News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by FredPret on Monday December 11, 2023 @06:46PM (#38607085)
Qualcomm does have a nice margin (20%) [https://valustox.com/QCOM] but this is roughly in line with other big co's in the industry.

Motorola makes 18% [https://valustox.com/MSI]

Broadcom, Nvidia, and even Texas Instruments are around 40%! [https://valustox.com/AVGO, https://valustox.com/NVDA, https://valustox.com/TXN].

Intel and AMD bring up the rear with 1.8% and 0.5%. [https://valustox.com/INTC, https://valustox.com/AMD]

For reference, Apple is at 25% and Tesla is at 11%. https://valustox.com/AAPL, https://valustox.com/TSLA]

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by axlee on Monday December 11, 2023 @06:53PM (#38607147)
It's so weird that an oligopolistic industry with the largest barriers to entry (your average CPU factory will cost $5/10+ billions, and that's just the factory) have the lowest margin, by far. Why is that so?
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by Scoundreller on Monday December 11, 2023 @07:29PM (#38607502)
AMD is fabless since 2008/2009 (and sold its last stake in the subsidiary in 2012):

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/GlobalFoundries

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by gary_0 on Monday December 11, 2023 @07:47PM (#38607647)
You're looking at the wrong company. TSMC has a margin of 40%.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by jandrese on Monday December 11, 2023 @08:53PM (#38608272)
And Intel has just been poorly managed for over a decade now.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by FredPret on Monday December 11, 2023 @07:09PM (#38607310)
It might be that that's not as high of a barrier to entry as it seems. It would cost much more than that to replicate the engineering quality that goes into the Apple system of products for instance.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by lotsofpulp on Monday December 11, 2023 @07:58PM (#38607744)
Also, Apple has lots of products and services to lots of potential buyers it can sell to at lots of price points, whereas a fab owner only has a few buyers and therefore less negotiating power, plus all the buyers are sophisticated and well informed.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by Guvante on Monday December 11, 2023 @07:22PM (#38607446)
They made a ton of money not long ago. 30% in 2021 eye balling it.

But all those factories have to be paid for no matter income.

So if income goes down your profit margin goes to terrible.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by chorsestudios on Monday December 11, 2023 @09:54PM (#38608755)
This particular bump in sales might be attributable to the boom in computer sales resulting from COVID and the surge in WFH.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by bootloop on Monday December 11, 2023 @07:08PM (#38607298)
I guess that is what competition brings to the table.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by asianometry on Monday December 11, 2023 @08:54PM (#38608285)
I cannot speak to AMD, but for the case of Intel, it is hard to be a fast follower. The billion dollar factory translates to hundreds of millions of dollars of depreciation each year - a fixed cost that means declines in revenue hit the bottom line very hard.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by dathinab on Monday December 11, 2023 @09:12PM (#38608425)
While there are not many competitors, they still do (most times) properly compete due to various factors like pressure from their customer (some very very large with the capabilities to become a competition iff they stop innovating and/or become to expensive), but also factors like political pressure to stay ahead of mainland china.

Through TSMC for example has margin >40%. Which isn't that surprising I mean there is not much competition. Intel doesn't (yet) provide their capabilities to anyone else, and the other competition is behind enough to not be an option for many things, especially high end and/or high efficiency.

What is quite fascinating is that while TSMC is a close to monopoly(/duopoly if you count Intel) in many sectors and takes advantage of it they seem to have successfully resisted the common problem of such companies stopping/slowing innovation and similar problem. I'm not sure if it's related to the additional pressure of them being on of the main lifelines for Taiwan or if they have just pretty good management or if it's because they still competition oligopoly main customers do push them to do so.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by chii on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:17AM (#38609805)
i suspect that TSMC doesn't have as big a monopoly as you've made it out to be, not because intel is competing, but because the customers of TSMC are large enough that they "force" the innovation (aka, they "threaten" to not use them if they stop innovating).

Also, TSMC hasn't been around long enough to become the slow behemoths that other big monopolies have become.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by hughesjj on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @02:13AM (#38610567)
I think it's just a matter of 'if you stop innovating, others will catch up quicker than you expect'. It's a continual r&d March, and you don't want to end up like Intel and get stuck on 14nm forever

And Intel was a company that was still shoving billions into r&d, yet still got stuck

So much of the tech industry has Moore's law baked into the supply chain forecasts, so lots of incentive to deliver on it.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by civilitty on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @10:40AM (#38613582)
TSMC doesn’t have a real monopoly, they’re just a few years ahead of everyone else in integrating ASML’s latest tech. Samsung and Intel aren’t very far behind. The more money TSMC charges the more incentive the others have to catch up but they can only move so fast. GlobalFoundries and STMicroelectronics seem stuck in the double digits.

It makes a big difference to a few competitive customers so TSMC gets paid well for that first mover advantage, but yeah it’s not well secured monopoly.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by dathinab on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:03AM (#38624074)
thinking that TSMC is "just" integrating ASML tech is a common but big misconception

ASML tech is a tool, one essential for new better chips but not sufficient

You also need to have a lot of know how about how to best use the tool, integrate it in workflows etc. where TSMC seems to be somehow ahead of Intel.

Additionally the custom tooling in the steps leading up to the use of ASML tooling are also hugely important and TSMC is quite a bit ahead of intel with that. It turned out having multiple different customers with different needs which all collaborate with TSMC to optimize the tools in their workflows.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by ksec on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @03:24AM (#38610791)
AMD they had amortisation assets with the Xilinx acquisition. Otherwise they are doing in the industry standard 20% margin if I remember correctly.

Intel has been burning their cash to try and catch up in both Foundry and CPU business.

