Because they offered it for free.
YouTube can close the doors any time. If they want my money, they can make a service offering that meets my needs. They could charge content providers for bandwidth and storage and meter it with assisted ad-support networks. They could charge a price I'm willing to pay.
But they don't and I will not accept any argument that consuming resources they put into the public sphere for free use means I am under any moral obligation to either give them money or facilitate them making money off of my traffic.
The only time ads worked was when Google made them an unobtrusive part of search. They dominate literally every piece of software I use now. I'm sorry but I say burn it all to the ground. I will either pay for or build its replacement.
You don't want ad-blockers? Shut it down. I was doing the internet before there was a need for them.
As I think that infrastructure should be publically owned, I'm happy to do my bit for nationalization, and use adblock.
I'm as against ads as anybody, in the sense that (1) in general I think ads are unhealthy (2) I want infrastructure that makes access to content without ads possible (3) being able to disable ad blockers is one reason it's bad to let one company control how your browser works.
I can't say I disagree with Youtube's right to monetize, it's more of an "I'd really rather if you didn't" thing, but I think they do in fact offer the affordable plan you are asking for.
The family plan is $23/month in the US. The regular plan is $14/month.
How many other people or services do we use for hours a month for free?
Are we mad at them - and entitled - for offering an ad-supported option?
So if the price of Premium was lower you'd be ok with this? Premium costs about the same as Netflix.
Disclosure: I work at Google, but not on Youtube.
If YouTube would be willing to charge me something in the neighborhood of $5-$10 per month for that I'd happily pay. I have never had a Netflix subscription. I stopped consuming pop content and movies in 2010.
I am serious about this. If you have any way of making recommendations to anyone anywhere within Alphabet that will listen, please offer it up. I would point you to a site like HistoryHit which is far more in-line with what I want. It is $60/year.
Also, I already pay $5/month to the Kevin Richardson foundation and the ad-blocking mechanism on YouTube prevents me from watching those videos (which I paid for).
The Information Service Provider offered it for "free with ads".
Do you otherwise support paying creators for their work, if not through YouTube's system for compensating creators?
If you don't want ad-blockers, shut it down.
Or do you just 'not tell yourself you deserve it?' and take the content none the less?
Then it isn't free?
Google have no right to make us watch ads either. IP laws protecting their profit is preventing youtube-dl like alternative hosting, since Google got the IP rights for the video. And the network effect is keeping creators trapped in their playground.
But you could also do private caching for a solo user.
Like the VCRs of old people used to skip ads. And later the hard drive equiped variants.
Hopefully someone will make such a service for YouTube if they block adblockers. Worst case, run YouTube in Chrome in a VM and record the screen.
Just think how expensive YouTube would be if artists started demanding royalties for works that match their video fingerprints (in addition to the payouts according to audio fingerprints that YouTube pioneered).
Encoding, moderation, storage, and bandwidth cost money. I'm sure the YouTube financials and margin are posted.
A video streaming service can afford to operate without ads only if: _____.
You understand this if you've ever tried to host (multiply-reencoded) video on a shared hosting service with a bandwidth quota for $10-$20 a month.
https://WebMonetization.org/ is one proposed solution to advertising-supported media.
Maybe I can simplify it for you with this question:
Does Google have the ability to legally compel you to only use chrome?
Im guessing you would say no- Antitrust and whatnot. So the next followup is, Does Google have the ability to tell blind people they cannot use screen readers? Or that people on linux cant browse the site in lynx?
Again, I am guessing the answer is no- Theres anti competitive, antitrust and 230c reasons why. Legally, ad blocking is fine to do. Heres a great article going over it : https://scholarlycommons.law.wlu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?art...
HOWEVER- I disagree with the premise that Youtube cant try to stop adblockers- They just need to do so in a way that doesnt target specifically target a user. Twitch did a system where they would not send the video stream to you until the advertisement was done playing (which was embedded in the feed itself)- So if you blocked the ad somehow, you would just look at a black screen for 15-30 seconds. This, in my opinion would be completely compliant.
Is this really what consumers prefer?
Logged-in users necessarily carry state in some way such that they are identifiable as a logged-in user. "Session cookies" (and 'super cookies' etc) are standard practice for tracking which users are logged in.
YouTube does not and has not required login to view creators' videos and shorts.
And now don't they - just YouTube, hopefully - have to require login for their TOS to be a recognized agreement that authorizes determining whether the user is logged in and not stealing hours of free services.
That they offer an ad-supported service does not entitle us to an ad-free service.
Limiting playback without ads is not beyond the rights of the information service provider.
In other words, the issue is not that YT fights back, it's how they do it.
Are you familiar with keggerator systems with usage quotas? ("Free as in beer")
How can a computerized keggerator system (or a bartender) limit a person to a specific number of drafts from the tap? Is that spyware, or what you agree to when you draw from their kegs?
Google already has a definitive solution: close down the free access under a registration+payment (reasonable one). Why they are still serving free content? Why they don't get the moneys from the viewers directly?
I think that the reason is that they are inflating the number of viewers to everyone (content creator, stakeholders, etc.). You can fake viewers, you can't fake revenue. So, Google wants us to get more advertising so that they can claim that the number of views in ads increased, to earn more.
Isn't this about privacy!? How can free video plays have privacy if login is required to prevent freeloading hours of free service that others pay for?
That would be a significant pivot away from free video that democratizes video, and from video URLs that people share to walled garden video URLs.
Because Google has been monopolistic in their strategy to become the no.1 video platform and crushed alternatives.
