News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You are never taught how to build quality software by foobiekr on Friday December 08, 2023 @09:19PM (#38577768)
For years a friend tried to get his department (where he worked as a lecturer) to add a software engineering course where the basic syllabus was to (1) receive a TOI from the last semester and the code base, (2) implement some new features in the code base, (3) deploy and operate the code for awhile, and (4) produce a TOI for the next semester.

The code base was for a simple service that basically provided virus/malware scanning and included the malware scanner and signatures (this ensured there would never be an end to the work - there's always more signatures to add, more features, etc.)

I thought this was a fantastic idea and its a pity he never convinced them. That was more than fifteen years ago, and in his plan it would have just run forever.

Re:You are never taught how to build quality software by AlphaWeaver on Friday December 08, 2023 @10:43PM (#38578337)
In my university, (US, state school,) we had a software engineering course exactly like this. It was great in theory, but in practice, the experience was rushed, the codebase was poor quality, (layers upon layers of nothing features with varying code quality,) and the background knowledge was completely ignored. The application we had to work on was a Tomcat Java Web application with an Angular frontend, when neither of those technologies were taught in any other classes (including electives.)

This approach to education can work, but I think simulating/mocking portions of this would have been more helpful (it could've been a teacher/TA managed codebase we started with rather than the monstrosity passed between generations of students who were inexperienced.)

Re:You are never taught how to build quality software by azemetre on Friday December 08, 2023 @11:10PM (#38578481)
I think like your example where things go wrong is the most realistic exposure to programming you can give someone.

Learning why things are bad, and why it's bad to experience them offers a new level of appreciation or better ways to argue why certain things should be done.

Re:You are never taught how to build quality software by Mtinie on Saturday December 09, 2023 @12:42AM (#38578977)
Am I understanding correctly that your concern was that the course is too close to reality to be useful?
Re:You are never taught how to build quality software by skeeter2020 on Saturday December 09, 2023 @10:46AM (#38582821)
You needed to partner with the business school to get a future MBA to convince the faculty (executives) the biggest return (profitability) was a total re-write!
Re:You are never taught how to build quality software by elptacek on Saturday December 09, 2023 @04:41PM (#38586356)
I had a single phone interview with someone at Northwestern (a long time ago) where they were looking for someone to build a pen of developers to "partner" with MBA students to turn ideas into apps. I laughed so hard my sides hurt.
Re:You are never taught how to build quality software by adastra22 on Saturday December 09, 2023 @02:53AM (#38579684)
That sounds like a very realistic classroom experience. I think you missed the point?
Re:You are never taught how to build quality software by rjzzleep on Friday December 08, 2023 @09:36PM (#38577910)
The thing is for academics quality software sometimes isn't actually quality software.

My experience has been that people who's first jobs were in companies with quality software or who's job included reading through other people's quality software learn to write good software, the other ones learn whatever they saw in the environments they worked in.

Re:You are never taught how to build quality software by maxwelljoslyn on Friday December 08, 2023 @09:20PM (#38577780)
That sounds like an excellent way to do practice that directly mirrors real-world SWE, while still cutting it down to an appropriate size for a pedagogical environment. What a good idea.
Re:You are never taught how to build quality software by steveBK123 on Friday December 08, 2023 @10:02PM (#38578088)
I went to a STEM school and exactly 0 of the professors had been in industry ever or at least in the last 30 years. The only guy with some experience was an underpaid lecturer. He was also the only good lecturer.

A lot of professors just want to do research and mentor students onto the PHD track to self replicate. My mandated faculty advisor was basically like "go to the career center" when I asked about, you know, getting a job of some sort with my degree.

So yes, it is a real problem. CMU may stand out by actually having courses in the space, but it is not the norm by any means.

Re:You are never taught how to build quality software by mwcremer on Friday December 08, 2023 @09:27PM (#38577834)
TOI?
Re:You are never taught how to build quality software by dmux on Friday December 08, 2023 @09:47PM (#38577989)
I’m guessing Transfer of Information.