News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Death to MS Word by tptacek on Wednesday April 11, 2012 @11:22PM (#3830870)
Word "Track Changes" is still the industry standard for legal documents.
Re:Death to MS Word by Alex3917 on Wednesday April 11, 2012 @11:57PM (#3830950)
And for good reason. Trying to edit anything without 'track changes' would be a nightmare. This guy's argument that you can just view the version history with Google Docs is ridiculous, that doesn't even come close to being a feasible replacement.
Re:Death to MS Word by guard-of-terra on Thursday April 12, 2012 @03:57AM (#3831467)
A legal document is essentially a program; but: - They don't use variables where they should. - They don't factor out common code in libraries. - They don't use any reasonable kind of diff and patch.

All this means they are doing extra work with bad tools not made for their needs. They might not see it, but that's lame.

Re:Death to MS Word by andreasvc on Thursday April 12, 2012 @08:29AM (#3832040)
No it's not; a program defines computations from certain inputs to outputs. A legal document, on the other hand, is a deontologigal set of rules saying you must X and cannot Y etc. While introducing variables and libraries could make documents shorter, they wouldn't be easier to read or write, because a single change could have massive effects in other places, which you wouldn't notice at first because there's no computer to test the "code" on. In the end legal text is just natural language, and it needs to be interpreted as such. And this is for the better, I for one wouldn't want a judge to just apply some formal procedure to decide guilt.
Re:Death to MS Word by guard-of-terra on Thursday April 12, 2012 @11:53AM (#3832857)
"set of rules saying you must X and cannot Y etc" How it isn't a computation for certain inputs (X, Y...) to certain outputs (must, cannot, ...)?

Legal text doesn't look like natural language and doesn't behave as one.

Re:Death to MS Word by andreasvc on Thursday April 12, 2012 @01:14PM (#3833289)
I believe it's not computation because the inputs are not well-defined, and the result depends on contexts which aren't well-defined either.

What kind of definition of "look like" are you working with? I see words that are in the dictionary, plus I can parse them into meaningful sentences. I have no idea how "text" is supposed to behave anyway... It's about what humans do with it, and that happens to be the same as with other texts: humans read it and do stuff based on that. Sure there are differences, just as a letter of recommendation differs from a novel, but if you are claiming it's a different "language" you'll have to back that up.

Re:Death to MS Word by guard-of-terra on Thursday April 12, 2012 @02:08PM (#3833533)
Well, programs sometimes have to handle such problems too.

You can always find keywords and function names from a program source in a dictionary, but it doesn't make program source a normal text. The main difference is that a legal document can be evaluated and it transforms input to output; novel doesn't.

Re:Death to MS Word by mjwalshe on Thursday April 12, 2012 @05:37AM (#3831675)
erm no its a very speclised form of document - I wish programmers who have no experience of how laws are made and parliamentary procedure would stop making broad assumptions like this.

Any thing using a parliamentry system to draft laws has a lot of fuzy areas and some non obvious gotchas.

I while back i had a whole day being briefed on the new employment laws one of my collegues asked well why did they not draft the wording so its clear exactly when you are allowed to discriminate on age grounds.

The General Counsel who was leading the course gave a wry grin and said well there are lots of lawyers in the House of commons so maybe they wanted to create loads of work for there lawyer friends

Re:Death to MS Word by tow21 on Thursday April 12, 2012 @08:20AM (#3832022)
Well, as a programmer

* whose father is an academic lawyer

* who has actually developed software for drafting and reviewing legal documents within parliamentary procedure

I can tell you that all the above is entirely true.

In any case, the vast majority of legal documents in everyday use aren't developed in a parliamentary system, they're developed within the framework of contract law, where sensible refactoring and variable naming would go a very long way if lawyers had the tooling and training to make use of them.

Re:Death to MS Word by icebraining on Thursday April 12, 2012 @06:51AM (#3831810)
I don't know why have you brought up draft laws. Parents said "legal documents," of which only a minuscule number are laws. Most are contracts, licenses, agreements, deeds, etc.
Re:Death to MS Word by mjwalshe on Thursday April 12, 2012 @08:02AM (#3831977)
Which have a law that underpins them - I was talking about the more general case/
Re:Death to MS Word by guard-of-terra on Thursday April 12, 2012 @08:14AM (#3832008)
I failed to parse your response, but it doesn't seem to address the points I made. Any program text itself is a "very specialised form of document".
Re:Death to MS Word by mjwalshe on Thursday April 12, 2012 @02:41PM (#3833661)
no that's just the high level representation of the program I was commenting the tendency of non political tecies (who are not wonks) to make a very superficial link between using a SCS to commit code and how government and in how particular laws are made.
Re:Death to MS Word by homosaur on Wednesday April 11, 2012 @11:35PM (#3830900)
So there's one industry that's keeping it. Any others actually NEED Word's advanced functionality?

Not being facetious, let's name em.

