News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Expanse's James S.A. Corey Announces a New Sci-Fi Tri... by alephnerd on Sunday November 12, 2023 @04:55AM (#38238862)
Any advice on how to appreciate the Expanse tv show?

I love backstory and worldbuilding sci-fi the Foundation Trilogy, The Man in the High Castle, For All Mankind, The Silo, The Tick, and Battlestar Galactica, but I can't seem to get immersed with The Expanse despite how much I try.

Is it a work that is better appreciated in the literary form instead of on television? Or did Syfy just jumble the first season?

Re:The Expanse's James S.A. Corey Announces a New Sci-Fi Tri... by southwesterly on Sunday November 12, 2023 @05:03AM (#38238918)
The books are waaaaayyy better. The show I think is good and the first series does have a different flavour to the rest of the series, but if you don’t like it by the end of series one, then it’s probably not for you.

You might like The Gap Series by Stephen R Donaldson though.

Re:The Expanse's James S.A. Corey Announces a New Sci-Fi Tri... by wkat4242 on Sunday November 12, 2023 @06:38PM (#38245284)
I think the first season is the most amazing. Ceres feels so alive.
Re:The Expanse's James S.A. Corey Announces a New Sci-Fi Tri... by oaiey on Sunday November 12, 2023 @05:49AM (#38239121)
You have to make it to episode 4. From that on, you are on a ride.
Re:The Expanse's James S.A. Corey Announces a New Sci-Fi Tri... by redhale on Sunday November 12, 2023 @05:55AM (#38239153)
Ok thank you, maybe I'll try again at some point. I got through episode 2 or 3 two different times and quit. I could not believe how bored I was with the show compared to how much I loved the books.
Re:The Expanse's James S.A. Corey Announces a New Sci-Fi Tri... by oaiey on Sunday November 12, 2023 @12:32PM (#38242272)
They set up the stage. The expanse series is later known for incredible pace and binge watching.
Re:The Expanse's James S.A. Corey Announces a New Sci-Fi Tri... by alephnerd on Sunday November 12, 2023 @10:25AM (#38240913)
I' on episode 8 and it's ok. The production feels a bit "amateur"
Re:The Expanse's James S.A. Corey Announces a New Sci-Fi Tri... by oaiey on Sunday November 12, 2023 @12:33PM (#38242287)
It does not have Star wars Budgets but for the many of us who grew up with 90s sci-fi, this is quite good.
Re:The Expanse's James S.A. Corey Announces a New Sci-Fi Tri... by alephnerd on Sunday November 12, 2023 @12:56PM (#38242488)
I wasn't around for much of the 90s so that explains it.

Also Star Wars sucks imo. Never understood the appeal for that either other than boomer nostalgia.

Re:The Expanse's James S.A. Corey Announces a New Sci-Fi Tri... by soylentcola on Tuesday November 14, 2023 @01:26PM (#38267348)
Don't forget about Gen X nostalgia! We were kids/teens when those came out and they were probably the coolest and most fun movies I'd ever seen for quite a few years.

Are they "deep"? Not at all. But between the adventure, spectacle, and the hints of so much going under the surface/in the past, it was incredibly appealing to young-me and it's hard to forget those feelings - even if the followups were either lacking the special sauce or no longer meant for adult-me. Take your pick. I still love the original 3, nostalgia or not.

Re:The Expanse's James S.A. Corey Announces a New Sci-Fi Tri... by tekla on Sunday November 12, 2023 @10:57AM (#38241268)
Yeah its weird. I watched the Expanse, and while I appreciated the more realistic space physics, I thought everything else sucked. The acting was bad, the CGI backgrounds were incredibly distracting. It was very obvious that everyone was emoting in front of green screens.

When I watch BSG, I believe that the actors are characters in the universe, its the opposite with the Expanse, everyone just feels like actors saying lines.

I was flabbergasted that people loved this show outside of the physics.

Re:The Expanse's James S.A. Corey Announces a New Sci-Fi Tri... by alephnerd on Sunday November 12, 2023 @11:12AM (#38241426)
Yeah.

This is the exact same issue I am grappling with right now!

The first season's production quality just feels very immature.

It's a shame because the writing clearly has legs.

Re:The Expanse's James S.A. Corey Announces a New Sci-Fi Tri... by rockemsockem on Sunday November 12, 2023 @11:46AM (#38241786)
They built one of the largest sets ever to house a full sized rocinante, so there's mostly not CGI backgrounds. Which scenes in particular did you think were bad?
Re:The Expanse's James S.A. Corey Announces a New Sci-Fi Tri... by alephnerd on Sunday November 12, 2023 @01:00PM (#38242522)
For me personally, a lot of the "urban" set designs feel very amateur. It feels and looks like the set in the Community Ham Girl episode.

#WhoIsGlipGlop

Re:The Expanse's James S.A. Corey Announces a New Sci-Fi Tri... by wkat4242 on Sunday November 12, 2023 @06:41PM (#38245304)
Yeah the New York skyline shots could have been a lot better. The futuristic skyscrapers they inserted look a bit fake.

Ps in the book the UN was actually based in the Hague which would have been a much cooler choice for a location IMO.

But I'm Dutch so I may be biased lol.

Re:The Expanse's James S.A. Corey Announces a New Sci-Fi Tri... by md49jn on Sunday November 12, 2023 @12:17PM (#38242128)
I got bored of it 2-3 books in. I can't even remember the names of the books. I think it's an extremely niche audience interested in a coating of space ships and space battles on top of general human drama.
Re:The Expanse's James S.A. Corey Announces a New Sci-Fi Tri... by mcv on Monday November 13, 2023 @07:24AM (#38249410)
The books were based on a roleplaying campaign. The start of the TV series works very well if you see the main characters as PCs in an RPG campaign. There's even the guy who drops out after a few sessions.

I haven't gotten around to reading the books yet, but I love the TV show, and was immediately immersed into the setting. The struggles of the Belters, the tension between Earth and Mars, different politicians on Earth jockeying for position, and our heroes in the middle of it all.

I think the world building is absolutely great. Better than most. But if it doesn't click for you, I have no idea. It's fine to enjoy something else instead.

One issue with the first season: it doesn't wrap up its story. That story arc, from the first book, doesn't end until halfway through season 2. SyFy did mix up some things to introduce some characters a bit earlier than happens in the books. They'll become more relevant later. Season 1 is primarily about Holden's crew and Miller. The people on Earth and Mars will become more important starting in the second half of season 2.