Probably better if those % were Non-GAAP numbers. But that is another debate.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by cushychicken on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @07:12AM (#38611174)
Intel’s business model is heavily based on reinvesting almost all profits into research on a node that’s 3-5 years out.

They’ve been betting the farm on delivering the highest performance chips on the market for the last 25 years.

For many years, they were unopposed technically. Now, though, their technological advantage is starting to erode.

Intel is in deep shit as a business. How much runway they have is anyone’s guess. But they’re in trouble.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by amadeuspagel on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @08:22AM (#38611745)
Margins are not determined by how many companies sell certain products, but rather by willing the individual buyer is to consider different products. Both Apple and Microsoft can charge high prices for MacOS and Windows, because most Mac and Windows users will not consider another OS. But most people who currently use a laptop with an Intel chip will consider a laptop with an AMD chip, and vice versa, even speaking of an Intel user or an AMD user feels wrong.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by RugnirViking on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @08:51AM (#38612028)
> Margins are not determined by how many companies sell certain products

Rule 1: Margins are as large as a company can get away with them being

Rule 2: The primary thing that brings down prices (thereby shifting consumer demand) is another company competing offering lower prices

Rule 3: Fewer companies are able to maintain a unified front of higher-than-required margins for longer, owing to fewer individuals needing to agree to make the prsioner's-dilemma-esque status quo hold. Any one of them can take business from the others by lowering their prices, but at the cost of reduced margins for everyone (including themselves).

Margin pricing in general is "sticky". When it goes down, its difficult for it to rise. That's why companies jump on inflation as an excuse to raise prices - usually much more than inflation. Similarly, see power prices in Europe after ukraine war - record profits despite attributing price rise to rising supply chain costs.

Yes, this doesn't follow your economics 101. This is economics 102.

As soon as there is an "excuse", companies make massive profits and margins rise. This will also cut into demand as price-sensitive consumers drop out. This is seen as fine. Sometimes, it is better to make more money from less work than grow less efficiently.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by amadeuspagel on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @08:57AM (#38612103)
My economics 101? Your comment is a random rant that doesn't engage with my comment or with the broader discussion.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by RugnirViking on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @09:12AM (#38612282)
it explains why typically markets with fewer players have higher margins. This is why competition is good (and also why the government has whole departments to consider whether mergers in sparse markets will hurt consumers)
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by Madetocomment on Monday December 11, 2023 @06:53PM (#38607150)
The article specifically refers to the patent division of Qualcomm which has margin of 68%
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by fomine3 on Monday December 11, 2023 @09:02PM (#38608354)
I wonder how R&D cost divided into patent and real product cost
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by ChainOfFools on Monday December 11, 2023 @07:28PM (#38607497)
Do you happen to know if it has always been this way, or is this the result of a gradual squeeze to a limit due to megahertz wars, increasingly shortened product cycles, and each companies product line structured in a way that tends to cannibalize their own sales before creating fresh profit.

And the decreasing return, in practical terms, for their customer base when upgrading since most basic computation tasks have long been solved and it's only exotic high-end workloads (plus constant bloat scaling factor that is largely a consequence of the added performance, rather than it's target) that benefit from added performance.

In short, was Intel making percent, or even single digit margins back in the 80s or even early '90s?

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by FredPret on Monday December 11, 2023 @09:57PM (#38608774)
Thats a great question; I'd have to dig into their statements to see more. It's hard to get reliable data from that long ago for free. From what I remember as a consumer, MSFT + INTC (Wintel) absolutely cleaned up in the 90s until AMD started the CPU price & MHz wars, and Apple started making MacBooks.

For Intel, it looks like they kept one dollar out of every four until the recent crash. I don't know the reason for the decline, but I know I wouldn't want to compete against Apple.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by jauntywundrkind on Monday December 11, 2023 @08:35PM (#38608122)
Having margins because no one can legally compete with you is pretty remarkable in the chip industry. No one else has carved out such a large market like this.

The other bit that blows me away is that sometimes it feels like Qualcomm's perpetual inability to integrate chips is a vast submarine point no one using Qualcomm sees coming, but which forever works out in Qualcomm's favor. I don't know how many chips a MediaTek cellular modem takes, but iPhone 15 pro has 6+ chips dedicated to cellular, probably more. Modem, two transceivers, an envelope tracker, and probably a bunch of in this case non-qualcomm power supplies but most probably use Qualcomm pmics, maybe plural. https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/iPhone+15+Pro+Max+Chip+ID/16532... . There's also separate but non-Qualcomm solutions for wifi & bt too, where-as again I rather expect a company like MediaTek has much more working together.

I'm really interested to see chip identifications of the upcoming desktop/server class Qualcomm Oryon, supposedly by the Nuvia team (one of the strongest possible cases for anti-trust I have ever seen). https://www.semiaccurate.com/2023/09/26/whats-going-on-with-... is not partial journalism, but this cavalcade of ridiculousness is entirely the sort of poorly integrated Qualcomm solution I'd expect, that both builds terrible terrible products but which also lets Qualcomm fail upwards by requiring 5x more board components than is reasonable. Terrible for consumers, OEMs are in tears, but oh sorry, your design is late hot over priced and seemed reasonable but you're going to have to add a bunch more pmic's to get to market because we are Qualcomm and we spend more on lawyers than design.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by anitil on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:13AM (#38609790)
> is a vast submarine point

This is an interesting turn of phrase, but I don't understand what it means - are you able to explain? (Google is not helping)

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by stavros on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:29AM (#38609870)
I guess they just mean "a point no one sees coming".
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by ejz on Monday December 11, 2023 @09:34PM (#38608596)
Read the article! Apple and Tesla aren’t the comps. Companies like Intel and Broadcom are. The industry as a whole has a 23% margin.

The 20% margin this year was an anomaly. It’s usually closer to 29%+