News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by mycroftiv on Monday April 09, 2012 @12:20PM (#3817641)
I was enjoying this essay and "with" the author all the way until he suddenly swerved into imploring everyone to not give their work away for free, in order to preserve the market value of the work of full-time professionals. This kind of argument has been used a lot against free open source software, and I doubt many readers of HN are very sympathetic to it.
Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by MartinCron on Monday April 09, 2012 @12:58PM (#3817818)
I also really hate this argument.

I'm what you call a serious amateur photographer. I make images because I love the process of creating and sharing art. Telling me that I shouldn't ever share my work because it erodes the value of others who have an entirely different motive is borderline price-fixing.

If you, as an established professional, can't compete with hobbyists and newcomers trying to break in, then you might need to find a different business model.

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by Domenic_S on Monday April 09, 2012 @01:25PM (#3818032)
The sentiment on this thread would be really different if instead of an unnamed calendar, the client was Coke running a $3MM international campaign and offering the author $100.

Why is that?

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by mirkules on Monday April 09, 2012 @01:47PM (#3818208)
The discussion is about two different things:

1. The amount of money offered for the author's work

2. Imploring others to not take "lowball" offers in order to preserve a certain pricing/business model.

Regarding #1: Everyone is allowed to make any kind of offer, and the author is free to refuse them, just as he did. Photography is a business, and everyone is trying to make a deal to make a buck. If Coke offered $100, that's their prerogative, and it's up to the author to either haggle up higher, or refuse them flatly.

Personally, I see no reason why the author was so offended -- the emails weren't rude, they weren't demanding, and the email person "L" was almost apologetic for having only $100 to spend. Since I don't know what company this is, we cannot make assumption on why the author thinks they will sell the calendars for $12.99 (although, there are religious undertones, and my suspicion and speculation is that they will not sell these at a huge profit as the author believes)

Regarding #2, that's been covered well. If I want to sell my software at $0.99 per app and it undercuts the competition, great. We saw iOS developers complain that the $0.99 games are undercutting their profits, but it turned out to be a sustainable model. It's not my problem if I give my photos (or product) away for free and undercuts his model.

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by MartinCron on Monday April 09, 2012 @02:52PM (#3818582)
Probably because humans have a sense of perspective and fairness that isn't always in sync with what a purely rational economic actor would do. Just a guess.

Something similar did happen to me. An ad agency found a photo* I had taken and wanted to use it in a campaign. I usually give things away to non-profits, but this was going to be a large-scale thing for a major drug company. I asked what price the person thought was fair and we settled on a reasonable price. Maybe I was lowballed? I don't know and don't really care. It was more than $100, though.

I didn't set a nonzero price just because I wanted to protect other artists ability to make money off of their work, I set a price because I thought it would be cool to have some extra money to buy some new camera gear.

* The picture in question: http://www.flickr.com/photos/martincron/2208026093/in/set-72...

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by sterling312 on Monday April 09, 2012 @01:30PM (#3818074)
This is precisely the problem, and I'm glad you mentioned it. If the cost to produce a calendar-grad image is so cheap that an amateur can produce it, perhaps the force of creative destruction has rendered the traditional photographer to compete on the same ground, perhaps it is time for traditional photographer to reconsider the service they are providing.
Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by aklemm on Monday April 09, 2012 @03:38PM (#3818810)
So true. The photographers need to get into the calendar making business or some other value-add beyond simply creating images.
Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by wicknicks on Monday April 09, 2012 @01:57PM (#3818278)
I agree with you. But this shows the culture in fields different from ours. What the photography area is witnessing is what we saw when free software came about. Smart photographers are using this to their advantage, whereas others are cribbing about it.

I wonder how hard it would be to negotiate a deal where the photos are given for free, but with a caption or footnote pointing to the photographer's website. That would make the calendar the best advertisement he has had in years. People are going to be staring at his photos all year long!

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by underwater on Monday April 09, 2012 @02:55PM (#3818595)
And those who see the credit will contact the photographer and ask if they can use his work for free "because it will give him exposure." If everyone did this then the photographer would never be paid.
Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by MartinCron on Monday April 09, 2012 @03:30PM (#3818766)
And if that happens and the entire market for professional photographers collapses, it's not a big deal. If there's no market for a service, that service doesn't have a right to exist.

The way to succeed in the marketplace is to make something distinctive worth paying for, not to lash out at other people who give stuff away for free.

Also, a simple "image credit: Person X" doesn't have to imply that the work was done for free. A potential client doesn't need to know how much previous portfolio pieces cost.

