Re:Locklin on science – Calling a bureaucrat by its name
by woodruffw on Saturday December 09, 2023 @09:32PM
(#38588477)
Looks like there are two confounding factors for this author: (1) his background is scientific, not engineering in nature, and (2) he appears to run his own consulting firm.
In other words: it's unclear to me that he's qualified to make blanket statements about what "real" engineering is; his closest professional qualification is being a consultant with limited long-term responsibilities. I say this as someone who is also a consultant.
Professional Engineering is almost entirely procedure and paperwork, documenting, ordering, checking specifications, identifying responsibility via chain of evidence, etc.
Big Engineering projects (eg: the multi year UK rail transport expansion, the London sewer mega build (both the original and the recent upscaling), etc.) require truly vast amounts of attention to detail to eventually complete.
Small engineering projects like building or safely removing bridges are very much the same; the work of an Engineer isn't to weild a spanner or press a plunger after cutting away steel to weaken a structure, it's to make a plan, order the ducks and line all the ducks up, to have a diagram of what steel to cut in what order (for both construction and demolition).
And, (and this is quite the thing), to be responsible in the case of resource over runs and|or lives lost.
Scott here has quite the romantic view of engineering, for Scott it seems that real engineering is all about single person | small team total control just have at it hacking about.
Don't get me wrong here, I love doing that - but that kind of activity is (to steal a quote from the author) not engineering in the normal several decades old definition of the word.