Re:Nothing Chats, an iMessage app for Android, is a privacy ...
by TheNewsIsHere on Sunday November 19, 2023 @06:08PM
(#38339551)
Apple has taken steps over the past several years to tie the cryptography in iMessage (and APNs generally) to Apple manufactured devices. It’s telling that every legitimate way of bridging onto iMessage to date has required an Apple device.
Tangentially related: My thinking is Apple’s reverse course on RCS will help them justify keeping iMessage itself closer to Apple platforms, particularly when governments/society demand that they justify their closed access.
Re:Nothing Chats, an iMessage app for Android, is a privacy ...
by dangus on Sunday November 19, 2023 @06:46PM
(#38339940)
You’re spot-on with RCS. Apple can point to it and say “we support open standards including everything Android supports.”
Re:Nothing Chats, an iMessage app for Android, is a privacy ...
by gruez on Sunday November 19, 2023 @08:41PM
(#38341066)
>It’s telling that every legitimate way of bridging onto iMessage to date has required an Apple device.
AFAIK you could get imessage to work on a hackintosh, which technically isn't an apple device.
Re:Nothing Chats, an iMessage app for Android, is a privacy ...
by iAMkenough on Sunday November 19, 2023 @09:23PM
(#38341397)
I'm guessing they don't view hackintoshes as legitimate. I'm curious about legitimate businesses that are built around hackintoshes.
Re:Nothing Chats, an iMessage app for Android, is a privacy ...
by sweetjuly on Sunday November 19, 2023 @11:39PM
(#38342322)
The point is that Apple couldn't possibly be requiring some hardware backed signature (i.e. HW attestation that this is a genuine Apple product) for iMessage if Hackintoshes can pull it off. In so far as Hackintoshes can send iMessages without any sketchy middle-end servers, so too could Android devices if someone were able to reverse engineer enough of the stack.
Re:Nothing Chats, an iMessage app for Android, is a privacy ...
by fomine3 on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:56AM
(#38344197)
Isn't it like a emulated TPM? It may or may not secure, but it works as a TPM.
Re:Nothing Chats, an iMessage app for Android, is a privacy ...
by gruez on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:19AM
(#38344542)
Apple does not use TPMs. They use their own proprietary security chips, which approximates TPMs. I'm not sure how their implementation works, but even for TPMs "emulated TPM" won't work because real TPMs have endorsement keys[1] with accompanying certificates signed by the manufacturer. If apple really wanted to, they could check against such key, which would theoretically block non-genuine devices.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trusted_Computing#Endorsement_...
Re:Nothing Chats, an iMessage app for Android, is a privacy ...
by iAMkenough on Sunday November 26, 2023 @09:35PM
(#38427443)
For Hackintosh purposes, the security chip doesn't come into play, at least not yet. There are still Macs supported by the latest macOS that don't require a T1 or T2 security chip.
Re:Nothing Chats, an iMessage app for Android, is a privacy ...
by duskwuff on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:00PM
(#38354675)
No. The only Apple-specific hardware information that Apple services like iMessage require is a couple of hardware serial numbers; Hackintosh systems just make one up.
https://dortania.github.io/OpenCore-Post-Install/universal/i...
The promise was, implicitly, that Nothing (terrible name) had reimplemented enough of the iMessage encryption architecture to replicate it on an Android phone. If that had been the case, there's no reason they couldn't have made it end-to-end encryption, just like Apple's implementation of iMessage is.
The reality is that they lied. It's not clear that there was any encryption involved beyond standard TLS and (possibly?) at-rest encryption in Firebase. None of this adds up to E2EE.