fun at, or more seriously, be confined to and judged by a representation that is either inherently bad, angry, irrational or stupid, misogynistic or repressed, exotic or lascivious.
https://www.runnymedetrust.org/blog/hooked-on-arab-stereotyp...

> So their only option is to fight just enough that their constituents are convinced they're doing a good job

You make it sound like Palestinians want war in perpetuity. Such a hateful rhetoric. How many Palestinians do you personally know?

> Palestinians need to make concessions for peace so that they can accumulate the bargaining chips they need to get their stuff back from Israel

Not so quick: https://www.972mag.com/trump-peace-plan-apartheid/

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by bloaf on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @09:34PM (#38621941)
> Neither has peace (Oslo).

The peace was immediately undermined by groups who did not want to stop fighting. Look, the wikipedia article on the 1996 palestinian general election following the accords literally says, quote:

    The Islamist Hamas, Fatah's main rival, refused to participate in the election; they felt that doing so would lend legitimacy to the PNA, which was created out of *what they called unacceptable negotiations and compromises with Israel.* [0]
> ["Those guys are giving away stuff to Israel! We'll get your stuff back!" is] A typical racist characterisation.

This is well documented history, see above for one such example. I know there are people out there who think we actually have an obligation to alter historical facts to avoid coming to uncomfortable conclusions, but I am not interested in debating that view here, if an honest accounting of the facts makes me racist in your eyes, so be it.

> You make it sound like Palestinians want war in perpetuity. Such a hateful rhetoric.

Of course not, they want their stuff back. I'm pointing out that they have consistently chosen a way of going about it that is actually preventing them from getting what they want.

Again, this is based purely on the actual history of the past 60 years where every Palestinian government has reverted to allowing anti-Israel violence because the public will not allow criticism of the fight to get their stuff back. As an example, the PA of today had to walk back its criticism of Hamas' Oct 7 attack after public backlash [1]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1996_Palestinian_general_elect...

[1] https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/abbas-appears-t...

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by ignoramous on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @10:25PM (#38622271)
> if an honest accounting of the facts makes me racist in your eyes, so be it.

Your mischaracterisation is racist. You may or may not be. I can't judge on back of just this one interaction.

> I know there are people out there who think we actually have an obligation to alter historical facts

Bill Clinton lamented Bibi's election, and called him out for specifically sabotaging the peace process after the initial unrest, once the parties were back at the negotiation table: https://foreignpolicy.com/2011/09/22/bill-clinton-netanyahu-...

> Of course not, they want their stuff back.

Who wouldn't? You make it sound like this is unreasonable. Last I checked, '67 borders, reparations, and a right of return for some small percentage of the refugees, and they are good?

> the PA of today had to walk back its criticism of Hamas' Oct 7 attack after public backlash

If one were in Pal shoes, pretty sure they'd hate an occupying force with all their might. This Haaretz article explains their possible psychological state after close to 3 decades of humiliation: https://archive.is/rLq02

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by bloaf on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:06PM (#38622520)
> Bill Clinton lamented Bibi's election

I'm not saying Israel is blameless. But you must recall Bibi was literally elected because Palestinians began a wave of suicide bombings right before the Israeli elections, which swayed their electorate towards a hard-liner. I.e. the violent Palestinian groups could not be controlled by the peaceful-er ones, and their terrorism ended up being counter-productive.

> Who wouldn't? You make it sound like this is unreasonable.

I am making no value judgements about their goals. I am asserting that their method for achieving those goals is not rational insofar as it is counterproductive.

> pretty sure they'd hate an occupying force with all their might

Being really emotional doesn't make your decisions rational. I'm not telling Palestinians to love their enemies. I'm telling them to pick their battles and not take losing fights.

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by ignoramous on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:27PM (#38622648)
> I'm not saying Israel is blameless. But you must recall Bibi was literally elected...

Agree, and his 2 decades led to apartheid, continued violation of Oslo, and flirting dangerously with the Temple Mount status quo... culminating in 7 Oct. Which is why I pointed out it was wrong to call out Pals as unreasonable and irrational (a typical stereotype, co-opted by the IDF https://archive.is/P4PyJ) when the fault is with both the sides.

(The Jordanian King shouldn't have endorsed Bibi at the time he did, which apparently tipped polls in his favour against Peres)

> asserting that their method for achieving those goals... I'm telling them to pick their battles and not take losing fights

True. The reason why Israeli far-right loves propping up Hamas. The extremists on the either side feed on each other. Remains to be seen what comes after the current situation. Sincerely hope 67 borders and it is done. Have a feeling West Bank and E Jerusalem settlers and their billionaire American donors won't like it.

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by hef19898 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @01:51AM (#38623566)
And then there was Rabin, the Israeli Prime Minister who actually wanted peace. He was assassinated. Guess what, the assassins were right wing Israelis and not Palatinians or Hamas.
Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by bloaf on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @01:07PM (#38631492)
Whether the Israeli's decisions are reasonable is a completely separate topic, and I think the answer is less clear.

