News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by maremmano on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @07:41AM (#38362861)
Why I feel that China will not slow down AI progress?
Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by ShamelessC on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @07:48AM (#38362937)
They won’t but mainland China hasn’t shown a very good track record of keeping up, much less inventing new methods that gain any sort of traction.

They do seem to produce plenty of good researchers, who sometimes proceed to do good research with proper funding from western institutions.

I would be more worried about Europe.

Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by deafpolygon on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @08:14AM (#38363207)
> I would be more worried about Europe.

Not really a concern. The AI phobia here in Europe is pretty bad, to the point where governments are shooting themselves in the foot by legislating progress on advancing tech out.

Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by boringuser2 on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @07:58AM (#38363073)
Why?

Europeans are generally regarded as more ethical than Chinese.

I feel that people perceive China as a Han supremacist country, which isn't ridiculous.

Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by fsociety on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @08:17AM (#38363233)
That seems like an overly broad and unfair generalization of Chinese.
Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by boringuser2 on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @08:19AM (#38363249)
Every generalization is "overly broad".

That's why it's called a "generalization".

As for whether the claim is fair or not, that's an opinion, but I disagree, obviously.

Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by solardev on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @08:22AM (#38363277)
Um, are we just skipping past the whole colonialist era and straight into some sort of enlightened modern age? Even then, Russia's European too.

China's had a rough and tumble history, to be sure, but they didn't try to take over the whole world. Just Tibet and Hong Kong so far, maybe Taiwan someday.

I think their ambitions are different, and so are their ethical frameworks. The CCP isn't a governing body I admire, but their people and culture have a very long history of collectivism and Confucianism. The flip side of Han supremacy and cultural erasure is national unity and civil harmony, their version of manifest destiny I guess, with an emphasis on assimilation.

I envision a Great Chinese AI to be in line with the firewall, ostensibly (and mostly) uses to promote harmony via strict control, rather than conquest. Maybe more Borg than Skynet?

Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by jncfhnb on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @08:37AM (#38363411)
> Um, are we just skipping past the whole colonialist era and straight into some sort of enlightened modern age? Even then, Russia's European too.

yes because we are not in the colonialist era

Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by boringuser2 on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @08:37AM (#38363417)
It sounds like you agree with me aside from some vague historical wishy-washiness.

Ironically, Russians don't really see themselves as "European".

Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by solardev on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @08:51AM (#38363573)
I don't agree or disagree with you; it's too broad a generalization to be useful.

Ethically, I'm worried about Chinese cultural genocide and stagnation, alongside European far-right nationalism and fascist resurgences. I don't think anybody has much of a claim to moral superiority here, much less supremacy.

I'm not worried about AI developments from either. I think AI is the only chance this planet has at actual moral governance. I have more faith in these models than human government.

Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by boringuser2 on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @08:57AM (#38363639)
The notion that the Chinese are the moral equivalent of the Europeans writ large beggars belief.

It's just an absurd, intellectually offensive statement that I generally think you should feel bad about making.

Note, I am neither Chinese nor European, an explicitly neutral observer.

Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by solardev on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @09:05AM (#38363737)
Well, I just don't think this provokes the moral outrage in me that it does in you. That's okay, we can have different beliefs.

I'm not Chinese or European either, I just don't believe in some singularly great evil (or good, for that matter). Humans are complex, flawed creatures across the world...

Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by FranzFerdiNaN on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @09:09AM (#38363791)
Europeans dont see Russians as European either.
Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by mepiethree on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @09:18AM (#38363906)
> generally regarded

Source?

The current Chinese dictator does many unethical things, but ascribing the actions of a ruler to an entire race of people is fallacious. Akin to saying that Trump’s philandery applies to all Americans globally. As the other commenter said, China has a long history of studying ethics, morality, and philosophy.

I’m not really a “PC” person but broadly saying that ”Europeans […] are more ethical than Chinese” is a white supremacist statement. I’m not saying you’re a white supremacist, but your comment is.

Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by chpatrick on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @09:23AM (#38363980)
I really don't think you're right there, many new models come from companies like Tencent and WeChat. Chinese investment in AI is increasing massively.

A huge percentage of AI researchers are Chinese, if PRC can convince them to work there instead of the US they won't have any trouble.

Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by drannex on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @09:35AM (#38364148)
Not only are a rather decent number of AI developers and researchers who are Chinese, perhaps, and likely, some of the best in the world. but not only this but they are also the only manufacturing center for the GPU/CPUs needed to run the things. Tight collaboration between AI researchers and the manufactures of the hardware? No other country (absent their direct neighbors) have any chance at growing manufacturing facilities fast enough to catch up, especially with that combination.
Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by ShamelessC on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @10:28PM (#38374403)
> Not only are a rather decent number of AI developers and researchers who are Chinese, perhaps, and likely, some of the best in the world

I didn't dispute that. In fact, I brought it up.

> only manufacturing center for the GPU/CPUs needed to run the things

they don't have the designs and sanctions by American companies are surprisingly already in place and historically effective.

Finally, you are presupposing that "slowing down" in America means moving slower than China. Not only is that not necessarily the case, I don't think it's even really possible. This research can be done on readily available gaming GPU's if needed. Do you really think the US will intentionally cripple these markets in this fashion? More likely, companies will lobby for the opposite.

Any slowing down done by the US will amount to virtue signaling.

Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by 0xDEF on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @07:57AM (#38363051)
It is infuriating how the West keeps sabotaging itself. Both China and Russia (Yandex) are moving ahead while the West is self-sabotaging with all the "responsible AI" bullshit.
Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by wholinator2 on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @09:44AM (#38364282)
Does China have similar level, viable models?
Re:'I'm a Doomer': OpenAI's New Interim CEO Wants to Slow AI... by FrozenTuna on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @02:23PM (#38368622)
Yes. Yi-34b is competitive with Llama2-70b which is often competitive with gpt 3.5. GPT-4 is on its own level atm but the point is that China has already created a good model that effectively beats Meta's current best.