News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by Agingcoder on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:18PM (#38615204)
How can they block municipal fiber isps ? Or prevent epb from selling services ?
Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by jzb on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:21PM (#38615248)
Many states have laws blocking municipal broadband [1] -- basically regulatory capture in its most blatant.

[1] https://broadbandnow.com/report/municipal-broadband-roadbloc...

Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by surge on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:12PM (#38667721)
The same happened in my state.
Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by thinkingtoilet on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:21PM (#38615251)
I'm sure it's within their regulatory laws to determine what can be rolled out where. Of course, the real question is where are all those free market Republicans in Tennessee when it comes time for the market to compete with their donors?
Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by freedomben on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:33PM (#38615420)
I've lived in a lot of red states, and the same thing repeatedly happens. I've given up trying to change things. For every 1 person who will care, there are 25 who just check that there is an "R" next to the name of the person. Ignorant votes make educated votes irrelevant.
Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by bigstrat2003 on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @02:52PM (#38617463)
If you think Democrats aren't just as corrupt and willing to pass bills that are bad for the people but good for their donors, I have a bridge in Arizona to sell you. The problem here is that the vast majority of public officials are corrupt, not which party they happen to run with.
Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by ProllyInfamous on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @02:58PM (#38617553)
>THE PROBLEM HERE IS THAT THE VAST MAJORITY OF PUBLIC OFFICIALS ARE CORRUPT

Again, for the people in the back!

BRING BACK RANK-CHOICE VOTING (To Tennessee, specifically!)

Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by thinkingtoilet on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @05:07PM (#38619353)
Did I say that? The conversation here was about municipal broadband in Tennessee. Whataboutism isn't helpful for any discussion.
Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by ProllyInfamous on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:30PM (#38615381)
>where are all those free market Republicans in Tennessee when it comes time for the market to compete with their donors?

"Privatize profits, subsidize losses." —My neighbor Tennesseans (when I used to live on Lookout).

Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by Spivak on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @01:17PM (#38616096)
> the real question is where are all those free market Republicans

Blocking public services that naturally have a pricing advantage over private businesses because they're supported by tax dollars. Like if you're gonna drag Republicans for not living up to their free market ideals this really isn't what you should point to.

People said the same thing when they opposed the public option in the '00's and the rationale was the same. "Competing" with government services is just roundabout price controls. I'm zero percent opposed to such things when the market fails to sort itself out but I can see why strict free market adherents wouldn't be on board.

Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by thinkingtoilet on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @01:32PM (#38616310)
ISPs and Pharma companies get subsidies from the government, I don't think your argument holds up here. Just another area that Republicans are happy to be hypocrites on. I would love to see Republicans set out "small government" legislation that removes subsidies to the core businesses in their states but you and I both know that will never happen. A child getting food stamps is an example of our 'welfare state' but it's never the billions that go to agriculture or pharma companies.
Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by ProllyInfamous on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @01:54PM (#38616598)
I laugh often knowing that WalMart is the largest single recipient of "corporate welfare" in this fine state/country. What a term/fact. When my black nephew started working there, they walked him through "applying for foodstamps" as part of his training/onboarding.
Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by p_j_w on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @01:50PM (#38616544)
>Blocking public services that naturally have a pricing advantage over private businesses because they're supported by tax dollars.

That's the stated rationale. The actual reason is that the entirety of Republican economic ideology revolves around the idea that the government isn't capable of providing better service than private companies and municipal broadband shows this to be a complete lie.

Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by NovemberWhiskey on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @02:03PM (#38616748)
Well, firstly, we should acknowledge that municipal broadband isn't a story of completely unmitigated success - there are cases of tremendous failure as well.

I'm also fairly sure that most Republicans would not mind if municipal broadband were run - and competed on - commercial terms.

However, if it's funded by municipal bonds that are backed by general obligation (i.e. all taxpayers subsidize, whether they use the service or not) then that seems obviously a problem to me. Even if they're revenue bonds, they're still implicitly subsidized by tax treatment.

Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by plagiarist on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @02:09PM (#38616820)
The real trick is them being able to claim that with a straight face and then turn around and give subsidies and handouts to the private services.
Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by ProllyInfamous on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @02:59PM (#38617567)
I have always been terrible at the [empathy-lacking] trick.

Oh'shucks, meself. /s

Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by surge on Saturday December 16, 2023 @04:13PM (#38667729)
They weren't using tax dollars. The service is paid for by the bills, its simply not for profit, it just treats the fiber lines like roads and side walks, a common public good. You can even choose your own ISP.
Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by ProllyInfamous on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:29PM (#38615360)
The reason Chattanooga is even allowed to offer fiber internet service is that TECHNICALLY it is for monitoring their power delivery infrastructure, down to each household. Customer internet is just an "additional benefit."

When your power disconnect here (without explanation), somebody from the power company shows up within the hour (to figure out why, then replace any broken hardware). But this is rare, as the "auto switchers" can typically reroute blackouts, restoring service usually within seconds.

Re:Telecom Industry Is Mad Because the FCC Might Examine Hig... by smelendez on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:53PM (#38615722)
US states typically can organize their municipalities, school districts, fire departments, public power agencies, etc. however they want.

If the state constitution doesn’t say otherwise, the legislature can just pass a law saying municipalities can’t get into the internet business and that’s that. This comes up a lot with liberal cities in conservative states.