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by ArtB on Monday April 09, 2012 @04:26PM (#3819050)
Except that it was a viable career and now you have feel that were earning a living finding their skills useless economically. Next thing you know their skills are just as marketable as a highschool drop-outs. I think one of the great problems of this age is that skills and wages fluctuate too wildly to make long-term plans like our parents did. I'll take more inefficiency for more stability any old day.
Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by MartinCron on Monday April 09, 2012 @04:52PM (#3819172)
I'll take more inefficiency for more stability any old day.

As would all of the newspaper classified ad salespeople, VHS tape manufacturers, blacksmiths, haberdashers, etc.

I see where you're coming from, and it's a valid perspective, although I don't know how realistic it is. All of the attempts to stabilize skills/wages seem to lead to guilds/cartels which keep prices artificially high and harm innovation.

If anything, this economic reality makes the case for a strong social safety net. If someone's livelihood is profoundly disrupted by technology, they should be given a meaningful opportunity to retrain and/or pivot onto something workable without suffering complete and total financial (or physical, in the case of losing one's health care) ruin.

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by ilkandi on Monday April 09, 2012 @06:20PM (#3819550)
It takes a long time to accumulate enough knowledge to get the pattern recognition and competent creativity to be an expert in any field. Brains have speed limits. It'd be nice if the valuation of the field lasted long enough to make it worth acquiring and increasing that knowledge. Fun thought; what's it like to compete directly against 7 billion people? Do all specialized skills become close to worthless if you're not part of a restrictive "guild" (bar exams, medical board exams, etc) or part of a corporation?
Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by tomjen3 on Monday April 09, 2012 @05:38PM (#3819379)
Well that is, naturally your choice, just as long as you don't try to force this on others.

You see I am pissed that I don't have my flying care and robotic servant already. I want progress and will take whatever stability that is necessary to do that.

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by wicknicks on Monday April 09, 2012 @03:21PM (#3818724)
Not so sure about that. As people on the thread commented, the popularity could lead to better contracts. For example, wedding photographers get paid quite well. If there are so many "free" contracts, that itself is a valid reason to start charging for the next one: I won't do your work, unless you pay me -- sorry, I have too many requests, and need to prioritize.
Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by MartinCron on Monday April 09, 2012 @02:43PM (#3818533)
I wonder how hard it would be to negotiate a deal where the photos are given for free, but with a caption or footnote pointing to the photographer's website.

That's basically how one of the Creative Commons licenses works. It's a valid choice for photographers, but not the only choice.

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by tomjen3 on Monday April 09, 2012 @05:41PM (#3819395)
That may be true now, but if the commercial value of these photographs asymptotically approach zero (or close enough for us) then that may be all they are worth -- the choice becomes credit or nothing at all.

And at that time the photographers would properly choose credits over nothing at all.

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by bartonfink on Monday April 09, 2012 @06:25PM (#3819569)
They'd properly choose another job.
Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by tomjen3 on Monday April 09, 2012 @05:35PM (#3819361)
Just so you don't feel like you have to apologize for your self, preventing you from sharing your work at whatever price you feel fair isn't borderline price fixing -- it is absolutely price fixing.
Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by MartinCron on Monday April 09, 2012 @05:52PM (#3819444)
Fair enough. I injected the "borderline" qualifier in there because it hasn't proven to be an effective strategy at price fixing.

I just pictured a violent "photographer's guild" gang, riding across the countryside on their penny-farthing bicycles in matching vests and destroying the cameras and/or memory cards of those who would dare try to undercut them.

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by tjr on Monday April 09, 2012 @06:55PM (#3819719)
I think the penny-farthing-bicycle-riding, vest-wearing photographer's guild sorts of people mostly still destroy film rather than memory cards.
Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by sp332 on Monday April 09, 2012 @12:40PM (#3817734)
There is a good point in artist circles, that you should never do free work "for exposure". Doing work for exposure is a great way to get more work... for exposure. But I agree he went a bit overboard on this one.

Edit: just for those who don't remember, here's the epic Bill Gates incident from the dawn of the software industry: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Letter_to_Hobbyists

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by MartinCron on Monday April 09, 2012 @02:55PM (#3818598)
You should only do free work "for exposure" if you want to do free work for exposure. Artists should have a realistic expectation of what value they'll get in exchange for their work, but the "never do it for exposure" advice feels a little one-size-fits-all.

The Bill Gates thing is a bit different. He was explicitly selling copyrighted works and other people were copying and/or re-selling that. He never tried to discourage people from making their own software and giving it away for free.

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by timwiseman on Monday April 09, 2012 @01:15PM (#3817936)
I do not think this follows. Linus Torvalds got well-paying work because of his free work on Linux. Of course, Torvalds is an outlier, but Cory Doctorow also does this.

