News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by factormeta on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:35PM (#38386782)
>They will continue to raise maintenance and licensing fees until they very last customer turns off their last ESXi box

hmm, why would people still use VMWare? Honest question. Maybe there are some licensing issues I'm not aware of. Isn't vbox open source? If not, wouldn't even things such as https://copy.sh/v86/ in the browser would do most virtualization trick now days?

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by barkingcat on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:43PM (#38386867)
most people don't use vmware the way you use virtualbox.

The money making part of vmware licensing is the baremetal hypervisor ESXi, the competitors are xen or hyperv and the likes.

The lock-in part of vmware is the vsphere management software, that allows you to move VM's en mass from one baremetal machine to another baremetal machine, or allows you to nest vm's, etc. manage your entire fleet of vm's which could be thousands or hundreds of thousands of virtual machines, from one management interface.

it's basically docker except it's actual entire vm's being moved around. VMWare ESXi being a baremetal hypervisor means you can run different OS's on top of these vm's and imagine being able to move these VM's all running different OS's around in your ecosystem.

That's what people pay the big bucks to vmware for.

It would be very difficult to build the vsphere/esxi ecosystem with pure opensource tools (it's possible with Xen, etc) but you'd be right back at paying some vendor a massive amount of money for building, integrating, and supporting this kind of system. (Redhat will happily sell you something that approximates vmware's tools, for megabucks).

As an aside, the consumer "vmware" software that you install on your workstation is such a small portion of their business, they basically spend no money on fixing/upkeeping. Apple silicon support was in beta for a loooong time, and they don't actually care about their workstation product. ESXi makes the money.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by scottjg on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @07:15PM (#38387276)
i don't know what the penetration of it looks like, but on the vsphere/esxi side there are also a number of really expensive addon features that i have not seen reproduced in open source software.

1. vmotion + storage vmotion - you can live migrate a vm from one hypervisor host machine to another. you can also live migrate the underlying storage (good if you want to consolidate storage servers, rebalance disk load, etc). with some caveats, you can do all of this without any downtime in the vm. it's not just a simple suspend on one host, resume on another host. a memory snapshot is migrated while the vm is still running on the first host, and when the amount of dirty pages starts to converge, they flip the vm over to the new host. similar idea for storage vmotion.

2. fault tolerance - for single cpu vms, you can use vmware's record-replay technology to execute a secondary vm in a "shadow" mode which replicates all of the nondeterministic events across the network. if one hypervisor host dies, the other can take over with no downtime. this is great when you need to add HA for a legacy application.

3. vsan - generally you run these systems with some sort of shared storage (nfs or iscsi attached SAN, or something like that). a SAN can be really expensive and a single point of failure. vmware can create a "virtual san" from a cluster of your esxi hypervisor hosts. as you can imagine, it has all sorts of HA features and can rebalance workloads to improve performance.

there are more, but that's just a few interesting features.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by lima on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @08:16PM (#38387882)
QEMU/libvirt can live migrate VMs without downtime. It works the same way.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by erkkie on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:29PM (#38388485)
Yep, happily using https://ganeti.org/ and KVM live migrations - mirrors across hosts.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by snapplebobapple on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:43PM (#38389380)
can you speak to how that is vs the gui web interface goodness of proxmox? I'm interested in playign with ganeti but all the youtube walkthroughs that would motivate me more are super outdated and the website doesn't really sell the product very well.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by erkkie on Wednesday November 29, 2023 @04:10AM (#38457193)
Ganeti can be quite arcane, I've only ever used the command-line.

But it has been solid otherwise, even with in-place upgrades over many years.

I haven't run proxmox so can not directly compare :)

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by everfrustrated on Thursday November 23, 2023 @02:43AM (#38390427)
VMware was doing live migration since 2002. Open source reimplantations are relatively recent.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by barkingcat on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @07:19PM (#38387340)
good mention of the replay feature! I haven't used that before, but that sounds like something that they could sell for a lot of money and companies would want to buy that feature.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by redundantly on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:02PM (#38388283)
> vsan... a SAN can be really expensive and a single point of failure.

