Re:Humans have 'large, negative impact on wildlife,' researc...
by davidw on Sunday December 10, 2023 @11:47PM
(#38597723)
Something people seem to struggle to get is that the more you contain human habitat, the better it is for animals.
As in: build smaller, denser cities and leave more land wild outside.
Many people seem to view their large lot with some landscaping that's friendly to a few species that do well in the wildland/urban interface as "environmentalism", without considering the systemic effects of what that would look like if everyone were to live that way, or what its costs are in terms of being car-centric.
Re:Humans have 'large, negative impact on wildlife,' researc...
by defrost on Monday December 11, 2023 @12:15AM
(#38597868)
Some people delibrately purchase large lots with a view to connecting isolated patches of undeveloped forrest areas with native corridors across the acquired land.
Re:Humans have 'large, negative impact on wildlife,' researc...
by xyse53 on Sunday December 10, 2023 @11:43PM
(#38597701)
I had the same thought, then worried I'd be slammed for not reading the article.
The premise of the headline is obvious... But I don't know if I even agree with the actual research. It seems like it's overwhelmingly selection(?) bias. The data seems based on humans bringing in or calling for help on wild animals. They do mention predators but also more on vehicles, etc.
As in: build smaller, denser cities and leave more land wild outside.
Many people seem to view their large lot with some landscaping that's friendly to a few species that do well in the wildland/urban interface as "environmentalism", without considering the systemic effects of what that would look like if everyone were to live that way, or what its costs are in terms of being car-centric.
Of course the animals a human found and took to an animal hospital were likely to have been there because of humans.
People don’t go deep into the wilderness to find injured animals, and those that do tend to leave them there.
This is some extreme sort of selection bias that needs a different name.
Like how many raccoons are eaten by coyotes?
There is a serious philosophical problem with the concept of “negative impact” here. And the core concept of the research.
The conclusions of the actual paper were more actionable steps towards policy (and selection bias is mentioned)
The premise of the headline is obvious... But I don't know if I even agree with the actual research. It seems like it's overwhelmingly selection(?) bias. The data seems based on humans bringing in or calling for help on wild animals. They do mention predators but also more on vehicles, etc.