It makes sense that the best way to get work in certain fields is to have a reputation. Sometimes the best way to get that reputation is to give away a certain portion of your work.

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by sp332 on Monday April 09, 2012 @01:29PM (#3818069)
Right, Torvalds started writing free software for a hobby. But then he got hired to work for a company. He didn't work for some company for free, hoping that some other company would hire him. There's a difference between doing whatever you want for free vs. working for a company for free.
Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by MartinCron on Monday April 09, 2012 @03:18PM (#3818702)
Three simple scenarios.

Bill Gates Selling software = great!

Linus Torvalds giving software away = great!

Bill Gates (or anyone) telling Linus Torvalds (or anyone) not to give software away for free = lame!

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by wtvanhest on Monday April 09, 2012 @01:09PM (#3817897)
So I implore you to think twice about your actions the next time you are approached with a similar deal. Don’t help to erode the market for high-quality artwork just because you’re not relying on that market to feed yourself.

Just because someone chooses to make a fun activity in to a job does not mean that person deserves to get paid for it. If they are not delivering economic value, they don't get paid. I cannot go in to my office and decide that I would rather sit around talking to people than putting in real work which adds value and expect to make my salary.

There are types of photography that do pay OK, mainly wedding and event photography. The reason they pay more is because the photographer needs to be contracted to capture a specific image at a specific time. If you decide to be a landscape artist you are competing with every image made ever. This is not a good competitive position to be in and why people will give away their work for free.

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by eli_gottlieb on Monday April 09, 2012 @03:41PM (#3818827)
This is true only if you equate "value" with "property", rivalrous and excludable private goods.
Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by wtvanhest on Monday April 09, 2012 @03:47PM (#3818857)
For those not aware, Eli_gottlieb is referring to this 2X2 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_good

Photos are Rivalrous and Excludable as long as the photographer protects them by not posting full sized images or using watermarks. (see iStockphoto).

I do associate value with that property, but that property is limited in value, not due to it not being rivalrous and excludable, but rather because of substitutes.

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by jonnathanson on Monday April 09, 2012 @02:09PM (#3818344)
The truth, as with many things, probably falls somewhere between the author's stance and yours. The rise of "free" simply represents a new dynamic in the market for artistic works. To be fair, it is a dynamic that places downward pressure on prices, and that's not necessarily great for most artists. But it's a dynamic that the market has created and is absorbing, and so artists must come to terms with it.

As an artist, you now have to think very carefully about how to price your work. If you believe your work is of exceptional quality, then by all means, price above the market. Likewise, if you believe your work appeals very specifically to a segment that's willing to pay X price, then go with X price and target that niche. If, on the other hand, your work is fairly generic, of average quality, or generally nothing special to any special groups of people, then making a living as an artist is going to be tough for you. Your choices are to price it to market (which may be $0), or differentiate substantially (enough to bear a nonzero price).

Practically speaking, moral arguments on either side are somewhat irrelevant. Instead, what matters is the artist's positioning relative to everyone else. Today, more than ever, you'll have to make yourself special -- or specialized -- if you want to earn a decent living.

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by eroded on Monday April 09, 2012 @12:33PM (#3817703)
Indeed. I'm always surprised how many people believe they should be paid proportional to the amount of time and money that went into their product, regardless of demand. Their work is worth whatever the market will bear.
Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by underwater on Monday April 09, 2012 @03:01PM (#3818621)
That's a good point. This is the equivalent of a customer asking a small time developer to give away their proprietary product for free because there are competing open source products. The developer can either rage against open source or change their business model.

The photographer can do the same by either a) take photos amateurs can't or won't take or b) take photos to order.

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by Domenic_S on Monday April 09, 2012 @01:21PM (#3818003)
> This kind of argument has been used a lot against free open source software, and I doubt many readers of HN are very sympathetic to it.

FOSS is a foot in the door -- how many of us get consulting contracts or even FT jobs implementing or managing that FOSS? FOSS doesn't run itself, unlike a photo that anyone can ship over to snapfish or uprint.

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by joshcrews on Monday April 09, 2012 @12:50PM (#3817777)
Open Source work for free AND not giving away photographs 'for exposure' to for-profit businesses are both allowed in the the Should I do this for Free? flowchart

http://shouldiworkforfree.com/clean.html

Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by MartinCron on Monday April 09, 2012 @01:01PM (#3817839)
I don't think you interpreting that chart the same way I am.
Re:A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone by olalonde on Monday April 09, 2012 @09:03PM (#3820158)
This was discussed at length here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3451145