Re:Death to MS Word by tylerritchie on Thursday April 12, 2012 @11:06AM (#3832607)
Looking at several of the other responses to this I found that most of the other individuals named fields that use either track changes or TOC generation. Those don't need Word. The inter-operation with other human beings who know and want to use Word, needs Word.

In biology (in government and industry) we use both. And we tend to use Word because that's what everyone else is using. But WordPerfect and LibreOffice generate TOC and figure lists, and track changes just fine. LaTeX and git also accomplish those goals. But the problem is working with other people in different groups, companies, levels of expertise, preference, etc. When track changes is breaking between LibreOffice and Word you just revert to using word to find the changes, and then incorporate them by hand into your LibreOffice document. Or, since you're using Word anyway and it does accomplish your goals, you just switch to Word.

Working in any setting aside from a self-contained research unit or the academic world, you just learn Word. In my case I learned Word and I use all of the various variable-esque and markup I can to make generating TOC, figure/table lists and references and adjusting values easier when working with people who just use Word because that's what you write reports in.

Even in an academic setting, if your advisers use Word (and prefer Word over dead trees) you're going to be creating Word documents for your thesis and academic papers (the journals mostly don't care because they re-typeset everything anyway) because you need their expertise to make your work awesome.

So, what about LaTeX? I like the idea more than the practice. Making basic changes (or what would be basic with CSS, Word, InDesign) to templates is mindbogglingly complicated to beginners. I'm not sure it's even particularly easy to create custom templates and formatting for experienced LaTeX users. However, once you have the Ecology, Washington Department of Fish And Wildlife, USDA, etc. LaTeX template all future publications for those is much faster.

If you want to know the actual one true solution to kill Word for academic, industry and government publishing it's this:

Modify Lyx (or make something like it using Markdown or reST) that uses sane defaults (I think WYSIWYM with a live preview is probably okay for everyone except the "lost dog" folks), some auto-correction, spelling and grammar checking tools and has the ability to easily and correctly make headings, adjust page headers and footers, footnotes, endnotes, and insert and edit figures, tables (the table formatting tools should be very powerful, ideally also the ability to include data from Excel and also tie into R, SAS and SPSS), images and variables (for things like n, p-value, species names) and integrate it with Evernote, Endnote, Papers, Mendeley and BibTeX (though, supporting BibTeX gets you pretty far). Now, make an extensive repository of formats for publications (like PyPI, rubygems, etc. but for templates from academic journals etc.) Ideally the templating should be powerful enough for experts to create anything they can imagine and simple enough that the Masters student studying the behavior of Little Auks can get her short fact sheet to look how she wants it to for her presentation to the Reykjavik Ornithological Society (using system fonts should not be difficult or require any amount of documentation reading).

Now you need to add collaboration tools. Track changes, highlighting, and commenting gets you to 90% of use cases for Word. Add in version control that is easy and makes sense, the ability for multiple people to live edit the same document and good merging tools (for multiple offline changes to the same document by different people) and suddenly your software is more useful than Word.

Oh, and it needs to be open-source, because us science-ey folks are increasingly grumpy about closed-source things, and we already have to buy the Microsoft Office suite to deal with documents and data from multiple different sources. It also can't be multiple gigabytes to download because I need to be able to tell my colleagues, "Hey, you should use this, it's easier to make pretty things, and the collaboration tools are more useful than Word's."

But even that only gets you the people who are writing for (essentially) print. If you have output formats that create sane, semantically correct and useful HTML (for people writing for online magazines, blogs and static pages) and HTML/CSS for people who want to use it as web publishing system you've got a tool that could slowly start gaining a foothold.

Re:Death to MS Word by wvenable on Thursday April 12, 2012 @02:12AM (#3831230)
http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000020.html

"A lot of software developers are seduced by the old '80/20' rule. It seems to make a lot of sense: 80% of the people use 20% of the features. So you convince yourself that you only need to implement 20% of the features, and you can still sell 80% as many copies.

"Unfortunately, it's never the same 20%. Everybody uses a different set of features. In the last 10 years I have probably heard of dozens of companies who, determined not to learn from each other, tried to release 'lite' word processors that only implement 20% of the features. This story is as old as the PC."

Re:Death to MS Word by dagw on Thursday April 12, 2012 @03:15AM (#3831369)
My girlfriend is an academic and uses the track changes feature all the time when writing or editing papers and articles. When you add Endnote integration and the fact that most journals outside of the hard math heavy sciences want Word documents, Word is clearly the best choice.

Does she NEED Word? Technically not I suppose, but Word is the tool that makes her job the easiest. That being said she still curses Word and Endnote all the time, so there is no doubt room for improvement.

Re:Death to MS Word by singingfish on Thursday April 12, 2012 @08:38AM (#3832060)
I am so hanging out to ditch word for academic writing.
Re:Death to MS Word by elithrar on Thursday April 12, 2012 @12:37AM (#3831050)
> So there's one industry that's keeping it. Any others actually NEED Word's advanced functionality? Not being facetious, let's name em.

