I assume by "realistic" you mean companies that prioritise profitably?
I don't hold a strong opinion on this, but the way I see this is that, yes, investors could invest in companies and demand those companies maximise profits so they can see a return on their investment as soon as possible without the need for accusation, but I genuinely don't know if most users would agree this is better for them.
To appeal to an acquirer or other investors companies most first appeal to their users and show strong user growth. So I don't buy your second point that companies prioritising profitably are somehow more focused on building a good products for their users – and if anything I'd probably argue the inverse is generally true.
I suppose if you were to push me for an opinion on this I think it's fine to let the market decide what's best. Companies can already focus on profits if they wish. And if you're right that companies that do this will have better products and keep their users happy then companies that choose to do this should take market share from big tech over time.
But to be so certain of this that you'd use regulation to enforce it thereby destroying a significant source of funding from early stage companies and the innovation those companies provide the tech sector would be a risk. Especially when I'm not even sure you're right that consumers prefer companies that focus on profitability.
It’s hard to compete with free. You can’t burn millions you don’t have to present a sweet deal to users or releasing features in month. And now people have become accustomed to receive everything on the internet for free (bundled with ads).
This right here. What happened to IPOs being the endgame?
These two are negatively correlated. Google and reddit and other companies were awesome and very user friendly when they had investors pouring in money and they could afford loss.
All the VC hate in HN is weird given we are in a platform owned by VC.
How many competitors died on the vine because Figma was able to offer a free tier subsidised with low interest rate VC money?
Is it any different from wealthy established multinationals offering a free tier subsidized by steady profits from established (sometimes even monopolistic) product lines killing all startup offerings?
If Figma was being acquired by literally any other company the regulators wouldn't have any problems with it.
Would the founders work as hard as they did, if instead of making $5bn, they made $2bn? Probably just as hard.
Yes, price signals work, but not linearly at these scales.
> If we got rid of M&A in tech there would significantly less investment and much less innovation
It appears this way because of the path we took with our economy, but that doesn’t mean that an alternate path isn’t viable. The giants didn’t get big through innovation. They all created some initial innovation that allowed them to print money, which then allowed them to gobble up any other company that could either be of use or compete against them. If they weren’t able to acquire, that money wouldn’t disappear from the economy. It could be sent back to shareholders in the form of dividends, who would find other investments for it. Perhaps the market would find the best use for that money instead of having it controlled by a few giant entities. I tend to think that’s how the stock market was supposed to work.
If we got rid of M&A in tech there would significantly less investment and much less innovation, which I think you could argue is bad for the ecosystem as a whole and the end consumer of these products – even if individual acquisitions are often not great when viewed independently.
Or to look at it another way, big tech basically outsources their R&D to startups and the successful projects (companies) are then acquired. And this goes both ways given the goal of a lot startups is to be acquired.