News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blender 16yo winner of UK younganimator of the year by sirodoht on Thursday November 16, 2023 @05:26AM (#38287823)
I would claim we should give a pass to everybody because we are all human.

I would also claim I don’t think it’s nice to judge people based on their age, regardless if it’s good or bad judgement. Furthermore, I would definitely be annoyed as 16yo if I were deemed “good enough for my age”. He competes with peers, at the highest level, not with superiors who do him a favour.

Re:Blender 16yo winner of UK younganimator of the year by benj111 on Thursday November 16, 2023 @05:48AM (#38287996)
Yes and no.

We have separate sports classes based on gender on age to reflect abilities.

It's takes time to get good at this stuff, a younger person has inherently had less time.

I'd structure it as one overall ranking, but special age rankings within that.

A 5 year old could hypothetically win overall, but if they didn't they'd still be rewarded in relation to their (age) peers.

There's an 'encouragement' element that you're missing. My 5 year old draws objectively bad pictures. I wouldn't tell him that though. I want him to get better so that he does become objectively good.

Re:Blender 16yo winner of UK younganimator of the year by ChrisRR on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:49AM (#38288406)
This is specifically a competition for young people. It's totally based around age and that's fine. A teenager doesn't have the luxury of 20 years of professional experience.