In the Engineering/Consulting industry we use it often to collaborate on proposals, reports and other documents. Key clients - many of them utilities or energy companies - also prefer Word documents and use Track Changes.

It's very hard to move away from that momentum, partly because you can't use another tool and just export to .doc/.docx due to the format being so arcane.

For what it's worth though, Track Changes is what Word does pretty well. I rarely use it outside of work though, preferring something like Byword on my Mac or just TextEdit.

Re:Death to MS Word by tincholio on Thursday April 12, 2012 @05:10AM (#3831612)
I work on European research projects, often with over 20 partners. When writing deliverables and integrating input from so many people, the track changes feature is an FSM-send. I say this as an otherwise hardcore Emacs and LaTeX guy.
Re:Death to MS Word by pnathan on Thursday April 12, 2012 @10:33AM (#3832441)
What's wrong with hg + Latex?
Re:Death to MS Word by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday April 12, 2012 @11:56AM (#3832875)
I also work on some European projects and love LaTeX and git, so I'll chime in.

LaTeX is much better if everyone uses them. However, most people use Word, and at that point, you may as well too. Anything I write I write in LaTeX and convert to odf, then save as doc, but most people only know word and will not be able to work with anything else. For instance, I once sent my supervisor a beautifully formatted latex paper. She replied and said that she couldn't give any feedback without a word copy of the document. Sigh.

Re:Death to MS Word by mmc on Thursday April 12, 2012 @11:37AM (#3832755)
Nothing - if everyone knows how to use it. Version control is not as commonly used in research & business writing as you might hope.
Re:Death to MS Word by tincholio on Thursday April 12, 2012 @08:52PM (#3834874)
You wouldn't believe the amount of technical people who cannot do LaTeX... nevermind DCVS. Also, tracking changes in a text document, with comments and such by the side, _is_ easier than looking at diffs and so on.
Re:Death to MS Word by mbreese on Thursday April 12, 2012 @12:22AM (#3831009)
Let's not forget that this is the industry that at least until recently was exclusively using WordPerfect...
Re:Death to MS Word by mdda on Thursday April 12, 2012 @12:01AM (#3830954)
LibreOffice track changes seems to work perfectly adequately, IMHO.
Re:Death to MS Word by tptacek on Thursday April 12, 2012 @12:25AM (#3831019)
If it doesn't interoperate perfectly with Word's Track Changes, that doesn't matter: your counterparty in any legal negotiation is sure to be using Word.
Re:Death to MS Word by gruseom on Thursday April 12, 2012 @02:50AM (#3831312)
I wonder how hard it is to interoperate perfectly with Word's Track Changes, or, let's say, with a minimal set of critical Word features. Could a small smart team pull that off? That's how I'd try to do it if I were trying to kill Word. Or is Word so complicated that it would just be hopeless?
Re:Death to MS Word by Duff on Thursday April 12, 2012 @09:34AM (#3832214)
Track changes isn't part of any standard, so it's harder to duplicate.

Technical superiority won't defeat Word. Office is on every business desktop because of the licensing regime that Microsoft has been very successful at implementing.

Re:Death to MS Word by mdda on Thursday April 12, 2012 @04:25PM (#3834025)
Frankly, it's better to own the drafting process yourself : We're happy to show all the black-lined versions, but (due to 'technical difficulties') get our counterparties to send over manual changes which we implement...
Re:Death to MS Word by forkandwait on Thursday April 12, 2012 @12:40AM (#3831056)
In some cases (like the state office I work at), Libre Office track changes would be fine. We aren't all doing legal negotiating with counterparties (MS Office power users! I am super impressed!)
Re:Death to MS Word by kooshball on Thursday April 12, 2012 @12:06AM (#3830971)
> So there's one industry that's keeping it. Any others actually NEED Word's advanced functionality?

Why do you need any more? Legal itself is a huge field and a lot of the work produced are obviously documents. Even if it's just the legal field that use Track Changes, it seems like it would be a huge win.

It's not like Tracking is forced upon anyone. It's an extra feature that stays out of the way unless you want it there. I dont understand why this is even an issue.

Re:Death to MS Word by homosaur on Thursday April 12, 2012 @12:21AM (#3831006)
It's not about disliking Word's advanced features, it's about disliking Word and that most industries have no particular need for most of Word's unique features. So far we have legal, so every other industry can stop using Word tomorrow without a problem? That's quite exciting to me but I doubt it's true.
Re:Death to MS Word by chollida1 on Thursday April 12, 2012 @09:17AM (#3832171)
Engineering uses the auto table of contents and appendix generation features pretty heavily.
Re:Death to MS Word by mutagen on Friday April 13, 2012 @01:58AM (#3835556)
Track Changes is version control and diff rolled into one rotten interface for the rest of the world.