Re:You Can Now Film in NYPD Precincts, Thanks to YouTuber's ...
by thrdbndndn on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:51AM
(#38193121)
Just curious, how does the law distinguish "public" part of a public place, and "private" part of it like staff's rooms, evidence rooms etc?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:You Can Now Film in NYPD Precincts, Thanks to YouTuber's ...
by LegitShady on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:01PM
(#38193318)
signs, locked doors, public ability to go into an area. Generally publicly accessible foyers, hallways, are ok.
Re:You Can Now Film in NYPD Precincts, Thanks to YouTuber's ...
by KennyBlanken on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:09PM
(#38193454)
I imagine NYPD's response to this will be to set up every precinct so there is a guard station at the front and you have to give a reason to be let in "for security."
Re:You Can Now Film in NYPD Precincts, Thanks to YouTuber's ...
by DoesntMatter22 on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:24PM
(#38193725)
That is already common and they go in and film anyway. If the public can legally get there they can legally film
Re:You Can Now Film in NYPD Precincts, Thanks to YouTuber's ...
by LegitShady on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:24PM
(#38195587)
i imagine that policy too would be subject to legal challenge, and if placed immediately after this judgement would probably not draw a lot of sympathy from a judge. The issue is that filming in the public foyer/area of a public building IS legitimate business, even protected activity, so the more they do to make that difficult the worse it becomes for them.
Re:You Can Now Film in NYPD Precincts, Thanks to YouTuber's ...
by anonymouskimmer on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @03:01PM
(#38196093)
From the article they have this angle covered too, though I don't know whether the judge specifically ruled on it as well:
> and the NYPD instituted its policy without following the Citywide Administrative Procedure Act, which specifies the steps a City agency must take before it can put a new rule in place.
Re:You Can Now Film in NYPD Precincts, Thanks to YouTuber's ...
by tehwebguy on Thursday November 09, 2023 @05:57AM
(#38203455)
Their response will just be to ignore the order, they don’t care what judges say. NYPD has been revolting against any oversight for years.
Re:You Can Now Film in NYPD Precincts, Thanks to YouTuber's ...
by NoMoreNicksLeft on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:46PM
(#38194082)
Statutory law rarely spells that out, leaving it to judges and case law. My guess is that judges would be pragmatic in such matters, and in those parts of the building where there is no public interest in allowing video recording, they would disallow it.
Likely, those rooms are off limits to the public anyway. And, if I'm not mistaken, as dumb as the public can be, no one's actually attempted to film in those places (though, with the rise of influencers and Youtube and whatnot, maybe we should just be anticipating the coming flood?).