Not surprisingly, the reason it was this way is because the label got most of the profit from the albums and the artists got most of the profit from touring. And since the labels were in control, they optimized for album sales. They loved it when a tour lost money, because then the artist owed them money.
I believe it was the 90s when tours started becoming more profitable than albums.
But that's my point, people never made money from this previously. Why is Spotify being demonised because bands have bad contracts with their labels?
Pay nearly-nothing to the artist, take money for themselves and charge the consumer. Nothing has changed other than an online-internet enabled application than a CD.
You don't even have your own physical copy, once you hit cancel you loose all. So your locked in to a model where if you wish to listen to music you are forced to pay, otherwise unless you head for the sea's and download which IS illegal and where the artist gets completely nothing, you've got nothing. Where at any point is that fair?
If Spotify sent you a CD of your top-listens of the year then that would be something.
No they don't, they pay out 70% of all their taking.
The problem is that almost all artists work through labels still. Spotify pays the label who then screws over the artist in the same way they always have.
You are misdirecting your anger, just like the RIAA wants you to.
I don't use Spotify, nor any subscription model for that matter. If I can't own it, then oh well. This goes for consumer products too.
> subtract a percentage for themselves
Streaming platforms (let's not just pick on Spotify, though they also pay worse than others) just do this arbitrarily. They decide how much to skim off for themselves before graciously paying artists. This isn't how it works in basically any other industry where one group of skilled individuals create content that is then sold on some marketplace - instead, the sale price and proceeds are visible to all, and the middleman takes a well-defined, reasonable cut of that.
There's no need to compare streaming platforms to other models of paying musicians, in order to know they're getting a bum deal. This model is not fair in the slightest, and it's perfectly alright to be upset about it.
If they were just deciding their cut "arbitrarily" they are doing a bad job of it.
The reality is labels have all the leverage and extract all of the profits because they have a monopoly on talent and content
> Our current payment agreements lead us to distribute (~)approximately 70% of our gross revenues to master recording and publishing rights (both mechanical reproduction and performance) holders. The precise division between these types of rights holders varies by territory in accordance with local laws and negotiated agreements.
So, 70% / 30% is actually just a self-reported figure, and also just a ballpark based on current agreements at the time. Also, I couldn't find a current version of this page, only the archived one cited. All current versions of this page seem to have nothing but deflection, which might indicate that their self-reported figure has become less flattering.
Can you cite some examples of this. Etsy perhaps?
The only thing I ever see are people comparing against the money that 90's rockstars used to be able to bring in from album sales.
That ship sailed a long time ago, Spotify take everyone's money, substract a percentage for themselves and distribute the rest based upon number of plays.
If you were a big artist it's probably worse because you aren't getting a sweet deal to pull you onto a label (which we would then have you bitching about in the music press every week), or your a smaller artist and don't make much off it because you don't get the plays but you would have never seen the big money from tape/CD sales anyway.
I've also seen people argue that they never see the sort of money that they would get with a single play from BBC Radio, completely misunderstanding that BBC radio would probably never play their song, there is a much smaller bandwidth for playing music. Per person listening to your song, it works out not far off a play on Radio 6.