In every scenario that we spec'd out vSAN for production use it came in at least two times as expensive as your average dual controller, HA capable, storage array.

vSAN pricing is absolute nonsense.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by mgiampapa on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:37PM (#38388548)
vSAN pricing is all about what the sales guy is willing to do to make the rest of the sale. It has zero marginal cost if they can get you on the platform and using their ecosystem of tools and software.

In edge deployments where rack space is tight it's actually a great solution if you only have a few U to work with and have a HA requirement for a legacy app as well.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by ikidd on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:25PM (#38389259)
You might be surprised how much of this the free Proxmox, running Qemu on Debian, can do.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by katbyte on Thursday November 23, 2023 @01:22AM (#38389951)
Fair bit of that can be done with Proxmox now. What esxi has going for it from what I hear is the ability to deal with 100/1000s of hosts over many many nodes and Proxmox struggles with that
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by edwintorok on Thursday November 23, 2023 @04:01AM (#38390857)
Memory and storage live migration across hosts and pools is possible with Xen too.

See VM.pool_migrate and VM.migrate_send https://xapi-project.github.io/xen-api/classes/vm.html. Those features got introduced in Xenserver 4.0 (2007) and 6.1 (2012).

Disclaimer: I work at XenServer.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by kbenson on Thursday November 23, 2023 @12:19AM (#38389613)
> Redhat will happily sell you something that approximates vmware's tools, for megabucks

Actually, no, they apparently won't, because I tried and was told they are discontinuing that product. They are going full steam on their OpenShift (k8s) product though, and will be happy to inform you that you can run a VM on that, but if you press them you'll find that you're actually running a VM in a container, and that you have to specify it as a k8s deployment, so apparently you can't just throw a VM up like you can in vCenter.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by lsllc on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @07:01PM (#38387066)
It's ESXi, the server class stuff, not so much the desktop VMware. So many companies have been using it for years. Now Broadcom are wanting to install spyware to "track" usage and license compliance and they're raising prices. For a lot of orgs, it'll probably take several years to move the production systems to something else.

For the desktop, VirtualBox isn't much better. At one point after Oracle purchased it, they were tracking your IP and if they found you were using their extension pack that provides essential capabilities like USB 3 support (only the core of VirtualBox is GPL) and it was for commercial use, they were hitting you up for a license [0].

[0] https://www.theregister.com/2019/10/04/oracle_virtualbox_mer...

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by nunez on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @07:41PM (#38387559)
Nearly every company/public service/non-profit/whatever uses vSphere/ESX somewhere. You'd be (very) surprised to see where people shoehorn ESXi hosts. VMware is EVERYWHERE, and vSphere/ESX/NSX is still the best game in town if you want to virtualize your datacenter. It's insanely rock-solid tech.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:37PM (#38388941)
Yep. Arguably if you have Windows licensing, Hyper-V will do mostly all the same stuff "for free", but only if you want your hypervisors to be exactly as reliable as Windows machines. If you're rolling VMware, your datacenter's backbone tends to be ridiculously solid.

Think servers with four digits of days of uptime, in terms of things you probably shouldn't do, but absolutely can.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by c0pium on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:58PM (#38389081)
That’s not actually different on the Windows side, you should update your priors. There are datacenters full of Server 2019 boxes that have never been upgraded because the guest VMs are mission critical.

