News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:From Aristocratic to Ordinary: Shifting Modes of Elite Di... by ur-whale on Monday November 13, 2023 @03:37AM (#38248202)
>I have learnt from a historian that when the elites adopt the modes of the plebeians, things go badly wrong.

Interesting theory.

Would you care to provide a couple of historical examples?

Re:From Aristocratic to Ordinary: Shifting Modes of Elite Di... by willsoon on Monday November 13, 2023 @03:44AM (#38248247)
Well, you know. The emperor who fancies himself a music hall singer. What's her name again? There are some things that are common to a decline in an important understanding of history. There are 99, this is one of them.
Re:From Aristocratic to Ordinary: Shifting Modes of Elite Di... by dcx on Monday November 13, 2023 @04:27AM (#38248485)
This is so insightful! What did they believe the main process was, that was causing things to break?

My guesses - this is about (a) inequality reaching a breaking point, where non-elites are starting to reject the social contract, making elite signaling dangerous, and (b) that elites at that moment don't have enough justification for their elevated status (mystification, misrecognition, etc)

Re:From Aristocratic to Ordinary: Shifting Modes of Elite Di... by username332211 on Monday November 13, 2023 @04:55AM (#38248631)
Well, it can't be (a). The inequality in Rome had already reached a breaking point and was completely resolved problem by then.

And by that I mean a revolutionary people's party had replaced a corrupt elected government with a divine monarchy.

(I don't think I need to describe the wonders that did for equality in the Roman state. Archeological record indicates when barbarians conquered Roman lands, the nutrition of the lower classes often improved.)

Re:From Aristocratic to Ordinary: Shifting Modes of Elite Di... by willsoon on Monday November 13, 2023 @06:39AM (#38249148)
Social contract. Every year I pay its passive. Can anyone tell me when the profits will be distributed?
Re:From Aristocratic to Ordinary: Shifting Modes of Elite Di... by r2_pilot on Monday November 13, 2023 @10:01AM (#38250921)
The profits were initially distributed before you were born. Every year more profits are added to the value of society (I assume you are a part of society; if not, I do apologize) because potholes are filled, food is verified safe to eat, electricity is regulated, and generally people leave you and your stuff alone so you can do whatever you want within the bounds of the social contract.
Re:From Aristocratic to Ordinary: Shifting Modes of Elite Di... by dcx on Monday November 13, 2023 @04:11PM (#38255438)
FYI OP is answering my question on what the historian's theory was! (They were downvoted)

This route makes sense to me; I do think the deal has been getting worse and worse lately, and periodic renegotiation is required to keep things running properly.

Re:From Aristocratic to Ordinary: Shifting Modes of Elite Di... by rsynnott on Monday November 13, 2023 @05:35AM (#38248812)
> The emperor who fancies himself a music hall singer.

... Wait, Caligula? That was some four centuries before the Western empire bit the dust, only a few decades after the _creation_ of the empire.

I mean, I know people love blaming absolutely everything for the collapse of the Roman Empire, but delayed action of four centuries feels like pushing it.

Re:From Aristocratic to Ordinary: Shifting Modes of Elite Di... by willsoon on Monday November 13, 2023 @06:36AM (#38249136)
You don't read too much history, do you? Of course I can understand the confusion. Caligula was the guy who started running from sea to sea until he came back with a very long and unrecognisable beard. Also: that was the decline of the Roman Empire. Nothing to do with the other empires that went through the same process.
Re:From Aristocratic to Ordinary: Shifting Modes of Elite Di... by wsgeorge on Monday November 13, 2023 @05:36AM (#38248821)
This was not very helpful, to be honest. From what I gathered, what you mean is that when elites are concerned about showing off their status, by pretending to be non-elite, it means inequality has gotten to a breaking point.

If that's it, then you could've been clearer.