Because Palestine has no bargaining chips, a peace deal will involve Israel making unilateral concessions to Palestine, i.e. charity. Israel will relinquish territory where it currently is the de-facto owner, and agree to put new limits on its treatment of the Palestinians. Palestine will continue to receive a great deal of international aid which it could use to rebuild quite quickly if at peace, and they could easily choose to rebuild into a more credible threat to Israel.

In exchange, Israel gets:

Maybe improved relations with their Arab neighbors. (It could also make things worse; their neighbors may become more openly hostile if their "arm the Palestinians against Israel" strategy is taken off the table)

Slightly improved international relations because the settlements Israel keeps would be legitimized.

Maybe a reduction in terrorism (assuming the Palestinian peace-making faction retains enough power to enforce this).

Maybe a reduction in defense costs (Israel still needs to maintain a large defense force because it is surrounded by potentially hostile countries).

Is that trade worth it for Israel? Its not obvious, and depends on how likely you think the positive outcomes are. This is reflected in their domestic politics, Israelis have supported both doves and hawks over the past 60 years depending on how likely they think a positive peace is, which largely depended on Palestinian behavior.

So while I don't think its worth assassinating people over, I do think reasonable people can come to different conclusions about the appropriateness of peace deals from the Israeli perspective.

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by amluto on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @04:17PM (#38618679)
I think that what’s going on in the minds of those calling the shots on Israel’s side (or at least most of them) is: they’re not trying to level Gaza. They’re trying to fight a war against Hamas, and Hamas is fighting from positions in cities that are often literally on the grounds of or inside what ought to be protected civilian sites: hospitals, mosques, etc. And they are surely making what seems a straightforward tactical calculation: they could send infantry in to try to minimize civilian casualties at enormous cost to their infantry, or they could use their massively superior firepower to just destroy the Hamas positions from a distance.

And the Israeli command feels the need to fight on the ground in the first place because Hamas is holding obviously innocent hostages and shooting militarily-useless but nonetheless quite dangerous explosive-filled rockets over the border. Hamas is goading them very effectively. If Israel could magically snap its fingers to destroy Hamas, get rid of all of Hamas’ weapons, and leave Gazan civilians, buildings and infrastructure alone, of course they would!

One might ask why Hamas is doing any of the above. I don’t think Hamas is at all on the side of the residents of Gaza. Their strategy seems much better explained by some rather different goals: improving their own status in the world, raising money, making a really big show, weakening Israel, seeming and feeling important, and recruiting more militant members. I think that every Gazan civilian injury and death is in Hamas’ favor. Israel making itself look bad is in Hamas’ favor. More Gazans who hate Israel and feel hopeless and marginalized is in Hamas’ favor. So of course Hamas wants to keep holding hostages and randomly blowing stuff up in Israel.

To be clear: I do not think Israel is making an ethically or strategically appropriate decision here. But I understand where they’re coming from.

And I don’t think Hamas is making the right decisions either, ethically or strategically, at least if the goal is making a good, safe life for residents of Gaza.

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by hef19898 on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @04:31PM (#38618869)
Politically, Hamas has something in common with Nethanyahus government: the urge to stay in power. From that perspective, at least for now, both sides, Israels politicak leadership and Hamas leadership, have achieved their goal.

Another thing both have in common: they don't give a fuck about the price other people have to pay in order to achieve that goal.

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by wahnfrieden on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @03:25PM (#38617913)
The Zionist project began long before WW2 (and before WW1)
Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by hef19898 on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @03:30PM (#38617982)
Not sure what that has to do with it. The current conflict between Palsetinians and Israel roots back to the foubdation of Israel as a state after WW2. Which I get, jews came pretty close to extinction, and arguably not a lot of people actually cared about that. Hence the need for a state of their own.

80 years and a bunch of wars, insurgencies, counter-insurgencies, terror and air campaigns later, interseded with a handful of peace initiatives, the situation is truely FUBAR. I am not convinced so that leveling Gaza actually does a lot to solve that problem.

Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by Maken on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @03:43PM (#38618196)
The origins of Israel go back to the post-WW1 Ottoman partition. WW2 just fed them more colonists.
[dead]
Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by Maken on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @03:46PM (#38618239)
If the UN was a properly working organization, it would have intervened long ago to force a ceasefire. But we all know that only applies to very poor countries with no economic or political relevance.
Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by vladgur on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @04:11PM (#38618596)
A ceasefire without releasing hostages? There are still more than a 100 of hostages being held in Gaza to this day?
Re:'Like we were lesser humans': Gaza boys, men recall Israe... by nielsbot on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @04:06PM (#38618531)
I am sad and angry that the US was the sole vetoer of the most recent attempt. Also sad that Israel's vengeful assault on the people of Gaza is enabled and funded by the US.