I feel like compatibility between clients is good, people just aren't used to having independent implementations anymore. It's easy to cook up your own protocol and have compatibility by being the only game in town but if you look at the bigger picture you have just created more fragmentation. We need more instant messaging standardization and XMPP serves an important role as the IETF internet standard for IM.
Maybe the modern web-based clients like Movim are better, never got around to testing them. I'll admit that Android always was the golden platform for XMPP thanks to Conversations - as long as you stick to that on both ends it's the perfect experience.
FWIW it's been smooth-sailing for me and my non-tech family and friends for many years now. BTW, OTR is deprecated, and OMEMO just works.
This project looks promising too: https://prose.org/
> Windows, where most people live
Most people live on their smartphone for IM these days, at least in my circles. I have been surprised by how few people are actually interested in getting a chat app on their "real computer".
point stands, as both deliver a subpar experience with either dm's or groups
And yet, in 2016, 9 years after the first iPhone, XMPP still struggled to provide any of the modern conveniences on the protocol level: https://gultsch.de/xmpp_2016.html (at the time most of the links marked as "solution available" were going to experimental and beta proposals)
The protocol/backend can be, and often is, as much hindrance as the clients.
Noting is "I need to spend a significunt chunk of my time for no renumeration"-friendly.
And yet there are numerous free, or pay-less-than-a-cup-of-coffee clients for many things and services, whether those are open or closed, free or paid (Ivory for Mastodon https://tapbots.com/ivory/ and Wikipedia's app come to mind).
Thanks for the tip for Siskin and Monal! Even a few years ago the situation was dire.
Fair point. I'm a dreamer ;)
I believe the lack of great clients for apple platforms is due to how little the overlap is between people who see value in using a self-hosted, federated, lightweight chat system and people who want to use apple products.
I suspect the thing that held back its adoption for end-users (or is still holding it back) is the fragmented ecosystem and so-so open source clients with questionable inter-compatibility, i.e. you can get calls from Windows to Android to work as an end-user, but it's a rocky path.
Hopefully we can one day see the great XMPP renaissance.