Source: I’ve responded incidents on those guests. It’s terrifying, but hypervisor uptime is limited by power not OS choice.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by pavelstoev on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:54PM (#38389445)
Agreed. I have 20+ Hyper-V Windows Server VMs running since 2017, seeing 400-600 Mbps live video traffic - no major crashes, only due to facility power loss or annual patching reboots.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by ocdtrekkie on Thursday November 23, 2023 @12:31AM (#38389672)
I mean, I work with every version of Windows Server since 2012 R2 up through Server 2022 on a daily basis...
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by c0pium on Thursday November 23, 2023 @01:26AM (#38389972)
No you don’t. It’s ok, just take the L.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by jiggawatts on Thursday November 23, 2023 @04:32AM (#38391033)
I'm the other "pro Microsoft guy" here on HN, but I have to agree with the GP comment: VMware stability puts Microsoft to shame.

These days Windows is stable if you don't touch it.

VMware is stable even if one of the disks is out of space, the fibre is flapping, some idiot misconfigured the switches, and the whole cluster has time out of sync... by seven hours.

That's not hyperbole, that's an actual cluster that I got given to look after. It was running like that for months, perfectly fine, with VMware HA just "taking care of things".

If you sneeze in the direction of a Windows Failover Cluster it'll... fail.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by hsbauauvhabzb on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:41PM (#38386842)
Edit: the following statement is incorrect and retracted: ‘Virtualbox is not free for commercial use iirc’

Esxi is an enterprise product which engineers are familiar with, the cost of the product vs the cost of migration and upskilling in alternative tech should not be underestimated, particularly when it’s the thing that runs all your other things.

Edit: in case you’re not aware, many organisations still leverage on-prem virtualisation technologies - that might not be obvious to people that haven’t seen it.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by p3n1s on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:55PM (#38386992)
Virtualbox is GPL licensed. Only the extension packs are non GPL. In any case virtualbox competes with VMWare player/Workstation/fusion which we all should know is not their core business.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by stephenr on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:57PM (#38388687)
As explained by others the parent comment is talking about ESXi, but to answer your question: virtualbox desktop hypervisor is the spam of desktop hypervisors.

Everyone has heard of it, it's theoretically comparable to the likes of VMware/Parallels desktop hypervisors, and it's cheaper. But just like spam (compared to ham), it's also obvious to anyone that's used both that it's by far the worse option, and there's very few reasons to use it besides cost, while there are numerous reasons to use one of the better alternatives.

In general, performance is significantly better with other hypervisors, but in particular shared filesystem performance (ie sharing a directory from the host OS into the guest) and features are lacking on virtualbox.

It's the default provider used by vagrant, and even the vagrant team recommend using a different provider for "any serious work".

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by fencepost on Thursday November 23, 2023 @12:56AM (#38389801)
One caution: SPAM isn't actually cheaper than ham, it's just shelf stable without refrigeration. You can get a decent spiral ham for well under $3.29/lb (Costco earlier today), but 12oz cans of SPAM work out to around $5/lb.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by stephenr on Thursday November 23, 2023 @01:40AM (#38390040)
I don't know if it's just a demand thing or perhaps because I don't really know what "spiral ham" is, but in Australia the only ham you're likely to find cheaper per-kilo than spam is going to be a 2+ kg leg of ham, complete with bone, fat, skin, etc. A boneless ham will be at least as expensive, and sliced/shaved ham from the deli section at a supermarket will be easily more expensive per-kilo than spam.

Of course one could argue there's an even higher percentage of inedible parts in the canned monstrosity because it's all inedible, and I wouldn't argue that view point is wrong.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by fencepost on Sunday November 26, 2023 @03:04PM (#38424497)
A spiral ham is actually a spiral sliced ham. This is the butt end or shank end of a whole ham and yes, typically probably 3kg at a minimum. The 'spiral' part is that during processing it's been sliced in a spiral that leaves slices roughly 5-7mm thick. These are typically a little more expensive than unsliced bone in hams, but the convenience factor is huge.

Hams like that often go on sale around US Thanksgiving and Christmas, with prices for them around US$4.50-6.50/kg last week and probably as 'loss leaders' around US$2-3/kg the week before Christmas. Ham is a regular part of 'traditional Thanksgiving' but not as much as turkey, whereas the 'Christmas ham' is definitely a thing.