This behaviour comes at a cost, pushing alternatives and now forcing adverts on everyone?
I can't do much to stop their monopolistic behavior but I can block adverts.
Isn't Times Square public property? NYC could absolutely make that a thing if they wanted.
> How the heck can you require only Netflix to host 30% local EU content and also demand free video streaming service with no ads?
Nobody's asking to make Netflix free. YouTube could absolutely charge for access if they wanted. Ads aren't the only way to monetize a service.
With that said, I'm generally in agreement that Google has a right to run ads on their platform and to try to block users who are blocking ads. The "spyware" argument seems pretty weak to me.
Does he work for Google? For Youtube? More than a few people here on HN must, right? But there are so many like him, it can't be the explanation all the time. Does he worship big tech companies to the point that if he shills for them, he believes that career success will rain down on him, like some sort of occupational cargo culting thing? Is he some amateur Deviant Art person, who shills for obscene copyright maximalism for similar reasons? Is it just that he does the one sort of 4chan-level shitposting that people can get away with on HackerNews, for the same reason the 4chan people do their thing there (whatever that is)?
It's weird. It's both the one topic you can see that stuff here on, where it isn't wished away to the cornfield. And the people doing it seem confident they can get away with it.
Here's this: "I hate ads. My time is valuable. I want free things. What I do is justifiable. Especially when you consider moral relativism and their practices."
And this: "I hate war, but the corporate media of the 2000s sold it to me and then didn't pay the bill; so we need citizen media."
I don't think we're entitled to free video streaming; maybe because I remember how much it costs to host an .mp4 without HLS on a shared hosting account without nginx-rtmp-module (C and ffmpeg, not yet Rust) and how long it takes to encode video without buying custom hardware video encoding accelerator cards and low-volume ASIC/FPGA TLS load balancer accelerators because now video over HTTPS, and because I don't want to pull media from your MediaGoblin tube site.
I don't support artists suing fans listening from the streets.
Artists are entitled to proceeds from their work if that's how they want to run the show.
I do support paying artists with the audio fingerprinting that YouTube pioneered.
(As an artist and a visual artist - it doesn't matter what kind - I don't want to ruin YouTube with payout demands; but if musical artists are due their cut for their plays, then visual artists are too. No musical artists have yet stood up for the plight of visual artists. Nobody has yet determined how to pay everyone on a production with a smart contract that gives them their fair cut for their contribution to the collaborative ari project.)
It costs money to encode, host, and moderate video, live video, comments, and live chats.
It costs money to stream video.
Good content costs money to create, in an ad hominem-d influencer-affected landscape devoid of critical thinking and media literacy.
Artists don't get paid when you stream for free without ads or premium subscription.
How can we pay artists and content producers and privately bootstrapped infrastructure if the marginal cost of a stream is not offset by the marginal returns of a stream?
Content creators have real costs.
--
Copyleft is my decision as an artist. Open Source is my decision as a developer who can't donate their services to charity.
--
Anti-competitive anti-competition context:
What's not fair, anticompetitively? Tying, Bundling, Exclusive agreements, Price fixing, Colluding cartels (for non-essential commodities), Bribery, Kickbacks, Becoming a lobbyist without waiting a fair amount of time first,
What is fair? Selling to the highest bidder. Approved mergers and acquisitions. Strategies against hostile corporate takeover. Taking the bank's money and your creditworthiness and bootstrapping. Penny-pinching to scale and gain market share. Appeasing shareholders/owners. Charging people when they use hours of free services per week.
That they've agreed to sell their content on a network with ads (which in particular enables low income folks to be fans) does not entitle me to free shtyff from them; though I may also have a justified medical reason for tuning out ads entirely unless they're funny.
If a monopoly uses it's monopolistic powers to squash all competition, then forces model a don't want, then the idea of a free market and my choice in provider is a deliberate illusion.
So no, I'm not entitled to free stuff, but neither are they entitled for me to play by their rules. You're on the web? Great, good luck in the adblocking arms race.
Yes, there's a eu-wide 30% content regulation. No, YouTube adblock detection scripts are/could not be legal because of not having EU competition. YouTube and Netflix are also entirely different, because on Netflix it's always required to pay. Not sure how this helps staying on topic, this thread is about ad blockers.
- A case that was in German media: Bild.de tried to take AdBlockerPlus off the market because of "circumventing complex anti-copyright mechanisms". It took some years & instances, but ABP was now deemed legal. - This case (Ireland) and some concerns in Germany about this are more about privacy (GDPR) and tracking. They are browser fingerprinting and tracking how often you are using the ad blocker. This may or may not be legal. Who knows.
This is nonsense.
They are the gatekeepers to what is effectively a captive market. And they don’t exactly play fair to content creators (professional journalists and amateur video producers), do they?
No, you don't have a right to free service either. Do you pay your other bills while you demand free rendered services from these companies?
Having a disability or similar does not entitle you to an unsubsidized Times Square with no ads.
(NASA is running their own streaming network and competing; it can be done. EU should try to run competing free video streaming businesses before shoving preferred American companies around with anti-competitive claims. EU haven't run a video hosting business that's been prevented from competing by the success, existence, and approved mergers and acquisitions of American media companies; and so EU video hosting businesses haven't and can't have been anti-conpetitively disadvantaged.)
I also run ad blockers for various justifiable reasons; but I don't tell myself that I have a right to free shtuff.
How the heck can you require only Netflix to host 30% local EU content and also demand free video streaming service with no ads?