News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Omegle founder shuts down site forever? by joenot443 on Thursday November 09, 2023 @06:34AM (#38203733)
And so now they’ll have to choose one of the other, even seedier bars. The kids aren’t any better off.

You’ve made a poor analogy, though, since obviously it’s very trivial for a bar to validate age at the door. If such a thing were easy for Omegle to do, I’m sure they would.

Re:Omegle founder shuts down site forever? by op00to on Thursday November 09, 2023 @07:25AM (#38204113)
If it’s trivial for a bar to validate, why not the same for a web site?
Re:Omegle founder shuts down site forever? by wizzwizz4 on Thursday November 09, 2023 @08:30AM (#38204745)
With websites, you can have one person serving ten million people, and support that on a single income. With bars, you can only fit about a hundred people in, and enough of them have to be paying customers that you can afford to keep the bar running – but that also means you can physically look at everyone's identification papers.
Re:Omegle founder shuts down site forever? by op00to on Thursday November 09, 2023 @08:35AM (#38204777)
If you can’t validate the age of the people using Omegle, perhaps the service is not appropriate to exist.
Re:Omegle founder shuts down site forever? by malfist on Thursday November 09, 2023 @08:56AM (#38205009)
I think my right to privacy out weighs a "think of the children" argument.
Re:Omegle founder shuts down site forever? by wizzwizz4 on Thursday November 09, 2023 @09:25AM (#38205362)
The anything goes / mass surveillance dichotomy is false. It is possible to have small-scale, individually-moderated websites, if the software to host them is available and easy to run, without sacrificing privacy (or even accountability). Pseudonymity is usually good enough, especially for things like Omegle.

Unfortunately, that requires a return to the days when most people's primary computing device was capable of acting as a web server, and computer literacy implied empowerment: that might be tricky, but if we work hard enough I'm sure we can get there.

Re:Omegle founder shuts down site forever? by malfist on Thursday November 09, 2023 @09:47AM (#38205656)
How do you propose verifying a users age without sacrificing privacy?

Even knowing their age at all is giving up some privacy.

If it can be done at small scale, it will get sold to data brokers and exploited at large a scale

Re:Omegle founder shuts down site forever? by wizzwizz4 on Thursday November 09, 2023 @09:56AM (#38205764)
> How do you propose verifying a users age without sacrificing privacy?

It's usually obvious if you can have a short conversation with the person in question. Throughout my childhood escapades, I'm certain that most, if not all, the responsible adults I interacted with knew pretty much exactly how old I was. (I'd managed to navigate a legal loophole that, I believe, still exists in GDPR today, so they weren't required to kick me off – but while I was treated as an equal, I wasn't treated the same way I'm treated now.)

> If it can be done at small scale, it will get sold to data brokers and exploited at large a scale

That's quite illegal, and quite easy to detect (just give slightly different data to everyone and see what leaks). Most people don't commit crimes: individuals just don't have the kinds of incentive to buy and sell people's personal data that organisations like Facebook, Taboola and Oracle have. (And what would they get for betraying these people's trust? $30? Sure… I'd totally go for that.)

Re:Omegle founder shuts down site forever? by malfist on Thursday November 09, 2023 @04:08PM (#38211343)
How do you propose to give slightly different data to everyone and see what leaks when you have to have a short conversation with the person in question?
Re:Omegle founder shuts down site forever? by o_nate on Thursday November 09, 2023 @01:35PM (#38208934)
Seems like a good opening for a service that could validate your age for a low cost and provide a token good for logging on to adults-only sites.
Re:Omegle founder shuts down site forever? by Blahah on Thursday November 09, 2023 @09:51PM (#38214522)
Because you can't police who is using the device at the other end. You're authenticating a client device, not a person, and that doesn't keep children any safer from abuse - if anything it means they have an incentive to keep their use of a thing secret for fear of punishment, which makes them more vulnerable.
Re:Omegle founder shuts down site forever? by kevindamm on Thursday November 09, 2023 @07:58AM (#38204410)
This bar had a complex tunnel system leading up to it that was completely unlit. In the beginning you could run right through, but eventually they made you yell "I'm over 18" and took your word on it.

This bar also had special partitions in each room that were practically indestructible, allowing sound and light through but protecting from physical harm.

[EDIT: I don't mean to imply that the check is easy! The reality of Omegle's difficulties is understood. I'm just riffing on the metaphor]