News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by chpatrick on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:02AM (#38288101)
How are people going to become professional musicians if it stops being a career?
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by Ferret7446 on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:23AM (#38288234)
Becoming a professional musician isn't a "right" of any kind. You don't have a "right" to be paid to do anything you want. You're certainly allowed to do it (barring outright criminal activity), but don't expect to be entitled to monetary compensation.
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by jillesvangurp on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:38AM (#38288337)
Plenty of musicians make money doing live performances. Since Spotify, record sales are just not a great revenue stream any more. I don't see AI impacting this much. But of course there are going to be some musicians that specialize in background music or other forms of, relatively, low value music work that are going to be affected by this.
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by progbits on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:06AM (#38288126)
Plenty of people make music for fun while having other careers. A lot of the masterpiece painters did it for passion and lived in poverty (I'm not saying that is good, but clearly a career is not necessary for great results).
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by chpatrick on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:15AM (#38288187)
Sure but most renowned artists had the time to become really skilled because they could dedicate all their time to it. If no one wants to pay humans for art any more, how will that happen?
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by prmoustache on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:56AM (#38288466)
People pay a lot of thing much higher because they are less perfectly made by humans. All the time.
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by Tadpole9181 on Thursday November 16, 2023 @10:44AM (#38290944)
Then become politically active and make sure we have a strong safety net with healthy labor rights that allow everyone to have ample free time. You don't ban music production software.
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by carlosjobim on Thursday November 16, 2023 @08:55AM (#38289516)
You can never reach a high proficiency of playing a musical instrument if you have another career. It takes an insane amount of practice.
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by jerojero on Thursday November 16, 2023 @07:11AM (#38288583)
Why would I go see a jazz band made of 20something year olds when I can just go into youtube and hear all the masters in the comfort of my bedroom?

Oh, maybe because watching live music is a different experience. Maybe because being the best is not as important as simply doing something most people can't do.

Funny thing is, when you go to shows of people who are not yet professional musicians but might be studying, might be in a band with their friends and so on... most of the people who attend these shows are their friends and also other musicians. Most musicians are not professional musicians.

Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by Davidzheng on Thursday November 16, 2023 @07:16AM (#38288624)
Strange question. Tautology they can't. But AI will be better than humans everywhere so why is this one different
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by Davidzheng on Thursday November 16, 2023 @07:17AM (#38288633)
But the question is if this is your passion why is being a hobbyist not enough. If there are no limitations of what you can be/do as a hobbyist
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by UncleMeat on Thursday November 16, 2023 @08:51AM (#38289477)
Being a professional musician is already a fraught career with low rates of success. This is even more true if you exclude people that are working with modern digital systems. Not a lot of jobs available for orchestral musicians, for example.

But there still are people making art with older techniques. There is a greater variety of art being made today than ever before in history. The development of new techniques has made art richer rather than poorer. Yes, the most commercially focused art chooses techniques based on price (far cheaper for a single person to stack synths than to pay a full orchestra) but that's okay.

Hip hop and electronic music have been creating totally new things for decades without ever touching a physical instrument. Music didn't die, it flourished.

Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by chpatrick on Thursday November 16, 2023 @09:25AM (#38289870)
This is different though, because the end game of AI music isn't better music technology for musicians, but replacing musicians.

I'm worried we're going to go into a dark age where society forgets how to make truly creative new art due to lack of incentives, and the AIs won't make anything new due to lack of anything creative to train on. We'll just regurgitate the pre-AI stuff forever.

Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by akaij on Thursday November 16, 2023 @10:13AM (#38290522)
If we're fast-forwarding the tape, why not directly go to the ultimate conclusion that the end game is AI replacing humans, period?

This is not a slippery slope; new art will be created regardless of incentives and skilled people who learn to augment their craft with AI will probably create better works of art.

Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by UncleMeat on Thursday November 16, 2023 @11:00AM (#38291152)
Why is it different? I don't see how any of the incentives go away here.
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by chpatrick on Thursday November 16, 2023 @12:16PM (#38292322)
Because previously if you honed your skills as a musician there was a chance that you could do it for a living, so there was another incentive to get better. Electronic tools just facilitated human creativity, but the random listener couldn't sit down with a synth or a DAW and just press a button to get music out. But if all the money drops out of the music industry because the consumers can auto-generate unlimited music, how will that work?
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by __loam on Thursday November 16, 2023 @05:16PM (#38296382)
Furthermore, generate music based on music you created. They're alienating the labor of the musician then using it to drive that musician ut of their livelihoods. I feel like pro-AI people constantly miss this point with inane quips about the printing press. Artists created all the value and get none of the reward.
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation by victorbjorklund on Thursday November 16, 2023 @09:42AM (#38290077)
You could make the same argument against recordings (and people did). It would take away jobs from the musicians. Yet, 136 years later and people are still creating music and playing instruments.